What is an "emotion" in the Hebrew Bible?

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

As emotions and feelings in the Hebrew Bible are starting to receive scholarly attention, I question here the appropriateness of applying the modern concept of "emotions" to Biblical Hebrew. To which extent do our "emotions" fit the way Biblical Hebrew organizes human experience? The first part of the article analyzes a few Hebrew words commonly translated by terms of emotion in modern languages. Based on existing scholarship and a brief study of the words in their literary contexts, I suggest that the terms are not limited to the expression of what we call emotions; rather, they also include actions, movements, ritual gestures, and physical sensations, without strict dissociation among these different dimensions. This observation casts doubt on the existence of an isolated emotional realm in Biblical Hebrew's organization of human experience. In the second half, I proceed in an opposite way: I start from a given situation-scenes where the self faces the suffering affecting another person and initiates different actions in favor of the sufferer. The examples highlight that the experience we commonly shape as an "emotion"-compassion or sympathy-does not receive such a construction in Biblical Hebrew. Besides, the experience affects the self not so much in its individuality as in its social relationships; as such, it also functions inside a given social hierarchy. I conclude by considering the potential impact that this reframed view on biblical "emotions" may have on this nascent field.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)442-465
Number of pages24
JournalBiblical Interpretation
Volume24
Issue number4-5
DOIs
StatePublished - 2016

Fingerprint

Hebrew Bible
Emotion
Biblical Hebrew
Human Experience
Physical
Person
Compassion
Gesture
Individuality
Appropriateness
Sympathy
Social Relationships
Dissociation
Modern Languages

Keywords

  • emotions
  • fear
  • grief
  • hate
  • joy
  • love

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Religious studies

Cite this

What is an "emotion" in the Hebrew Bible? / Mirguet, Francoise.

In: Biblical Interpretation, Vol. 24, No. 4-5, 2016, p. 442-465.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{d690bb094a9044d3993231360b176d82,
title = "What is an {"}emotion{"} in the Hebrew Bible?",
abstract = "As emotions and feelings in the Hebrew Bible are starting to receive scholarly attention, I question here the appropriateness of applying the modern concept of {"}emotions{"} to Biblical Hebrew. To which extent do our {"}emotions{"} fit the way Biblical Hebrew organizes human experience? The first part of the article analyzes a few Hebrew words commonly translated by terms of emotion in modern languages. Based on existing scholarship and a brief study of the words in their literary contexts, I suggest that the terms are not limited to the expression of what we call emotions; rather, they also include actions, movements, ritual gestures, and physical sensations, without strict dissociation among these different dimensions. This observation casts doubt on the existence of an isolated emotional realm in Biblical Hebrew's organization of human experience. In the second half, I proceed in an opposite way: I start from a given situation-scenes where the self faces the suffering affecting another person and initiates different actions in favor of the sufferer. The examples highlight that the experience we commonly shape as an {"}emotion{"}-compassion or sympathy-does not receive such a construction in Biblical Hebrew. Besides, the experience affects the self not so much in its individuality as in its social relationships; as such, it also functions inside a given social hierarchy. I conclude by considering the potential impact that this reframed view on biblical {"}emotions{"} may have on this nascent field.",
keywords = "emotions, fear, grief, hate, joy, love",
author = "Francoise Mirguet",
year = "2016",
doi = "10.1163/15685152-02445p02",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "24",
pages = "442--465",
journal = "Biblical Interpretation",
issn = "0927-2569",
publisher = "Brill",
number = "4-5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - What is an "emotion" in the Hebrew Bible?

AU - Mirguet, Francoise

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - As emotions and feelings in the Hebrew Bible are starting to receive scholarly attention, I question here the appropriateness of applying the modern concept of "emotions" to Biblical Hebrew. To which extent do our "emotions" fit the way Biblical Hebrew organizes human experience? The first part of the article analyzes a few Hebrew words commonly translated by terms of emotion in modern languages. Based on existing scholarship and a brief study of the words in their literary contexts, I suggest that the terms are not limited to the expression of what we call emotions; rather, they also include actions, movements, ritual gestures, and physical sensations, without strict dissociation among these different dimensions. This observation casts doubt on the existence of an isolated emotional realm in Biblical Hebrew's organization of human experience. In the second half, I proceed in an opposite way: I start from a given situation-scenes where the self faces the suffering affecting another person and initiates different actions in favor of the sufferer. The examples highlight that the experience we commonly shape as an "emotion"-compassion or sympathy-does not receive such a construction in Biblical Hebrew. Besides, the experience affects the self not so much in its individuality as in its social relationships; as such, it also functions inside a given social hierarchy. I conclude by considering the potential impact that this reframed view on biblical "emotions" may have on this nascent field.

AB - As emotions and feelings in the Hebrew Bible are starting to receive scholarly attention, I question here the appropriateness of applying the modern concept of "emotions" to Biblical Hebrew. To which extent do our "emotions" fit the way Biblical Hebrew organizes human experience? The first part of the article analyzes a few Hebrew words commonly translated by terms of emotion in modern languages. Based on existing scholarship and a brief study of the words in their literary contexts, I suggest that the terms are not limited to the expression of what we call emotions; rather, they also include actions, movements, ritual gestures, and physical sensations, without strict dissociation among these different dimensions. This observation casts doubt on the existence of an isolated emotional realm in Biblical Hebrew's organization of human experience. In the second half, I proceed in an opposite way: I start from a given situation-scenes where the self faces the suffering affecting another person and initiates different actions in favor of the sufferer. The examples highlight that the experience we commonly shape as an "emotion"-compassion or sympathy-does not receive such a construction in Biblical Hebrew. Besides, the experience affects the self not so much in its individuality as in its social relationships; as such, it also functions inside a given social hierarchy. I conclude by considering the potential impact that this reframed view on biblical "emotions" may have on this nascent field.

KW - emotions

KW - fear

KW - grief

KW - hate

KW - joy

KW - love

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85018749781&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85018749781&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1163/15685152-02445p02

DO - 10.1163/15685152-02445p02

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85018749781

VL - 24

SP - 442

EP - 465

JO - Biblical Interpretation

JF - Biblical Interpretation

SN - 0927-2569

IS - 4-5

ER -