Irrelevant-action imitation is short-term and contextual: Evidence from two under-studied populations

Michelle A. Kline, Matthew M. Gervais, Cristina Moya, Robert T. Boyd

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Across the lifespan and across populations, humans ‘overimitate’ causally unnecessary behaviors. Such irrelevant-action imitation facilitates faithful cultural transmission, but its immediate benefits to the imitator are controversial. Over short time scales, irrelevant-action imitation may bootstrap artifact exploration or interpersonal affiliation, and over longer time scales it may facilitate acquisition of either causal models or social conventions. To investigate these putative functions, we recruited community samples from two under-studied populations: Yasawa, Fiji, and Huatasani, Peru. We use a two-action puzzle box: first after a video demonstration, and again one month later. Treating age as a continuous variable, we reveal divergent developmental trajectories across sites. Yasawans (44 adults, M = 39.9 years, 23 women; 42 children, M = 9.8 years, 26 girls) resemble documented patterns, with irrelevant-action imitation increasing across childhood and plateauing in adulthood. In contrast, Huatasaneños (48 adults, M = 37.6 years, 33 women; 47 children, M = 9.3 years, 13 girls) evince a parabolic trajectory: adults at the site show the lowest irrelevant-action imitation of any demographic set in our sample. In addition, all age sets in both populations reduce their irrelevant actions at Time 2, but do not reduce their relevant-action imitation or goal attainment. Taken together, and considering the local cultural contexts, our results suggest that irrelevant-action imitation serves a short-term function and is sensitive to the social context of the demonstration.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article numbere12903
JournalDevelopmental Science
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

Population
Fiji
Peru
Artifacts
Demography

Keywords

  • culture and development
  • overimitation
  • social learning

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Developmental and Educational Psychology
  • Cognitive Neuroscience

Cite this

Irrelevant-action imitation is short-term and contextual : Evidence from two under-studied populations. / Kline, Michelle A.; Gervais, Matthew M.; Moya, Cristina; Boyd, Robert T.

In: Developmental Science, 01.01.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{ba79b8f76fb44557aebdcf255b15ea21,
title = "Irrelevant-action imitation is short-term and contextual: Evidence from two under-studied populations",
abstract = "Across the lifespan and across populations, humans ‘overimitate’ causally unnecessary behaviors. Such irrelevant-action imitation facilitates faithful cultural transmission, but its immediate benefits to the imitator are controversial. Over short time scales, irrelevant-action imitation may bootstrap artifact exploration or interpersonal affiliation, and over longer time scales it may facilitate acquisition of either causal models or social conventions. To investigate these putative functions, we recruited community samples from two under-studied populations: Yasawa, Fiji, and Huatasani, Peru. We use a two-action puzzle box: first after a video demonstration, and again one month later. Treating age as a continuous variable, we reveal divergent developmental trajectories across sites. Yasawans (44 adults, M = 39.9 years, 23 women; 42 children, M = 9.8 years, 26 girls) resemble documented patterns, with irrelevant-action imitation increasing across childhood and plateauing in adulthood. In contrast, Huatasane{\~n}os (48 adults, M = 37.6 years, 33 women; 47 children, M = 9.3 years, 13 girls) evince a parabolic trajectory: adults at the site show the lowest irrelevant-action imitation of any demographic set in our sample. In addition, all age sets in both populations reduce their irrelevant actions at Time 2, but do not reduce their relevant-action imitation or goal attainment. Taken together, and considering the local cultural contexts, our results suggest that irrelevant-action imitation serves a short-term function and is sensitive to the social context of the demonstration.",
keywords = "culture and development, overimitation, social learning",
author = "Kline, {Michelle A.} and Gervais, {Matthew M.} and Cristina Moya and Boyd, {Robert T.}",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/desc.12903",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Developmental Science",
issn = "1363-755X",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Irrelevant-action imitation is short-term and contextual

T2 - Evidence from two under-studied populations

AU - Kline, Michelle A.

AU - Gervais, Matthew M.

AU - Moya, Cristina

AU - Boyd, Robert T.

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Across the lifespan and across populations, humans ‘overimitate’ causally unnecessary behaviors. Such irrelevant-action imitation facilitates faithful cultural transmission, but its immediate benefits to the imitator are controversial. Over short time scales, irrelevant-action imitation may bootstrap artifact exploration or interpersonal affiliation, and over longer time scales it may facilitate acquisition of either causal models or social conventions. To investigate these putative functions, we recruited community samples from two under-studied populations: Yasawa, Fiji, and Huatasani, Peru. We use a two-action puzzle box: first after a video demonstration, and again one month later. Treating age as a continuous variable, we reveal divergent developmental trajectories across sites. Yasawans (44 adults, M = 39.9 years, 23 women; 42 children, M = 9.8 years, 26 girls) resemble documented patterns, with irrelevant-action imitation increasing across childhood and plateauing in adulthood. In contrast, Huatasaneños (48 adults, M = 37.6 years, 33 women; 47 children, M = 9.3 years, 13 girls) evince a parabolic trajectory: adults at the site show the lowest irrelevant-action imitation of any demographic set in our sample. In addition, all age sets in both populations reduce their irrelevant actions at Time 2, but do not reduce their relevant-action imitation or goal attainment. Taken together, and considering the local cultural contexts, our results suggest that irrelevant-action imitation serves a short-term function and is sensitive to the social context of the demonstration.

AB - Across the lifespan and across populations, humans ‘overimitate’ causally unnecessary behaviors. Such irrelevant-action imitation facilitates faithful cultural transmission, but its immediate benefits to the imitator are controversial. Over short time scales, irrelevant-action imitation may bootstrap artifact exploration or interpersonal affiliation, and over longer time scales it may facilitate acquisition of either causal models or social conventions. To investigate these putative functions, we recruited community samples from two under-studied populations: Yasawa, Fiji, and Huatasani, Peru. We use a two-action puzzle box: first after a video demonstration, and again one month later. Treating age as a continuous variable, we reveal divergent developmental trajectories across sites. Yasawans (44 adults, M = 39.9 years, 23 women; 42 children, M = 9.8 years, 26 girls) resemble documented patterns, with irrelevant-action imitation increasing across childhood and plateauing in adulthood. In contrast, Huatasaneños (48 adults, M = 37.6 years, 33 women; 47 children, M = 9.3 years, 13 girls) evince a parabolic trajectory: adults at the site show the lowest irrelevant-action imitation of any demographic set in our sample. In addition, all age sets in both populations reduce their irrelevant actions at Time 2, but do not reduce their relevant-action imitation or goal attainment. Taken together, and considering the local cultural contexts, our results suggest that irrelevant-action imitation serves a short-term function and is sensitive to the social context of the demonstration.

KW - culture and development

KW - overimitation

KW - social learning

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85074431933&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85074431933&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/desc.12903

DO - 10.1111/desc.12903

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85074431933

JO - Developmental Science

JF - Developmental Science

SN - 1363-755X

M1 - e12903

ER -