Utilizing civil engineering senior design capstone projects to evaluate students' sustainability education across engineering curriculum

Claire L.A. Dancz, Kevin J. Ketchman, Rebekah D. Burke, Troy A. Hottle, Kristen Parrish, Melissa M. Bilec, Amy E. Landis

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

While many institutions express interest in integrating sustainability into their civil engineering curriculum, the engineering community lacks consensus on established methods for infusing sustainability into curriculum and verified approaches to assess engineers' sustainability knowledge. This paper presents the development of a sustainability rubric and application of the rubric to civil engineering senior design capstone projects to evaluate students' sustainability knowledge at two institutions. The rubric built upon previous assessment approaches to evaluate student reports for nine different factors including dimensions of sustainability, Bloom's taxonomy, sustainability links, drivers for including sustainability, location of sustainability within report, qualitative/quantitative incorporation, sustainability source/reference, and sustainability topics. The sustainability content within Spring 2014, Fall 2014, and Spring 2015 senior design capstone projects from university A (UA, n = 181 students, np = 28 projects) and university B (UB, n = 106 students, np = 15 projects) was evaluated using a mixed-methods approach. The mixed-methods assessment included observation of student project presentations and evaluation of student reports via rubric. Rubric evaluation of student reports revealed that students' performance in senior design projects is primarily driven by their instructor's expectations; if sustainability is not a major deliverable, then students are less likely to integrate sustainability concepts that they learned from prior classes in their reports. To make sustainability a priority, senior design project requirements should be updated to explicitly require holistic sustainability applications. Instructors could approach raising sustainability expectations by engaging a sustainability expert as an advisor to the senior design course and/or utilizing a sustainability expert as project mentor, as demonstrated in the success of one senior design project at each institution during this study.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalAdvances in Engineering Education
Volume6
Issue number2
StatePublished - 2017

Fingerprint

Engineering education
Civil engineering
Curricula
Sustainable development
sustainability
Students
engineering
curriculum
education
student
instructor
expert
university
Taxonomies

Keywords

  • Capstone design
  • Mixed methods
  • Sustainability

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education
  • Engineering(all)

Cite this

Utilizing civil engineering senior design capstone projects to evaluate students' sustainability education across engineering curriculum. / Dancz, Claire L.A.; Ketchman, Kevin J.; Burke, Rebekah D.; Hottle, Troy A.; Parrish, Kristen; Bilec, Melissa M.; Landis, Amy E.

In: Advances in Engineering Education, Vol. 6, No. 2, 2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Dancz, Claire L.A. ; Ketchman, Kevin J. ; Burke, Rebekah D. ; Hottle, Troy A. ; Parrish, Kristen ; Bilec, Melissa M. ; Landis, Amy E. / Utilizing civil engineering senior design capstone projects to evaluate students' sustainability education across engineering curriculum. In: Advances in Engineering Education. 2017 ; Vol. 6, No. 2.
@article{93adc9be915b4d3cbd395381825175da,
title = "Utilizing civil engineering senior design capstone projects to evaluate students' sustainability education across engineering curriculum",
abstract = "While many institutions express interest in integrating sustainability into their civil engineering curriculum, the engineering community lacks consensus on established methods for infusing sustainability into curriculum and verified approaches to assess engineers' sustainability knowledge. This paper presents the development of a sustainability rubric and application of the rubric to civil engineering senior design capstone projects to evaluate students' sustainability knowledge at two institutions. The rubric built upon previous assessment approaches to evaluate student reports for nine different factors including dimensions of sustainability, Bloom's taxonomy, sustainability links, drivers for including sustainability, location of sustainability within report, qualitative/quantitative incorporation, sustainability source/reference, and sustainability topics. The sustainability content within Spring 2014, Fall 2014, and Spring 2015 senior design capstone projects from university A (UA, n = 181 students, np = 28 projects) and university B (UB, n = 106 students, np = 15 projects) was evaluated using a mixed-methods approach. The mixed-methods assessment included observation of student project presentations and evaluation of student reports via rubric. Rubric evaluation of student reports revealed that students' performance in senior design projects is primarily driven by their instructor's expectations; if sustainability is not a major deliverable, then students are less likely to integrate sustainability concepts that they learned from prior classes in their reports. To make sustainability a priority, senior design project requirements should be updated to explicitly require holistic sustainability applications. Instructors could approach raising sustainability expectations by engaging a sustainability expert as an advisor to the senior design course and/or utilizing a sustainability expert as project mentor, as demonstrated in the success of one senior design project at each institution during this study.",
keywords = "Capstone design, Mixed methods, Sustainability",
author = "Dancz, {Claire L.A.} and Ketchman, {Kevin J.} and Burke, {Rebekah D.} and Hottle, {Troy A.} and Kristen Parrish and Bilec, {Melissa M.} and Landis, {Amy E.}",
year = "2017",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "6",
journal = "Advances in Engineering Education",
issn = "1941-1766",
publisher = "American Society for Engineering Education",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Utilizing civil engineering senior design capstone projects to evaluate students' sustainability education across engineering curriculum

