First demonstration of ECHO: An external calibrator for hydrogen observatories

Daniel Jacobs, Jacob Burba, Judd Bowman, Abraham R. Neben, Benjamin Stinnett, Lauren Turner, Kali Johnson, Michael Busch, Jay Allison, Marc Leatham, Victoria Serrano Rodriguez, Mason Denney, David Nelson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Multiple instruments are pursuing constraints on dark energy, observing reionization and opening a window on the dark ages through the detection and characterization of the 21 cm hydrogen line for redshifts ranging from ~1 to 25. These instruments, including CHIME in the sub-meter and HERA in the meter bands, are wide-field arrays with multiple-degree beams, typically operating in transit mode. Accurate knowledge of their primary beams is critical for separation of bright foregrounds from the desired cosmological signals, but difficult to achieve through astronomical observations alone. Previous beam calibration work at low frequencies has focused on model verification and does not address the need of 21 cm experiments for routine beam mapping, to the horizon, of the as-built array. We describe the design and methodology of a drone-mounted calibrator, the External Calibrator for Hydrogen Observatories (ECHO), that aims to address this need. We report on a first set of trials to calibrate lowfrequency dipoles at 137 MHz and compare ECHO measurements to an established beam-mapping system based on transmissions from the Orbcomm satellite constellation. We create beam maps of two dipoles at a 9° resolution and find sample noise ranging from 1% at the zenith to 100% in the far sidelobes. Assuming this sample noise represents the error in the measurement, the higher end of this range is not yet consistent with the desired requirement but is an improvement on Orbcomm. The overall performance of ECHO suggests that the desired precision and angular coverage is achievable in practice with modest improvements. We identify the main sources of systematic error and uncertainty in our measurements and describe the steps needed to overcome them.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number035002
JournalPublications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific
Volume129
Issue number973
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1 2017

Fingerprint

observatories
observatory
hydrogen
dipoles
satellite constellations
sidelobes
zenith
transit
calibration
dark energy
systematic errors
horizon
methodology
low frequencies
energy
requirements
experiment
need

Keywords

  • Dark ages, reionization, first stars
  • Instrumentation: interferometers

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • Space and Planetary Science

Cite this

First demonstration of ECHO : An external calibrator for hydrogen observatories. / Jacobs, Daniel; Burba, Jacob; Bowman, Judd; Neben, Abraham R.; Stinnett, Benjamin; Turner, Lauren; Johnson, Kali; Busch, Michael; Allison, Jay; Leatham, Marc; Rodriguez, Victoria Serrano; Denney, Mason; Nelson, David.

In: Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific, Vol. 129, No. 973, 035002, 01.03.2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Jacobs, D, Burba, J, Bowman, J, Neben, AR, Stinnett, B, Turner, L, Johnson, K, Busch, M, Allison, J, Leatham, M, Rodriguez, VS, Denney, M & Nelson, D 2017, 'First demonstration of ECHO: An external calibrator for hydrogen observatories', Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific, vol. 129, no. 973, 035002. https://doi.org/10.1088/1538-3873/aa56b9
Jacobs, Daniel ; Burba, Jacob ; Bowman, Judd ; Neben, Abraham R. ; Stinnett, Benjamin ; Turner, Lauren ; Johnson, Kali ; Busch, Michael ; Allison, Jay ; Leatham, Marc ; Rodriguez, Victoria Serrano ; Denney, Mason ; Nelson, David. / First demonstration of ECHO : An external calibrator for hydrogen observatories. In: Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific. 2017 ; Vol. 129, No. 973.
@article{076d702f1846421880f9830e12a75c7f,
title = "First demonstration of ECHO: An external calibrator for hydrogen observatories",
abstract = "Multiple instruments are pursuing constraints on dark energy, observing reionization and opening a window on the dark ages through the detection and characterization of the 21 cm hydrogen line for redshifts ranging from ~1 to 25. These instruments, including CHIME in the sub-meter and HERA in the meter bands, are wide-field arrays with multiple-degree beams, typically operating in transit mode. Accurate knowledge of their primary beams is critical for separation of bright foregrounds from the desired cosmological signals, but difficult to achieve through astronomical observations alone. Previous beam calibration work at low frequencies has focused on model verification and does not address the need of 21 cm experiments for routine beam mapping, to the horizon, of the as-built array. We describe the design and methodology of a drone-mounted calibrator, the External Calibrator for Hydrogen Observatories (ECHO), that aims to address this need. We report on a first set of trials to calibrate lowfrequency dipoles at 137 MHz and compare ECHO measurements to an established beam-mapping system based on transmissions from the Orbcomm satellite constellation. We create beam maps of two dipoles at a 9° resolution and find sample noise ranging from 1{\%} at the zenith to 100{\%} in the far sidelobes. Assuming this sample noise represents the error in the measurement, the higher end of this range is not yet consistent with the desired requirement but is an improvement on Orbcomm. The overall performance of ECHO suggests that the desired precision and angular coverage is achievable in practice with modest improvements. We identify the main sources of systematic error and uncertainty in our measurements and describe the steps needed to overcome them.",
keywords = "Dark ages, reionization, first stars, Instrumentation: interferometers",
author = "Daniel Jacobs and Jacob Burba and Judd Bowman and Neben, {Abraham R.} and Benjamin Stinnett and Lauren Turner and Kali Johnson and Michael Busch and Jay Allison and Marc Leatham and Rodriguez, {Victoria Serrano} and Mason Denney and David Nelson",
year = "2017",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1088/1538-3873/aa56b9",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "129",
journal = "Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific",
issn = "0004-6280",
publisher = "University of Chicago",
number = "973",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - First demonstration of ECHO

