Mass distribution and planet formation in the solar nebula

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

110 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The surface density profile Σ(r) of the solar nebula protoplanetary disk is a fundamental input to all models of disk processes and evolution. Traditionally it is estimated by spreading out the augmented masses of the planets over the annuli in which the planets orbit today, the so-called minimum-mass solar nebula. Doing so implicitly assumes that the planets completely accreted all planetesimals in their feeding zones, but this assumption has not been tested. Indeed, models of the growth of Uranus and Neptune predict that these planets could not have grown to ∼10 M within the lifetime of the disk, even though they must have, to accrete H/He atmospheres. In this paper we adopt the starting positions of the planets in the "Nice" model of planetary dynamics (Tsiganis and coworkers), in which the solar system started in a much more compact configuration. We derive a surface density profile that is well approximated by the power law Σ(r) = 343(fp/0.5)-1(r/10 AU) -2.168 g cm-2, where fp is the fraction of the solid mass in the form of planetesimals. We show that this profile is inconsistent with a steady state accretion disk but is consistent with a steady state decretion disk that is being photoevaporated. We calculate the growth of planets in the context of this disk model and demonstrate for the first time that all of the giant planets can achieve their isolation masses and begin to accrete H/He atmospheres within the lifetime of the disk. The fit of our inferred Σ(r) to the augmented masses of the planets is excellent (<10%), but only if Uranus and Neptune swtiched places early in the solar system's evolution, a possibility predicted by the Nice model.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)878-893
Number of pages16
JournalAstrophysical Journal
Volume671
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 10 2007

Fingerprint

solar nebula
mass distribution
planets
planet
Uranus (planet)
Uranus
Neptune (planet)
protoplanets
Neptune
planetesimal
solar system
solar system evolution
profiles
atmospheres
life (durability)
protoplanetary disks
distribution
atmosphere
annuli
accretion disks

Keywords

  • Kuiper belt
  • Oort cloud
  • Planetary systems: protoplanetary disks
  • Solar system: formation
  • Stars: formation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Space and Planetary Science

Cite this

Mass distribution and planet formation in the solar nebula. / Desch, Steven.

In: Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 671, No. 1, 10.12.2007, p. 878-893.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{f82abeea94614afcb2d12c78f1de1e45,
title = "Mass distribution and planet formation in the solar nebula",
abstract = "The surface density profile Σ(r) of the solar nebula protoplanetary disk is a fundamental input to all models of disk processes and evolution. Traditionally it is estimated by spreading out the augmented masses of the planets over the annuli in which the planets orbit today, the so-called minimum-mass solar nebula. Doing so implicitly assumes that the planets completely accreted all planetesimals in their feeding zones, but this assumption has not been tested. Indeed, models of the growth of Uranus and Neptune predict that these planets could not have grown to ∼10 M ⊖ within the lifetime of the disk, even though they must have, to accrete H/He atmospheres. In this paper we adopt the starting positions of the planets in the {"}Nice{"} model of planetary dynamics (Tsiganis and coworkers), in which the solar system started in a much more compact configuration. We derive a surface density profile that is well approximated by the power law Σ(r) = 343(fp/0.5)-1(r/10 AU) -2.168 g cm-2, where fp is the fraction of the solid mass in the form of planetesimals. We show that this profile is inconsistent with a steady state accretion disk but is consistent with a steady state decretion disk that is being photoevaporated. We calculate the growth of planets in the context of this disk model and demonstrate for the first time that all of the giant planets can achieve their isolation masses and begin to accrete H/He atmospheres within the lifetime of the disk. The fit of our inferred Σ(r) to the augmented masses of the planets is excellent (<10{\%}), but only if Uranus and Neptune swtiched places early in the solar system's evolution, a possibility predicted by the Nice model.",
keywords = "Kuiper belt, Oort cloud, Planetary systems: protoplanetary disks, Solar system: formation, Stars: formation",
author = "Steven Desch",
year = "2007",
month = "12",
day = "10",
doi = "10.1086/522825",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "671",
pages = "878--893",
journal = "Astrophysical Journal",
issn = "0004-637X",
publisher = "IOP Publishing Ltd.",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Mass distribution and planet formation in the solar nebula

AU - Desch, Steven

PY - 2007/12/10

Y1 - 2007/12/10

N2 - The surface density profile Σ(r) of the solar nebula protoplanetary disk is a fundamental input to all models of disk processes and evolution. Traditionally it is estimated by spreading out the augmented masses of the planets over the annuli in which the planets orbit today, the so-called minimum-mass solar nebula. Doing so implicitly assumes that the planets completely accreted all planetesimals in their feeding zones, but this assumption has not been tested. Indeed, models of the growth of Uranus and Neptune predict that these planets could not have grown to ∼10 M ⊖ within the lifetime of the disk, even though they must have, to accrete H/He atmospheres. In this paper we adopt the starting positions of the planets in the "Nice" model of planetary dynamics (Tsiganis and coworkers), in which the solar system started in a much more compact configuration. We derive a surface density profile that is well approximated by the power law Σ(r) = 343(fp/0.5)-1(r/10 AU) -2.168 g cm-2, where fp is the fraction of the solid mass in the form of planetesimals. We show that this profile is inconsistent with a steady state accretion disk but is consistent with a steady state decretion disk that is being photoevaporated. We calculate the growth of planets in the context of this disk model and demonstrate for the first time that all of the giant planets can achieve their isolation masses and begin to accrete H/He atmospheres within the lifetime of the disk. The fit of our inferred Σ(r) to the augmented masses of the planets is excellent (<10%), but only if Uranus and Neptune swtiched places early in the solar system's evolution, a possibility predicted by the Nice model.

AB - The surface density profile Σ(r) of the solar nebula protoplanetary disk is a fundamental input to all models of disk processes and evolution. Traditionally it is estimated by spreading out the augmented masses of the planets over the annuli in which the planets orbit today, the so-called minimum-mass solar nebula. Doing so implicitly assumes that the planets completely accreted all planetesimals in their feeding zones, but this assumption has not been tested. Indeed, models of the growth of Uranus and Neptune predict that these planets could not have grown to ∼10 M ⊖ within the lifetime of the disk, even though they must have, to accrete H/He atmospheres. In this paper we adopt the starting positions of the planets in the "Nice" model of planetary dynamics (Tsiganis and coworkers), in which the solar system started in a much more compact configuration. We derive a surface density profile that is well approximated by the power law Σ(r) = 343(fp/0.5)-1(r/10 AU) -2.168 g cm-2, where fp is the fraction of the solid mass in the form of planetesimals. We show that this profile is inconsistent with a steady state accretion disk but is consistent with a steady state decretion disk that is being photoevaporated. We calculate the growth of planets in the context of this disk model and demonstrate for the first time that all of the giant planets can achieve their isolation masses and begin to accrete H/He atmospheres within the lifetime of the disk. The fit of our inferred Σ(r) to the augmented masses of the planets is excellent (<10%), but only if Uranus and Neptune swtiched places early in the solar system's evolution, a possibility predicted by the Nice model.

KW - Kuiper belt

KW - Oort cloud

KW - Planetary systems: protoplanetary disks

KW - Solar system: formation

KW - Stars: formation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=40249089802&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=40249089802&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1086/522825

DO - 10.1086/522825

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:40249089802

VL - 671

SP - 878

EP - 893

JO - Astrophysical Journal

JF - Astrophysical Journal

SN - 0004-637X

IS - 1

ER -