'To and fro' the southern Andean highlands (Argentina and Chile): Archaeometric insights on geographic vectors of mobility

Victor A. Durán, Valeria Cortegoso, Ramiro Barberena, Cecilia Frigolé, Paula Novellino, Gustavo Lucero, Lucía Yebra, Alejandra Gasco, Diego Winocur, Anahí Benítez, Kelly Knudson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The Andes mountain range is one key physiographic feature of South America with the potential to have acted as a barrier and corridor for human societies. The goal of this paper is to assess from where and how were the highlands utilized during the last 2000years, which is a key period witnessing the development of productive economies and changes in the organization of mobility. We develop a regional case study focused on the highland wetland Laguna del Diamante (3300masl), which is a highly productive ecosystem only accessible during summer. This case is based on a multidisciplinary approach combining: a) geochemical characterization of obsidian sources located in the highlands and artifacts; b) isotopic approach to ranges of paleomobility of individuals by means of 87Sr/86Sr; and c) stylistic study of ceramic assemblages.The two main obsidian types from the highlands have restricted and decaying spatial distribution, suggesting that these archaeological distributions track part of human circuits of mobility instead of indirect transport acquisition. Their archaeological distribution is heavily skewed towards the western Andean slope. We present strontium isotope values for four teeth and bone samples from two individuals recovered in the area, which are interpreted in reference to a preliminary baseline of biologically available strontium. We infer that these individuals had ranges of paleomobility systematically connecting the western slope with the highlands. The analysis of the ceramic assemblages shows that most of the diagnostic sherds can be assigned to styles that have distributional cores in the Central Valley of Chile up until the time of Inca presence, while only a minimum portion of the sample can be assigned to distributional cores on the eastern slope. By integrating the patterns in the transport of obsidian and ceramic artifacts and the paleomobility of individuals, we find support for the existence of dominant access to the highlands from the western Andean slope. A GIS-based analysis of the seasonality of precipitation shows that the western slope presents more pronounced and drier summer months, providing a context that contributes to explain these patterns. These results contradict previous interpretations suggesting that the archaeological record from the highlands is more directly tied to human groups inhabiting the eastern lowlands during most of the year. Beyond the geographic debate, this issue has an impact on the subsistence organization of the incoming groups, on the socio-economic role of the highlands, and on the demographic contexts leading to trajectories of economic intensification in both Andean slopes. This research contributes to build a framework for comparative research on human use of highland environments.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalJournal of Archaeological Science: Reports
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Feb 1 2017

Fingerprint

Argentina
Chile
artifact
organization
comparative research
wetland
economics
Geographical Information System
diagnostic
Group
interpretation
economy
Highlands
society
Values
Obsidian

Keywords

  • Andean highlands
  • Ceramic styles
  • Human biogeography
  • Obsidian geochemistry
  • Stable isotopes and human paleomobility

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Archaeology
  • History
  • Archaeology

Cite this

'To and fro' the southern Andean highlands (Argentina and Chile) : Archaeometric insights on geographic vectors of mobility. / Durán, Victor A.; Cortegoso, Valeria; Barberena, Ramiro; Frigolé, Cecilia; Novellino, Paula; Lucero, Gustavo; Yebra, Lucía; Gasco, Alejandra; Winocur, Diego; Benítez, Anahí; Knudson, Kelly.

In: Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports, 01.02.2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Durán, Victor A. ; Cortegoso, Valeria ; Barberena, Ramiro ; Frigolé, Cecilia ; Novellino, Paula ; Lucero, Gustavo ; Yebra, Lucía ; Gasco, Alejandra ; Winocur, Diego ; Benítez, Anahí ; Knudson, Kelly. / 'To and fro' the southern Andean highlands (Argentina and Chile) : Archaeometric insights on geographic vectors of mobility. In: Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports. 2017.
@article{c184c2234d8f4004a8c95ec63abf4dec,
title = "'To and fro' the southern Andean highlands (Argentina and Chile): Archaeometric insights on geographic vectors of mobility",
abstract = "The Andes mountain range is one key physiographic feature of South America with the potential to have acted as a barrier and corridor for human societies. The goal of this paper is to assess from where and how were the highlands utilized during the last 2000years, which is a key period witnessing the development of productive economies and changes in the organization of mobility. We develop a regional case study focused on the highland wetland Laguna del Diamante (3300masl), which is a highly productive ecosystem only accessible during summer. This case is based on a multidisciplinary approach combining: a) geochemical characterization of obsidian sources located in the highlands and artifacts; b) isotopic approach to ranges of paleomobility of individuals by means of 87Sr/86Sr; and c) stylistic study of ceramic assemblages.The two main obsidian types from the highlands have restricted and decaying spatial distribution, suggesting that these archaeological distributions track part of human circuits of mobility instead of indirect transport acquisition. Their archaeological distribution is heavily skewed towards the western Andean slope. We present strontium isotope values for four teeth and bone samples from two individuals recovered in the area, which are interpreted in reference to a preliminary baseline of biologically available strontium. We infer that these individuals had ranges of paleomobility systematically connecting the western slope with the highlands. The analysis of the ceramic assemblages shows that most of the diagnostic sherds can be assigned to styles that have distributional cores in the Central Valley of Chile up until the time of Inca presence, while only a minimum portion of the sample can be assigned to distributional cores on the eastern slope. By integrating the patterns in the transport of obsidian and ceramic artifacts and the paleomobility of individuals, we find support for the existence of dominant access to the highlands from the western Andean slope. A GIS-based analysis of the seasonality of precipitation shows that the western slope presents more pronounced and drier summer months, providing a context that contributes to explain these patterns. These results contradict previous interpretations suggesting that the archaeological record from the highlands is more directly tied to human groups inhabiting the eastern lowlands during most of the year. Beyond the geographic debate, this issue has an impact on the subsistence organization of the incoming groups, on the socio-economic role of the highlands, and on the demographic contexts leading to trajectories of economic intensification in both Andean slopes. This research contributes to build a framework for comparative research on human use of highland environments.",
keywords = "Andean highlands, Ceramic styles, Human biogeography, Obsidian geochemistry, Stable isotopes and human paleomobility",
author = "Dur{\'a}n, {Victor A.} and Valeria Cortegoso and Ramiro Barberena and Cecilia Frigol{\'e} and Paula Novellino and Gustavo Lucero and Luc{\'i}a Yebra and Alejandra Gasco and Diego Winocur and Anah{\'i} Ben{\'i}tez and Kelly Knudson",
year = "2017",
month = "2",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.jasrep.2017.05.047",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports",
issn = "2352-409X",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - 'To and fro' the southern Andean highlands (Argentina and Chile)