T2 - An external calibrator for hydrogen observatories

AU - Jacobs, Daniel

AU - Burba, Jacob

AU - Bowman, Judd

AU - Neben, Abraham R.

AU - Stinnett, Benjamin

AU - Turner, Lauren

AU - Johnson, Kali

AU - Busch, Michael

AU - Allison, Jay

AU - Leatham, Marc

AU - Rodriguez, Victoria Serrano

AU - Denney, Mason

AU - Nelson, David

PY - 2017/3/1

Y1 - 2017/3/1

N2 - Multiple instruments are pursuing constraints on dark energy, observing reionization and opening a window on the dark ages through the detection and characterization of the 21 cm hydrogen line for redshifts ranging from ~1 to 25. These instruments, including CHIME in the sub-meter and HERA in the meter bands, are wide-field arrays with multiple-degree beams, typically operating in transit mode. Accurate knowledge of their primary beams is critical for separation of bright foregrounds from the desired cosmological signals, but difficult to achieve through astronomical observations alone. Previous beam calibration work at low frequencies has focused on model verification and does not address the need of 21 cm experiments for routine beam mapping, to the horizon, of the as-built array. We describe the design and methodology of a drone-mounted calibrator, the External Calibrator for Hydrogen Observatories (ECHO), that aims to address this need. We report on a first set of trials to calibrate lowfrequency dipoles at 137 MHz and compare ECHO measurements to an established beam-mapping system based on transmissions from the Orbcomm satellite constellation. We create beam maps of two dipoles at a 9° resolution and find sample noise ranging from 1% at the zenith to 100% in the far sidelobes. Assuming this sample noise represents the error in the measurement, the higher end of this range is not yet consistent with the desired requirement but is an improvement on Orbcomm. The overall performance of ECHO suggests that the desired precision and angular coverage is achievable in practice with modest improvements. We identify the main sources of systematic error and uncertainty in our measurements and describe the steps needed to overcome them.

AB - Multiple instruments are pursuing constraints on dark energy, observing reionization and opening a window on the dark ages through the detection and characterization of the 21 cm hydrogen line for redshifts ranging from ~1 to 25. These instruments, including CHIME in the sub-meter and HERA in the meter bands, are wide-field arrays with multiple-degree beams, typically operating in transit mode. Accurate knowledge of their primary beams is critical for separation of bright foregrounds from the desired cosmological signals, but difficult to achieve through astronomical observations alone. Previous beam calibration work at low frequencies has focused on model verification and does not address the need of 21 cm experiments for routine beam mapping, to the horizon, of the as-built array. We describe the design and methodology of a drone-mounted calibrator, the External Calibrator for Hydrogen Observatories (ECHO), that aims to address this need. We report on a first set of trials to calibrate lowfrequency dipoles at 137 MHz and compare ECHO measurements to an established beam-mapping system based on transmissions from the Orbcomm satellite constellation. We create beam maps of two dipoles at a 9° resolution and find sample noise ranging from 1% at the zenith to 100% in the far sidelobes. Assuming this sample noise represents the error in the measurement, the higher end of this range is not yet consistent with the desired requirement but is an improvement on Orbcomm. The overall performance of ECHO suggests that the desired precision and angular coverage is achievable in practice with modest improvements. We identify the main sources of systematic error and uncertainty in our measurements and describe the steps needed to overcome them.

KW - Dark ages, reionization, first stars

KW - Instrumentation: interferometers

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85014262920&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85014262920&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1088/1538-3873/aa56b9

DO - 10.1088/1538-3873/aa56b9

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85014262920

VL - 129

JO - Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific

JF - Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific

SN - 0004-6280

IS - 973

M1 - 035002

ER -