Tomographic inversion of S-SKS times for shear velocity heterogeneity in D″: Degree 12 and hybrid models

Ban Yuan Kuo, Edward Garnero, Thorne Lay

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

55 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Differential travel times between 5 (or diffracted S) and SKS were measured to study the global distribution of shear wave velocity heterogeneity in the lowermost 250 km of the mantle (the D″ region). Commencing with -3000 S-SKS times with variable qualities, we minimize uneven path coverage by thinning redundantly sampled regions (e.g., the Fiji-Tonga to North America corridor) and collect additional data for sparsely sampled areas, especially in the Southern Hemisphere. About 1500 paths were retained, distributed to reconcile both high-density and homogeneous sampling. We compare (1) spherical harmonic and (2) equal-area block parameterizations of D″ shear velocity heterogeneity for identical minimum resolving lengths and mean model errors. We show that the two parameterizations result in indistinguishable patterns of heterogeneity and power distribution for resolution down to a block size of 4.5° × 4.5° and maximum spherical harmonic degree of 40. We demonstrate synthetically that a high-degree (L) inversion followed by a lower-degree (Ls) spherical harmonic synthesis effectively circumvents model contamination from expansion truncation effects. Tomographic inversion of this data set yields a global distribution of D″ heterogeneity robust up to degree 12. In our preferred model (L=40, Ls=12, rms ∼1%), surface hotspots and estimated lower mantle plume roots are located in or at edges of low-velocity regions (δVs<-2%), for both the Atlantic-Indian low-velocity corridor as well as the low velocities beneath the central Pacific. Although the above parameterizations entail no intrinsic difference in resolvability, higher resolution is regionally achieved by removing the derived degree 12 model from the data then inverting the corrected residuals using 4.5°×4.5° blocks. This hybrid method prevents power loss at intermediate to long wavelengths from otherwise severe damping and recovers smaller-scale structure where constraints are better than the global average, such as beneath the Pacific and Eurasia. A synthetic recovery test yields resolvability maps that reflect both the path geometry and the quality of data, which help to identify robust features in both the degree 12 and the hybrid D″ models.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number2000JB900334
Pages (from-to)28139-28157
Number of pages19
JournalJournal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
Volume105
Issue numberB12
StatePublished - Dec 10 2000

Fingerprint

inversions
shear
spherical harmonics
Parameterization
parameterization
low speed
corridors
Earth mantle
D region
Shear waves
power loss
Southern Hemisphere
Travel time
lower mantle
mantle plume
travel time
travel
damping
S waves
plumes

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geochemistry and Petrology
  • Geophysics
  • Earth and Planetary Sciences (miscellaneous)
  • Space and Planetary Science
  • Atmospheric Science
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • Oceanography

Cite this

Tomographic inversion of S-SKS times for shear velocity heterogeneity in D″ : Degree 12 and hybrid models. / Kuo, Ban Yuan; Garnero, Edward; Lay, Thorne.

In: Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, Vol. 105, No. B12, 2000JB900334, 10.12.2000, p. 28139-28157.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{b03482f7fbe24471ba450bf506692c31,
title = "Tomographic inversion of S-SKS times for shear velocity heterogeneity in D″: Degree 12 and hybrid models",
abstract = "Differential travel times between 5 (or diffracted S) and SKS were measured to study the global distribution of shear wave velocity heterogeneity in the lowermost 250 km of the mantle (the D″ region). Commencing with -3000 S-SKS times with variable qualities, we minimize uneven path coverage by thinning redundantly sampled regions (e.g., the Fiji-Tonga to North America corridor) and collect additional data for sparsely sampled areas, especially in the Southern Hemisphere. About 1500 paths were retained, distributed to reconcile both high-density and homogeneous sampling. We compare (1) spherical harmonic and (2) equal-area block parameterizations of D″ shear velocity heterogeneity for identical minimum resolving lengths and mean model errors. We show that the two parameterizations result in indistinguishable patterns of heterogeneity and power distribution for resolution down to a block size of 4.5° × 4.5° and maximum spherical harmonic degree of 40. We demonstrate synthetically that a high-degree (L) inversion followed by a lower-degree (Ls) spherical harmonic synthesis effectively circumvents model contamination from expansion truncation effects. Tomographic inversion of this data set yields a global distribution of D″ heterogeneity robust up to degree 12. In our preferred model (L=40, Ls=12, rms ∼1{\%}), surface hotspots and estimated lower mantle plume roots are located in or at edges of low-velocity regions (δVs<-2{\%}), for both the Atlantic-Indian low-velocity corridor as well as the low velocities beneath the central Pacific. Although the above parameterizations entail no intrinsic difference in resolvability, higher resolution is regionally achieved by removing the derived degree 12 model from the data then inverting the corrected residuals using 4.5°×4.5° blocks. This hybrid method prevents power loss at intermediate to long wavelengths from otherwise severe damping and recovers smaller-scale structure where constraints are better than the global average, such as beneath the Pacific and Eurasia. A synthetic recovery test yields resolvability maps that reflect both the path geometry and the quality of data, which help to identify robust features in both the degree 12 and the hybrid D″ models.",
author = "Kuo, {Ban Yuan} and Edward Garnero and Thorne Lay",
year = "2000",
month = "12",
day = "10",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "105",
pages = "28139--28157",
journal = "Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres",
issn = "2169-897X",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "B12",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Tomographic inversion of S-SKS times for shear velocity heterogeneity in D″

