Toward Consistent Modeling of Atmospheric Chemistry and Dynamics in Exoplanets

Validation and Generalization of the Chemical Relaxation Method

Shang Min Tsai, Daniel Kitzmann, James Lyons, Joao Mendonca, Simon L. Grimm, Kevin Heng

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Motivated by the work of Cooper & Showman, we revisit the chemical relaxation method, which seeks to enhance the computational efficiency of chemical kinetics calculations by replacing the chemical network with a handful of independent source/sink terms. Chemical relaxation solves the evolution of the system and can treat disequilibrium chemistry, as the source/sink terms are driven toward chemical equilibrium on a prescribed chemical timescale, but it has surprisingly never been validated. First, we generalize the treatment by forgoing the use of a single chemical timescale, instead developing a pathway analysis tool that allows us to identify the rate-limiting reaction as a function of temperature and pressure. For the interconversion between methane and carbon monoxide, and between ammonia and molecular nitrogen, we identify the key rate-limiting reactions for conditions relevant to currently characterizable exo-atmospheres (500-3000 K, 0.1 mbar to 1 kbar). Second, we extend chemical relaxation to include carbon dioxide and water. Third, we examine the role of metallicity and the carbon-to-oxygen ratio in chemical relaxation. Fourth, we apply our pathway analysis tool to diagnose the differences between our chemical network and that of Moses and Venot. Finally, we validate the chemical relaxation method against full chemical kinetics calculations in one dimension. For WASP-18b-, HD 189733b-, and GJ 1214-b-like atmospheres, we show that chemical relaxation is mostly accurate to within an order of magnitude, a factor of 2, and ∼10%, respectively. The level of accuracy attained allows for the chemical relaxation method to be included in three-dimensional general circulation models.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number31
JournalAstrophysical Journal
Volume862
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 20 2018

Fingerprint

atmospheric chemistry
atmospheric dynamics
chemical method
extrasolar planets
molecular relaxation
reaction kinetics
modeling
sinks
atmospheres
chemical
carbon monoxide
metallicity
chemical equilibrium
carbon dioxide
ammonia
timescale
kinetics
methane
atmosphere
chemistry

Keywords

  • Methods: numerical
  • planets and satellites: atmospheres
  • planets and satellites: composition

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • Space and Planetary Science

Cite this

Toward Consistent Modeling of Atmospheric Chemistry and Dynamics in Exoplanets : Validation and Generalization of the Chemical Relaxation Method. / Tsai, Shang Min; Kitzmann, Daniel; Lyons, James; Mendonca, Joao; Grimm, Simon L.; Heng, Kevin.

In: Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 862, No. 1, 31, 20.07.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{12778f56a34b47c390993185b2f21f4c,
title = "Toward Consistent Modeling of Atmospheric Chemistry and Dynamics in Exoplanets: Validation and Generalization of the Chemical Relaxation Method",
abstract = "Motivated by the work of Cooper & Showman, we revisit the chemical relaxation method, which seeks to enhance the computational efficiency of chemical kinetics calculations by replacing the chemical network with a handful of independent source/sink terms. Chemical relaxation solves the evolution of the system and can treat disequilibrium chemistry, as the source/sink terms are driven toward chemical equilibrium on a prescribed chemical timescale, but it has surprisingly never been validated. First, we generalize the treatment by forgoing the use of a single chemical timescale, instead developing a pathway analysis tool that allows us to identify the rate-limiting reaction as a function of temperature and pressure. For the interconversion between methane and carbon monoxide, and between ammonia and molecular nitrogen, we identify the key rate-limiting reactions for conditions relevant to currently characterizable exo-atmospheres (500-3000 K, 0.1 mbar to 1 kbar). Second, we extend chemical relaxation to include carbon dioxide and water. Third, we examine the role of metallicity and the carbon-to-oxygen ratio in chemical relaxation. Fourth, we apply our pathway analysis tool to diagnose the differences between our chemical network and that of Moses and Venot. Finally, we validate the chemical relaxation method against full chemical kinetics calculations in one dimension. For WASP-18b-, HD 189733b-, and GJ 1214-b-like atmospheres, we show that chemical relaxation is mostly accurate to within an order of magnitude, a factor of 2, and ∼10{\%}, respectively. The level of accuracy attained allows for the chemical relaxation method to be included in three-dimensional general circulation models.",
keywords = "Methods: numerical, planets and satellites: atmospheres, planets and satellites: composition",
author = "Tsai, {Shang Min} and Daniel Kitzmann and James Lyons and Joao Mendonca and Grimm, {Simon L.} and Kevin Heng",
year = "2018",
month = "7",
day = "20",
doi = "10.3847/1538-4357/aac834",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "862",
journal = "Astrophysical Journal",
issn = "0004-637X",
publisher = "IOP Publishing Ltd.",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Toward Consistent Modeling of Atmospheric Chemistry and Dynamics in Exoplanets

