Using Best-Value Procurement to Measure the Impact of Initial Risk-Management Capability on Qualitative Construction Performance

Anthony Perrenoud, Brian C. Lines, John Savicky, Kenneth Sullivan

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Managing project risk in construction is becoming increasingly critical for ensuring that project objectives are met effectively. Perceptions and practices related to effective risk management vary among contractors, which results in different levels of risk-management capabilities. A best-value selection method enables owners to identify, during the selection process, contractors with strong risk-management capabilities. This paper presents qualitative data from 133 construction projects in which contractors were selected through a best-value process. During the selection process, contractors completed a risk-management plan (RMP) in which they identified the major risks of prospective projects and ways to manage the risks. The RMPs were then scored by a group of reviewers, and the scores for each contractor were averaged and used within the best-value selection model. In addition, after completion of each project, a close-out survey was used to gather data on several aspects of the contractors' project performance. A contractor's average RMP score and survey data were examined with Pearson's product-moment correlation and linear regression analysis. A positive correlation was found between average RMP scores and the performance metrics assessed in the survey. Contractors with high average RMP scores also had achieved high levels in the performance metrics of quality, professionalism, risk communication, and overall customer satisfaction. An additional correlation was found between average RMP scores and project award percentage. These correlations highlight the importance of establishing and developing effective project risk- management methods and selecting vendors through a best-value approach.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number04017019
JournalJournal of Management in Engineering
Volume33
Issue number5
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 1 2017
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Risk management
Contractors
Management capability
Procurement
Customer satisfaction
Project management
Linear regression
Regression analysis
Management plan
Communication

Keywords

  • Best value
  • Project risk management
  • Risk maturity

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Industrial relations
  • Engineering(all)
  • Strategy and Management
  • Management Science and Operations Research

Cite this

Using Best-Value Procurement to Measure the Impact of Initial Risk-Management Capability on Qualitative Construction Performance. / Perrenoud, Anthony; Lines, Brian C.; Savicky, John; Sullivan, Kenneth.

In: Journal of Management in Engineering, Vol. 33, No. 5, 04017019, 01.09.2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{1f4dd292c4274682a9f6c43941d866b1,
title = "Using Best-Value Procurement to Measure the Impact of Initial Risk-Management Capability on Qualitative Construction Performance",
abstract = "Managing project risk in construction is becoming increasingly critical for ensuring that project objectives are met effectively. Perceptions and practices related to effective risk management vary among contractors, which results in different levels of risk-management capabilities. A best-value selection method enables owners to identify, during the selection process, contractors with strong risk-management capabilities. This paper presents qualitative data from 133 construction projects in which contractors were selected through a best-value process. During the selection process, contractors completed a risk-management plan (RMP) in which they identified the major risks of prospective projects and ways to manage the risks. The RMPs were then scored by a group of reviewers, and the scores for each contractor were averaged and used within the best-value selection model. In addition, after completion of each project, a close-out survey was used to gather data on several aspects of the contractors' project performance. A contractor's average RMP score and survey data were examined with Pearson's product-moment correlation and linear regression analysis. A positive correlation was found between average RMP scores and the performance metrics assessed in the survey. Contractors with high average RMP scores also had achieved high levels in the performance metrics of quality, professionalism, risk communication, and overall customer satisfaction. An additional correlation was found between average RMP scores and project award percentage. These correlations highlight the importance of establishing and developing effective project risk- management methods and selecting vendors through a best-value approach.",
keywords = "Best value, Project risk management, Risk maturity",
author = "Anthony Perrenoud and Lines, {Brian C.} and John Savicky and Kenneth Sullivan",
year = "2017",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1061/(ASCE)ME.1943-5479.0000535",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "33",
journal = "Journal of Management in Engineering - ASCE",
issn = "0742-597X",
publisher = "American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Using Best-Value Procurement to Measure the Impact of Initial Risk-Management Capability on Qualitative Construction Performance

AU - Perrenoud, Anthony

AU - Lines, Brian C.

AU - Savicky, John

AU - Sullivan, Kenneth

PY - 2017/9/1

Y1 - 2017/9/1

N2 - Managing project risk in construction is becoming increasingly critical for ensuring that project objectives are met effectively. Perceptions and practices related to effective risk management vary among contractors, which results in different levels of risk-management capabilities. A best-value selection method enables owners to identify, during the selection process, contractors with strong risk-management capabilities. This paper presents qualitative data from 133 construction projects in which contractors were selected through a best-value process. During the selection process, contractors completed a risk-management plan (RMP) in which they identified the major risks of prospective projects and ways to manage the risks. The RMPs were then scored by a group of reviewers, and the scores for each contractor were averaged and used within the best-value selection model. In addition, after completion of each project, a close-out survey was used to gather data on several aspects of the contractors' project performance. A contractor's average RMP score and survey data were examined with Pearson's product-moment correlation and linear regression analysis. A positive correlation was found between average RMP scores and the performance metrics assessed in the survey. Contractors with high average RMP scores also had achieved high levels in the performance metrics of quality, professionalism, risk communication, and overall customer satisfaction. An additional correlation was found between average RMP scores and project award percentage. These correlations highlight the importance of establishing and developing effective project risk- management methods and selecting vendors through a best-value approach.

AB - Managing project risk in construction is becoming increasingly critical for ensuring that project objectives are met effectively. Perceptions and practices related to effective risk management vary among contractors, which results in different levels of risk-management capabilities. A best-value selection method enables owners to identify, during the selection process, contractors with strong risk-management capabilities. This paper presents qualitative data from 133 construction projects in which contractors were selected through a best-value process. During the selection process, contractors completed a risk-management plan (RMP) in which they identified the major risks of prospective projects and ways to manage the risks. The RMPs were then scored by a group of reviewers, and the scores for each contractor were averaged and used within the best-value selection model. In addition, after completion of each project, a close-out survey was used to gather data on several aspects of the contractors' project performance. A contractor's average RMP score and survey data were examined with Pearson's product-moment correlation and linear regression analysis. A positive correlation was found between average RMP scores and the performance metrics assessed in the survey. Contractors with high average RMP scores also had achieved high levels in the performance metrics of quality, professionalism, risk communication, and overall customer satisfaction. An additional correlation was found between average RMP scores and project award percentage. These correlations highlight the importance of establishing and developing effective project risk- management methods and selecting vendors through a best-value approach.

KW - Best value

KW - Project risk management

KW - Risk maturity

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85018891633&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85018891633&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1061/(ASCE)ME.1943-5479.0000535

DO - 10.1061/(ASCE)ME.1943-5479.0000535

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85018891633

VL - 33

JO - Journal of Management in Engineering - ASCE

JF - Journal of Management in Engineering - ASCE

SN - 0742-597X

IS - 5

M1 - 04017019

ER -