Stoichiometric constraints on food-web dynamics: A whole-lake experiment on the Canadian Shield

James Elser, Thomas H. Chrzanowski, Robert W. Sterner, Kenneth H. Mills

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

107 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

A whole-lake manipulation of food-web structure (introduction of a top predator, northern pike, to a minnow-dominated lake) was performed in a Canadian Shield lake (L110) to examine the stoichiometric consequences of changes in planktonic community structure generated by altered food-web structure. Minnow abundance, zooplankton biomass and community composition, microconsumer abundance, and concentration and carbon-phosphorus (C:P) ratio of suspended particulate matter were monitored in L110 and unmanipulated L240 before (1992) and after (1993-95) pike introduction. Algal biomass in L110 determined from microscopic examination for postmanipulation and premanipulation periods was also compared with dynamics in a suite of unmanipulated reference lakes from long-term monitoring records. Pike were added in spring in 1993 and 1994 in sufficient quantity to raise pike biomass to levels of around 22 kg ha-1 by 1994. Minnow populations in L110 responded dramatically, decreasing to levels 30% (1993), 10% (1994), and less than 1% (1995) of premanipulation values. However, most components lower in the food web did not respond in a manner consistent with predictions of existing food-web theory, such as the idea of cascading trophic interactions (CTI). While Daphnia biomass increased in L110 in the first year following manipulation, consistent with CTI, this effect was temporary and Daphnia collapsed in 1995, the year of lowest minnow abundance. Total zooplankton biomass in both lakes declined during the study period and, contrary to CTI, this decline appeared somewhat stronger in L110 than in L240. Dominant microconsumers (heterotrophic microflagellates) did not differ among years in either lake and did not appear to respond to food-web manipulation. At the bottom of the food web, no changes in bacterial biomass occurred in either lake. However, total concentrations of particulate matter appeared to increase in L110 after manipulation (contrary to expectations based on the theory of CTI) while algal biomass did not change in the manipulated lake relative to reference systems. Finally, particulate C:P increased in both L110 and L240 during the study period. The lack of strong response of Daphnia, the lack of response of the microbial food web, decreases in zooplankton biomass and increases in particulate biomass following reduction of minnow populations after piscivore introduction are at odds with expectations from existing food-web theory, such as the idea of CTI as currently formulated. However, the extremely high C:P ratios in particulate matter at the base of the food webs in these lakes, the coincidence of zooplankton declines and increases in particulate C:P ratios, and the results of small-scale mesocosm food-quality experiments are consistent with a hypothesis of a stoichiometric constraint operating on food-web dynamics in this and similar ecosystems.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)120-136
Number of pages17
JournalEcosystems
Volume1
Issue number1
StatePublished - 1998

Fingerprint

food webs
Lakes
food web
shield
Biomass
lakes
minnows
trophic interaction
lake
biomass
particulates
experiment
Experiments
pike
Phosphorus
zooplankton
Particulate Matter
Daphnia
Carbon
phosphorus

Keywords

  • Carbon
  • Cascading trophic interactions
  • Ecological stoichiometry
  • Ecosystem experimentation
  • Food quality
  • Food webs
  • Nutrient cycling
  • Phosphorus
  • Plankton

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology

Cite this

Elser, J., Chrzanowski, T. H., Sterner, R. W., & Mills, K. H. (1998). Stoichiometric constraints on food-web dynamics: A whole-lake experiment on the Canadian Shield. Ecosystems, 1(1), 120-136.

Stoichiometric constraints on food-web dynamics : A whole-lake experiment on the Canadian Shield. / Elser, James; Chrzanowski, Thomas H.; Sterner, Robert W.; Mills, Kenneth H.

