Description of two new species and phylogenetic reassessment of Perelleschus OBrien & Wibmer, 1986 (Coleoptera: Curculionidae), with a complete taxonomic concept history of Perelleschus sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque, 2013

Nico Franz, Juliana Cardona-Duque

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

19 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The weevil genus Perelleschus OBrien & Wibmer, 1986, is revised; including the description of P. salpinflexus Cardona-Duque & Franz sp. nov. sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013) from Colombia and P. spinothylax Cardona-Duque & Franz sp. nov. sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013) from Colombia and Venezuela. This study furthermore demonstrates the feasibility and utility of the taxonomic concept approach as laid out in Franz & Peet (2009). In particular, we establish and consistently practice a convention where (1) the taxonomic name sec. author annotation is used in all instances where a specific meaning of a name is intended; (2) just the taxonomic name is used to refer to the cumulative nomenclatural and taxonomic legacy associated with that name; and (3) the term [non-focal] is added to a taxonomic name to signal that specifying or redefining its meaning is outside of the scope of this study. We reproduce six classifications and 54 constituent taxonomic concepts that represent a complete taxonomic history of the entities classified in Perelleschus sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013). We provide tabular summaries in which (1) each of the 54 concepts is uniquely identified, (2) the six concept groups are arranged via parent/child relationships into their respective classifications, (3) 76 articulations are asserted to semantically integrate concepts across classifications, and (4) the textual circumscription of each concept is reproduced. These data reveal that the taxonomic history of Perelleschus sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013) has been rather stable at the species level and more complicated at higher levels, where 49 out of 54 articulations are not unambiguously congruent and 37 articulations use the intensional/ostensive annotation. This cumulative information presents a novel use case suitable for representation and reasoning about taxonomic classifications and classification provenance in computational logic. We discuss the merits of this approach and provide recommendations for a wider implementation.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)209-236
Number of pages28
JournalSystematics and Biodiversity
Volume11
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Jun 1 2013

Fingerprint

Curculionidae
Coleoptera
new species
phylogenetics
phylogeny
history
Colombia
parent-child relationships
Venezuela
provenance
taxonomy

Keywords

  • concept taxonomy
  • knowledge representation
  • Neotropics
  • new species
  • ontology mapping
  • phylogeny
  • reasoning
  • revision
  • systematics
  • weevils

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Plant Science
  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics

Cite this

@article{8f0a5eb3508944b5aa92e98446ecf0d9,
title = "Description of two new species and phylogenetic reassessment of Perelleschus OBrien & Wibmer, 1986 (Coleoptera: Curculionidae), with a complete taxonomic concept history of Perelleschus sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque, 2013",
abstract = "The weevil genus Perelleschus OBrien & Wibmer, 1986, is revised; including the description of P. salpinflexus Cardona-Duque & Franz sp. nov. sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013) from Colombia and P. spinothylax Cardona-Duque & Franz sp. nov. sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013) from Colombia and Venezuela. This study furthermore demonstrates the feasibility and utility of the taxonomic concept approach as laid out in Franz & Peet (2009). In particular, we establish and consistently practice a convention where (1) the taxonomic name sec. author annotation is used in all instances where a specific meaning of a name is intended; (2) just the taxonomic name is used to refer to the cumulative nomenclatural and taxonomic legacy associated with that name; and (3) the term [non-focal] is added to a taxonomic name to signal that specifying or redefining its meaning is outside of the scope of this study. We reproduce six classifications and 54 constituent taxonomic concepts that represent a complete taxonomic history of the entities classified in Perelleschus sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013). We provide tabular summaries in which (1) each of the 54 concepts is uniquely identified, (2) the six concept groups are arranged via parent/child relationships into their respective classifications, (3) 76 articulations are asserted to semantically integrate concepts across classifications, and (4) the textual circumscription of each concept is reproduced. These data reveal that the taxonomic history of Perelleschus sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013) has been rather stable at the species level and more complicated at higher levels, where 49 out of 54 articulations are not unambiguously congruent and 37 articulations use the intensional/ostensive annotation. This cumulative information presents a novel use case suitable for representation and reasoning about taxonomic classifications and classification provenance in computational logic. We discuss the merits of this approach and provide recommendations for a wider implementation.",
keywords = "concept taxonomy, knowledge representation, Neotropics, new species, ontology mapping, phylogeny, reasoning, revision, systematics, weevils",
author = "Nico Franz and Juliana Cardona-Duque",
year = "2013",
month = "6",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1080/14772000.2013.806371",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "11",
pages = "209--236",
journal = "Systematics and Biodiversity",
issn = "1477-2000",
publisher = "Taylor and Francis Ltd.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Description of two new species and phylogenetic reassessment of Perelleschus OBrien & Wibmer, 1986 (Coleoptera