AU - Dancz, Claire L.A.

AU - Ketchman, Kevin J.

AU - Burke, Rebekah D.

AU - Hottle, Troy A.

AU - Parrish, Kristen

AU - Bilec, Melissa M.

AU - Landis, Amy E.

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - While many institutions express interest in integrating sustainability into their civil engineering curriculum, the engineering community lacks consensus on established methods for infusing sustainability into curriculum and verified approaches to assess engineers' sustainability knowledge. This paper presents the development of a sustainability rubric and application of the rubric to civil engineering senior design capstone projects to evaluate students' sustainability knowledge at two institutions. The rubric built upon previous assessment approaches to evaluate student reports for nine different factors including dimensions of sustainability, Bloom's taxonomy, sustainability links, drivers for including sustainability, location of sustainability within report, qualitative/quantitative incorporation, sustainability source/reference, and sustainability topics. The sustainability content within Spring 2014, Fall 2014, and Spring 2015 senior design capstone projects from university A (UA, n = 181 students, np = 28 projects) and university B (UB, n = 106 students, np = 15 projects) was evaluated using a mixed-methods approach. The mixed-methods assessment included observation of student project presentations and evaluation of student reports via rubric. Rubric evaluation of student reports revealed that students' performance in senior design projects is primarily driven by their instructor's expectations; if sustainability is not a major deliverable, then students are less likely to integrate sustainability concepts that they learned from prior classes in their reports. To make sustainability a priority, senior design project requirements should be updated to explicitly require holistic sustainability applications. Instructors could approach raising sustainability expectations by engaging a sustainability expert as an advisor to the senior design course and/or utilizing a sustainability expert as project mentor, as demonstrated in the success of one senior design project at each institution during this study.

AB - While many institutions express interest in integrating sustainability into their civil engineering curriculum, the engineering community lacks consensus on established methods for infusing sustainability into curriculum and verified approaches to assess engineers' sustainability knowledge. This paper presents the development of a sustainability rubric and application of the rubric to civil engineering senior design capstone projects to evaluate students' sustainability knowledge at two institutions. The rubric built upon previous assessment approaches to evaluate student reports for nine different factors including dimensions of sustainability, Bloom's taxonomy, sustainability links, drivers for including sustainability, location of sustainability within report, qualitative/quantitative incorporation, sustainability source/reference, and sustainability topics. The sustainability content within Spring 2014, Fall 2014, and Spring 2015 senior design capstone projects from university A (UA, n = 181 students, np = 28 projects) and university B (UB, n = 106 students, np = 15 projects) was evaluated using a mixed-methods approach. The mixed-methods assessment included observation of student project presentations and evaluation of student reports via rubric. Rubric evaluation of student reports revealed that students' performance in senior design projects is primarily driven by their instructor's expectations; if sustainability is not a major deliverable, then students are less likely to integrate sustainability concepts that they learned from prior classes in their reports. To make sustainability a priority, senior design project requirements should be updated to explicitly require holistic sustainability applications. Instructors could approach raising sustainability expectations by engaging a sustainability expert as an advisor to the senior design course and/or utilizing a sustainability expert as project mentor, as demonstrated in the success of one senior design project at each institution during this study.

KW - Capstone design

KW - Mixed methods

KW - Sustainability

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85032860808&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85032860808&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85032860808

VL - 6

JO - Advances in Engineering Education

JF - Advances in Engineering Education

SN - 1941-1766

IS - 2

ER -