In: Ecosystems, Vol. 1, No. 1, 1998, p. 120-136.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Elser, J, Chrzanowski, TH, Sterner, RW & Mills, KH 1998, 'Stoichiometric constraints on food-web dynamics: A whole-lake experiment on the Canadian Shield', Ecosystems, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 120-136.
Elser, James ; Chrzanowski, Thomas H. ; Sterner, Robert W. ; Mills, Kenneth H. / Stoichiometric constraints on food-web dynamics : A whole-lake experiment on the Canadian Shield. In: Ecosystems. 1998 ; Vol. 1, No. 1. pp. 120-136.
@article{420e100c0db949d299afe56312db5155,
title = "Stoichiometric constraints on food-web dynamics: A whole-lake experiment on the Canadian Shield",
abstract = "A whole-lake manipulation of food-web structure (introduction of a top predator, northern pike, to a minnow-dominated lake) was performed in a Canadian Shield lake (L110) to examine the stoichiometric consequences of changes in planktonic community structure generated by altered food-web structure. Minnow abundance, zooplankton biomass and community composition, microconsumer abundance, and concentration and carbon-phosphorus (C:P) ratio of suspended particulate matter were monitored in L110 and unmanipulated L240 before (1992) and after (1993-95) pike introduction. Algal biomass in L110 determined from microscopic examination for postmanipulation and premanipulation periods was also compared with dynamics in a suite of unmanipulated reference lakes from long-term monitoring records. Pike were added in spring in 1993 and 1994 in sufficient quantity to raise pike biomass to levels of around 22 kg ha-1 by 1994. Minnow populations in L110 responded dramatically, decreasing to levels 30{\%} (1993), 10{\%} (1994), and less than 1{\%} (1995) of premanipulation values. However, most components lower in the food web did not respond in a manner consistent with predictions of existing food-web theory, such as the idea of cascading trophic interactions (CTI). While Daphnia biomass increased in L110 in the first year following manipulation, consistent with CTI, this effect was temporary and Daphnia collapsed in 1995, the year of lowest minnow abundance. Total zooplankton biomass in both lakes declined during the study period and, contrary to CTI, this decline appeared somewhat stronger in L110 than in L240. Dominant microconsumers (heterotrophic microflagellates) did not differ among years in either lake and did not appear to respond to food-web manipulation. At the bottom of the food web, no changes in bacterial biomass occurred in either lake. However, total concentrations of particulate matter appeared to increase in L110 after manipulation (contrary to expectations based on the theory of CTI) while algal biomass did not change in the manipulated lake relative to reference systems. Finally, particulate C:P increased in both L110 and L240 during the study period. The lack of strong response of Daphnia, the lack of response of the microbial food web, decreases in zooplankton biomass and increases in particulate biomass following reduction of minnow populations after piscivore introduction are at odds with expectations from existing food-web theory, such as the idea of CTI as currently formulated. However, the extremely high C:P ratios in particulate matter at the base of the food webs in these lakes, the coincidence of zooplankton declines and increases in particulate C:P ratios, and the results of small-scale mesocosm food-quality experiments are consistent with a hypothesis of a stoichiometric constraint operating on food-web dynamics in this and similar ecosystems.",
keywords = "Carbon, Cascading trophic interactions, Ecological stoichiometry, Ecosystem experimentation, Food quality, Food webs, Nutrient cycling, Phosphorus, Plankton",
author = "James Elser and Chrzanowski, {Thomas H.} and Sterner, {Robert W.} and Mills, {Kenneth H.}",
year = "1998",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "1",
pages = "120--136",
journal = "Ecosystems",
issn = "1432-9840",
publisher = "Springer New York",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Stoichiometric constraints on food-web dynamics

T2 - A whole-lake experiment on the Canadian Shield

AU - Elser, James

AU - Chrzanowski, Thomas H.

AU - Sterner, Robert W.

AU - Mills, Kenneth H.