T2 - Curculionidae), with a complete taxonomic concept history of Perelleschus sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque, 2013

AU - Franz, Nico

AU - Cardona-Duque, Juliana

PY - 2013/6/1

Y1 - 2013/6/1

N2 - The weevil genus Perelleschus OBrien & Wibmer, 1986, is revised; including the description of P. salpinflexus Cardona-Duque & Franz sp. nov. sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013) from Colombia and P. spinothylax Cardona-Duque & Franz sp. nov. sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013) from Colombia and Venezuela. This study furthermore demonstrates the feasibility and utility of the taxonomic concept approach as laid out in Franz & Peet (2009). In particular, we establish and consistently practice a convention where (1) the taxonomic name sec. author annotation is used in all instances where a specific meaning of a name is intended; (2) just the taxonomic name is used to refer to the cumulative nomenclatural and taxonomic legacy associated with that name; and (3) the term [non-focal] is added to a taxonomic name to signal that specifying or redefining its meaning is outside of the scope of this study. We reproduce six classifications and 54 constituent taxonomic concepts that represent a complete taxonomic history of the entities classified in Perelleschus sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013). We provide tabular summaries in which (1) each of the 54 concepts is uniquely identified, (2) the six concept groups are arranged via parent/child relationships into their respective classifications, (3) 76 articulations are asserted to semantically integrate concepts across classifications, and (4) the textual circumscription of each concept is reproduced. These data reveal that the taxonomic history of Perelleschus sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013) has been rather stable at the species level and more complicated at higher levels, where 49 out of 54 articulations are not unambiguously congruent and 37 articulations use the intensional/ostensive annotation. This cumulative information presents a novel use case suitable for representation and reasoning about taxonomic classifications and classification provenance in computational logic. We discuss the merits of this approach and provide recommendations for a wider implementation.

AB - The weevil genus Perelleschus OBrien & Wibmer, 1986, is revised; including the description of P. salpinflexus Cardona-Duque & Franz sp. nov. sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013) from Colombia and P. spinothylax Cardona-Duque & Franz sp. nov. sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013) from Colombia and Venezuela. This study furthermore demonstrates the feasibility and utility of the taxonomic concept approach as laid out in Franz & Peet (2009). In particular, we establish and consistently practice a convention where (1) the taxonomic name sec. author annotation is used in all instances where a specific meaning of a name is intended; (2) just the taxonomic name is used to refer to the cumulative nomenclatural and taxonomic legacy associated with that name; and (3) the term [non-focal] is added to a taxonomic name to signal that specifying or redefining its meaning is outside of the scope of this study. We reproduce six classifications and 54 constituent taxonomic concepts that represent a complete taxonomic history of the entities classified in Perelleschus sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013). We provide tabular summaries in which (1) each of the 54 concepts is uniquely identified, (2) the six concept groups are arranged via parent/child relationships into their respective classifications, (3) 76 articulations are asserted to semantically integrate concepts across classifications, and (4) the textual circumscription of each concept is reproduced. These data reveal that the taxonomic history of Perelleschus sec. Franz & Cardona-Duque (2013) has been rather stable at the species level and more complicated at higher levels, where 49 out of 54 articulations are not unambiguously congruent and 37 articulations use the intensional/ostensive annotation. This cumulative information presents a novel use case suitable for representation and reasoning about taxonomic classifications and classification provenance in computational logic. We discuss the merits of this approach and provide recommendations for a wider implementation.

KW - concept taxonomy

KW - knowledge representation

KW - Neotropics

KW - new species

KW - ontology mapping

KW - phylogeny

KW - reasoning

KW - revision

KW - systematics

KW - weevils

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84880253179&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84880253179&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/14772000.2013.806371

DO - 10.1080/14772000.2013.806371

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84880253179

VL - 11

SP - 209

EP - 236

JO - Systematics and Biodiversity

JF - Systematics and Biodiversity

SN - 1477-2000

IS - 2

ER -