A Pledge of Faithfulness

How Black Christian Fraternity Men Embody Race, Gender and Religious Identities

Keon McGuire, Joseph D. Sweet, Kenzalia Bryant-Scott, Terrence S. McTier, Emeka Ikegwuonu

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Though much has been written about the benefits that Black sororities and fraternities offer its members as well as broader communities within and beyond the ivory towers, comparatively fewer studies have addressed how these organizations interact with men's constructions and embodiments of masculinities. Moreover, even fewer studies examine the intersections of masculinities, race, and religion. As such, this paper examines how members of one Black Christian fraternity construct their manhood amid these intersections. To do this, we conduct an interpretative phenomenological analysis based on interviews, a photovoice exercise, and field notes taken during a fraternity retreat to examine how members of this fraternity negotiate race-gender-religion as they navigate both college life and emerging adulthood. Our analysis reveals that the men embody Black Christian masculinities as responsibility, assuming leadership roles, and actively working against stereotypes and tropes of Black Christian manhood. Ultimately, we argue that colleges and universities should be cognizant of the ways that Black Christian fraternity men experience and respond to gendered racism and that educators themselves be aware of the subtle ways (cisgender heterosexual) Black manhood can sometimes reinforce heteropatriarchy.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalJournal of Higher Education
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

fraternity
gender
masculinity
Religion
adulthood
racism
stereotype
educator
leadership
responsibility
university
interview
community
experience

Keywords

  • college student identity
  • fraternities
  • masculinities
  • race
  • Religion

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education

Cite this

A Pledge of Faithfulness : How Black Christian Fraternity Men Embody Race, Gender and Religious Identities. / McGuire, Keon; Sweet, Joseph D.; Bryant-Scott, Kenzalia; McTier, Terrence S.; Ikegwuonu, Emeka.

In: Journal of Higher Education, 01.01.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

McGuire, Keon ; Sweet, Joseph D. ; Bryant-Scott, Kenzalia ; McTier, Terrence S. ; Ikegwuonu, Emeka. / A Pledge of Faithfulness : How Black Christian Fraternity Men Embody Race, Gender and Religious Identities. In: Journal of Higher Education. 2019.
@article{e7408b7febd84e57a5d17202fb0bdf5b,
title = "A Pledge of Faithfulness: How Black Christian Fraternity Men Embody Race, Gender and Religious Identities",
abstract = "Though much has been written about the benefits that Black sororities and fraternities offer its members as well as broader communities within and beyond the ivory towers, comparatively fewer studies have addressed how these organizations interact with men's constructions and embodiments of masculinities. Moreover, even fewer studies examine the intersections of masculinities, race, and religion. As such, this paper examines how members of one Black Christian fraternity construct their manhood amid these intersections. To do this, we conduct an interpretative phenomenological analysis based on interviews, a photovoice exercise, and field notes taken during a fraternity retreat to examine how members of this fraternity negotiate race-gender-religion as they navigate both college life and emerging adulthood. Our analysis reveals that the men embody Black Christian masculinities as responsibility, assuming leadership roles, and actively working against stereotypes and tropes of Black Christian manhood. Ultimately, we argue that colleges and universities should be cognizant of the ways that Black Christian fraternity men experience and respond to gendered racism and that educators themselves be aware of the subtle ways (cisgender heterosexual) Black manhood can sometimes reinforce heteropatriarchy.",
keywords = "college student identity, fraternities, masculinities, race, Religion",
author = "Keon McGuire and Sweet, {Joseph D.} and Kenzalia Bryant-Scott and McTier, {Terrence S.} and Emeka Ikegwuonu",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1080/00221546.2019.1631072",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Journal of Higher Education",
issn = "0022-1546",
publisher = "Ohio State University Press",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A Pledge of Faithfulness

T2 - How Black Christian Fraternity Men Embody Race, Gender and Religious Identities

AU - McGuire, Keon

AU - Sweet, Joseph D.

AU - Bryant-Scott, Kenzalia

AU - McTier, Terrence S.

AU - Ikegwuonu, Emeka

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Though much has been written about the benefits that Black sororities and fraternities offer its members as well as broader communities within and beyond the ivory towers, comparatively fewer studies have addressed how these organizations interact with men's constructions and embodiments of masculinities. Moreover, even fewer studies examine the intersections of masculinities, race, and religion. As such, this paper examines how members of one Black Christian fraternity construct their manhood amid these intersections. To do this, we conduct an interpretative phenomenological analysis based on interviews, a photovoice exercise, and field notes taken during a fraternity retreat to examine how members of this fraternity negotiate race-gender-religion as they navigate both college life and emerging adulthood. Our analysis reveals that the men embody Black Christian masculinities as responsibility, assuming leadership roles, and actively working against stereotypes and tropes of Black Christian manhood. Ultimately, we argue that colleges and universities should be cognizant of the ways that Black Christian fraternity men experience and respond to gendered racism and that educators themselves be aware of the subtle ways (cisgender heterosexual) Black manhood can sometimes reinforce heteropatriarchy.

AB - Though much has been written about the benefits that Black sororities and fraternities offer its members as well as broader communities within and beyond the ivory towers, comparatively fewer studies have addressed how these organizations interact with men's constructions and embodiments of masculinities. Moreover, even fewer studies examine the intersections of masculinities, race, and religion. As such, this paper examines how members of one Black Christian fraternity construct their manhood amid these intersections. To do this, we conduct an interpretative phenomenological analysis based on interviews, a photovoice exercise, and field notes taken during a fraternity retreat to examine how members of this fraternity negotiate race-gender-religion as they navigate both college life and emerging adulthood. Our analysis reveals that the men embody Black Christian masculinities as responsibility, assuming leadership roles, and actively working against stereotypes and tropes of Black Christian manhood. Ultimately, we argue that colleges and universities should be cognizant of the ways that Black Christian fraternity men experience and respond to gendered racism and that educators themselves be aware of the subtle ways (cisgender heterosexual) Black manhood can sometimes reinforce heteropatriarchy.

KW - college student identity

KW - fraternities

KW - masculinities

KW - race

KW - Religion

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85070293900&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85070293900&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/00221546.2019.1631072

DO - 10.1080/00221546.2019.1631072

M3 - Article

JO - Journal of Higher Education

JF - Journal of Higher Education

SN - 0022-1546

ER -