PY - 1998

Y1 - 1998

N2 - A whole-lake manipulation of food-web structure (introduction of a top predator, northern pike, to a minnow-dominated lake) was performed in a Canadian Shield lake (L110) to examine the stoichiometric consequences of changes in planktonic community structure generated by altered food-web structure. Minnow abundance, zooplankton biomass and community composition, microconsumer abundance, and concentration and carbon-phosphorus (C:P) ratio of suspended particulate matter were monitored in L110 and unmanipulated L240 before (1992) and after (1993-95) pike introduction. Algal biomass in L110 determined from microscopic examination for postmanipulation and premanipulation periods was also compared with dynamics in a suite of unmanipulated reference lakes from long-term monitoring records. Pike were added in spring in 1993 and 1994 in sufficient quantity to raise pike biomass to levels of around 22 kg ha-1 by 1994. Minnow populations in L110 responded dramatically, decreasing to levels 30% (1993), 10% (1994), and less than 1% (1995) of premanipulation values. However, most components lower in the food web did not respond in a manner consistent with predictions of existing food-web theory, such as the idea of cascading trophic interactions (CTI). While Daphnia biomass increased in L110 in the first year following manipulation, consistent with CTI, this effect was temporary and Daphnia collapsed in 1995, the year of lowest minnow abundance. Total zooplankton biomass in both lakes declined during the study period and, contrary to CTI, this decline appeared somewhat stronger in L110 than in L240. Dominant microconsumers (heterotrophic microflagellates) did not differ among years in either lake and did not appear to respond to food-web manipulation. At the bottom of the food web, no changes in bacterial biomass occurred in either lake. However, total concentrations of particulate matter appeared to increase in L110 after manipulation (contrary to expectations based on the theory of CTI) while algal biomass did not change in the manipulated lake relative to reference systems. Finally, particulate C:P increased in both L110 and L240 during the study period. The lack of strong response of Daphnia, the lack of response of the microbial food web, decreases in zooplankton biomass and increases in particulate biomass following reduction of minnow populations after piscivore introduction are at odds with expectations from existing food-web theory, such as the idea of CTI as currently formulated. However, the extremely high C:P ratios in particulate matter at the base of the food webs in these lakes, the coincidence of zooplankton declines and increases in particulate C:P ratios, and the results of small-scale mesocosm food-quality experiments are consistent with a hypothesis of a stoichiometric constraint operating on food-web dynamics in this and similar ecosystems.

AB - A whole-lake manipulation of food-web structure (introduction of a top predator, northern pike, to a minnow-dominated lake) was performed in a Canadian Shield lake (L110) to examine the stoichiometric consequences of changes in planktonic community structure generated by altered food-web structure. Minnow abundance, zooplankton biomass and community composition, microconsumer abundance, and concentration and carbon-phosphorus (C:P) ratio of suspended particulate matter were monitored in L110 and unmanipulated L240 before (1992) and after (1993-95) pike introduction. Algal biomass in L110 determined from microscopic examination for postmanipulation and premanipulation periods was also compared with dynamics in a suite of unmanipulated reference lakes from long-term monitoring records. Pike were added in spring in 1993 and 1994 in sufficient quantity to raise pike biomass to levels of around 22 kg ha-1 by 1994. Minnow populations in L110 responded dramatically, decreasing to levels 30% (1993), 10% (1994), and less than 1% (1995) of premanipulation values. However, most components lower in the food web did not respond in a manner consistent with predictions of existing food-web theory, such as the idea of cascading trophic interactions (CTI). While Daphnia biomass increased in L110 in the first year following manipulation, consistent with CTI, this effect was temporary and Daphnia collapsed in 1995, the year of lowest minnow abundance. Total zooplankton biomass in both lakes declined during the study period and, contrary to CTI, this decline appeared somewhat stronger in L110 than in L240. Dominant microconsumers (heterotrophic microflagellates) did not differ among years in either lake and did not appear to respond to food-web manipulation. At the bottom of the food web, no changes in bacterial biomass occurred in either lake. However, total concentrations of particulate matter appeared to increase in L110 after manipulation (contrary to expectations based on the theory of CTI) while algal biomass did not change in the manipulated lake relative to reference systems. Finally, particulate C:P increased in both L110 and L240 during the study period. The lack of strong response of Daphnia, the lack of response of the microbial food web, decreases in zooplankton biomass and increases in particulate biomass following reduction of minnow populations after piscivore introduction are at odds with expectations from existing food-web theory, such as the idea of CTI as currently formulated. However, the extremely high C:P ratios in particulate matter at the base of the food webs in these lakes, the coincidence of zooplankton declines and increases in particulate C:P ratios, and the results of small-scale mesocosm food-quality experiments are consistent with a hypothesis of a stoichiometric constraint operating on food-web dynamics in this and similar ecosystems.

KW - Carbon

KW - Cascading trophic interactions

KW - Ecological stoichiometry

KW - Ecosystem experimentation

KW - Food quality

KW - Food webs

KW - Nutrient cycling

KW - Phosphorus

KW - Plankton

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0000960249&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0000960249&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:0000960249

VL - 1

SP - 120

EP - 136

JO - Ecosystems

JF - Ecosystems

SN - 1432-9840

IS - 1

ER -