T2 - Validation and Generalization of the Chemical Relaxation Method

AU - Tsai, Shang Min

AU - Kitzmann, Daniel

AU - Lyons, James

AU - Mendonca, Joao

AU - Grimm, Simon L.

AU - Heng, Kevin

PY - 2018/7/20

Y1 - 2018/7/20

N2 - Motivated by the work of Cooper & Showman, we revisit the chemical relaxation method, which seeks to enhance the computational efficiency of chemical kinetics calculations by replacing the chemical network with a handful of independent source/sink terms. Chemical relaxation solves the evolution of the system and can treat disequilibrium chemistry, as the source/sink terms are driven toward chemical equilibrium on a prescribed chemical timescale, but it has surprisingly never been validated. First, we generalize the treatment by forgoing the use of a single chemical timescale, instead developing a pathway analysis tool that allows us to identify the rate-limiting reaction as a function of temperature and pressure. For the interconversion between methane and carbon monoxide, and between ammonia and molecular nitrogen, we identify the key rate-limiting reactions for conditions relevant to currently characterizable exo-atmospheres (500-3000 K, 0.1 mbar to 1 kbar). Second, we extend chemical relaxation to include carbon dioxide and water. Third, we examine the role of metallicity and the carbon-to-oxygen ratio in chemical relaxation. Fourth, we apply our pathway analysis tool to diagnose the differences between our chemical network and that of Moses and Venot. Finally, we validate the chemical relaxation method against full chemical kinetics calculations in one dimension. For WASP-18b-, HD 189733b-, and GJ 1214-b-like atmospheres, we show that chemical relaxation is mostly accurate to within an order of magnitude, a factor of 2, and ∼10%, respectively. The level of accuracy attained allows for the chemical relaxation method to be included in three-dimensional general circulation models.

AB - Motivated by the work of Cooper & Showman, we revisit the chemical relaxation method, which seeks to enhance the computational efficiency of chemical kinetics calculations by replacing the chemical network with a handful of independent source/sink terms. Chemical relaxation solves the evolution of the system and can treat disequilibrium chemistry, as the source/sink terms are driven toward chemical equilibrium on a prescribed chemical timescale, but it has surprisingly never been validated. First, we generalize the treatment by forgoing the use of a single chemical timescale, instead developing a pathway analysis tool that allows us to identify the rate-limiting reaction as a function of temperature and pressure. For the interconversion between methane and carbon monoxide, and between ammonia and molecular nitrogen, we identify the key rate-limiting reactions for conditions relevant to currently characterizable exo-atmospheres (500-3000 K, 0.1 mbar to 1 kbar). Second, we extend chemical relaxation to include carbon dioxide and water. Third, we examine the role of metallicity and the carbon-to-oxygen ratio in chemical relaxation. Fourth, we apply our pathway analysis tool to diagnose the differences between our chemical network and that of Moses and Venot. Finally, we validate the chemical relaxation method against full chemical kinetics calculations in one dimension. For WASP-18b-, HD 189733b-, and GJ 1214-b-like atmospheres, we show that chemical relaxation is mostly accurate to within an order of magnitude, a factor of 2, and ∼10%, respectively. The level of accuracy attained allows for the chemical relaxation method to be included in three-dimensional general circulation models.

KW - Methods: numerical

KW - planets and satellites: atmospheres

KW - planets and satellites: composition

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85050679046&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85050679046&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3847/1538-4357/aac834

DO - 10.3847/1538-4357/aac834

M3 - Article

VL - 862

JO - Astrophysical Journal

JF - Astrophysical Journal

SN - 0004-637X

IS - 1

M1 - 31

ER -