T2 - Degree 12 and hybrid models

AU - Kuo, Ban Yuan

AU - Garnero, Edward

AU - Lay, Thorne

PY - 2000/12/10

Y1 - 2000/12/10

N2 - Differential travel times between 5 (or diffracted S) and SKS were measured to study the global distribution of shear wave velocity heterogeneity in the lowermost 250 km of the mantle (the D″ region). Commencing with -3000 S-SKS times with variable qualities, we minimize uneven path coverage by thinning redundantly sampled regions (e.g., the Fiji-Tonga to North America corridor) and collect additional data for sparsely sampled areas, especially in the Southern Hemisphere. About 1500 paths were retained, distributed to reconcile both high-density and homogeneous sampling. We compare (1) spherical harmonic and (2) equal-area block parameterizations of D″ shear velocity heterogeneity for identical minimum resolving lengths and mean model errors. We show that the two parameterizations result in indistinguishable patterns of heterogeneity and power distribution for resolution down to a block size of 4.5° × 4.5° and maximum spherical harmonic degree of 40. We demonstrate synthetically that a high-degree (L) inversion followed by a lower-degree (Ls) spherical harmonic synthesis effectively circumvents model contamination from expansion truncation effects. Tomographic inversion of this data set yields a global distribution of D″ heterogeneity robust up to degree 12. In our preferred model (L=40, Ls=12, rms ∼1%), surface hotspots and estimated lower mantle plume roots are located in or at edges of low-velocity regions (δVs<-2%), for both the Atlantic-Indian low-velocity corridor as well as the low velocities beneath the central Pacific. Although the above parameterizations entail no intrinsic difference in resolvability, higher resolution is regionally achieved by removing the derived degree 12 model from the data then inverting the corrected residuals using 4.5°×4.5° blocks. This hybrid method prevents power loss at intermediate to long wavelengths from otherwise severe damping and recovers smaller-scale structure where constraints are better than the global average, such as beneath the Pacific and Eurasia. A synthetic recovery test yields resolvability maps that reflect both the path geometry and the quality of data, which help to identify robust features in both the degree 12 and the hybrid D″ models.

AB - Differential travel times between 5 (or diffracted S) and SKS were measured to study the global distribution of shear wave velocity heterogeneity in the lowermost 250 km of the mantle (the D″ region). Commencing with -3000 S-SKS times with variable qualities, we minimize uneven path coverage by thinning redundantly sampled regions (e.g., the Fiji-Tonga to North America corridor) and collect additional data for sparsely sampled areas, especially in the Southern Hemisphere. About 1500 paths were retained, distributed to reconcile both high-density and homogeneous sampling. We compare (1) spherical harmonic and (2) equal-area block parameterizations of D″ shear velocity heterogeneity for identical minimum resolving lengths and mean model errors. We show that the two parameterizations result in indistinguishable patterns of heterogeneity and power distribution for resolution down to a block size of 4.5° × 4.5° and maximum spherical harmonic degree of 40. We demonstrate synthetically that a high-degree (L) inversion followed by a lower-degree (Ls) spherical harmonic synthesis effectively circumvents model contamination from expansion truncation effects. Tomographic inversion of this data set yields a global distribution of D″ heterogeneity robust up to degree 12. In our preferred model (L=40, Ls=12, rms ∼1%), surface hotspots and estimated lower mantle plume roots are located in or at edges of low-velocity regions (δVs<-2%), for both the Atlantic-Indian low-velocity corridor as well as the low velocities beneath the central Pacific. Although the above parameterizations entail no intrinsic difference in resolvability, higher resolution is regionally achieved by removing the derived degree 12 model from the data then inverting the corrected residuals using 4.5°×4.5° blocks. This hybrid method prevents power loss at intermediate to long wavelengths from otherwise severe damping and recovers smaller-scale structure where constraints are better than the global average, such as beneath the Pacific and Eurasia. A synthetic recovery test yields resolvability maps that reflect both the path geometry and the quality of data, which help to identify robust features in both the degree 12 and the hybrid D″ models.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0034474027&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0034474027&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:0034474027

VL - 105

SP - 28139

EP - 28157

JO - Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres

JF - Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres

SN - 2169-897X

IS - B12

M1 - 2000JB900334

ER -