T2 - Archaeometric insights on geographic vectors of mobility

AU - Durán, Victor A.

AU - Cortegoso, Valeria

AU - Barberena, Ramiro

AU - Frigolé, Cecilia

AU - Novellino, Paula

AU - Lucero, Gustavo

AU - Yebra, Lucía

AU - Gasco, Alejandra

AU - Winocur, Diego

AU - Benítez, Anahí

AU - Knudson, Kelly

PY - 2017/2/1

Y1 - 2017/2/1

N2 - The Andes mountain range is one key physiographic feature of South America with the potential to have acted as a barrier and corridor for human societies. The goal of this paper is to assess from where and how were the highlands utilized during the last 2000years, which is a key period witnessing the development of productive economies and changes in the organization of mobility. We develop a regional case study focused on the highland wetland Laguna del Diamante (3300masl), which is a highly productive ecosystem only accessible during summer. This case is based on a multidisciplinary approach combining: a) geochemical characterization of obsidian sources located in the highlands and artifacts; b) isotopic approach to ranges of paleomobility of individuals by means of 87Sr/86Sr; and c) stylistic study of ceramic assemblages.The two main obsidian types from the highlands have restricted and decaying spatial distribution, suggesting that these archaeological distributions track part of human circuits of mobility instead of indirect transport acquisition. Their archaeological distribution is heavily skewed towards the western Andean slope. We present strontium isotope values for four teeth and bone samples from two individuals recovered in the area, which are interpreted in reference to a preliminary baseline of biologically available strontium. We infer that these individuals had ranges of paleomobility systematically connecting the western slope with the highlands. The analysis of the ceramic assemblages shows that most of the diagnostic sherds can be assigned to styles that have distributional cores in the Central Valley of Chile up until the time of Inca presence, while only a minimum portion of the sample can be assigned to distributional cores on the eastern slope. By integrating the patterns in the transport of obsidian and ceramic artifacts and the paleomobility of individuals, we find support for the existence of dominant access to the highlands from the western Andean slope. A GIS-based analysis of the seasonality of precipitation shows that the western slope presents more pronounced and drier summer months, providing a context that contributes to explain these patterns. These results contradict previous interpretations suggesting that the archaeological record from the highlands is more directly tied to human groups inhabiting the eastern lowlands during most of the year. Beyond the geographic debate, this issue has an impact on the subsistence organization of the incoming groups, on the socio-economic role of the highlands, and on the demographic contexts leading to trajectories of economic intensification in both Andean slopes. This research contributes to build a framework for comparative research on human use of highland environments.

AB - The Andes mountain range is one key physiographic feature of South America with the potential to have acted as a barrier and corridor for human societies. The goal of this paper is to assess from where and how were the highlands utilized during the last 2000years, which is a key period witnessing the development of productive economies and changes in the organization of mobility. We develop a regional case study focused on the highland wetland Laguna del Diamante (3300masl), which is a highly productive ecosystem only accessible during summer. This case is based on a multidisciplinary approach combining: a) geochemical characterization of obsidian sources located in the highlands and artifacts; b) isotopic approach to ranges of paleomobility of individuals by means of 87Sr/86Sr; and c) stylistic study of ceramic assemblages.The two main obsidian types from the highlands have restricted and decaying spatial distribution, suggesting that these archaeological distributions track part of human circuits of mobility instead of indirect transport acquisition. Their archaeological distribution is heavily skewed towards the western Andean slope. We present strontium isotope values for four teeth and bone samples from two individuals recovered in the area, which are interpreted in reference to a preliminary baseline of biologically available strontium. We infer that these individuals had ranges of paleomobility systematically connecting the western slope with the highlands. The analysis of the ceramic assemblages shows that most of the diagnostic sherds can be assigned to styles that have distributional cores in the Central Valley of Chile up until the time of Inca presence, while only a minimum portion of the sample can be assigned to distributional cores on the eastern slope. By integrating the patterns in the transport of obsidian and ceramic artifacts and the paleomobility of individuals, we find support for the existence of dominant access to the highlands from the western Andean slope. A GIS-based analysis of the seasonality of precipitation shows that the western slope presents more pronounced and drier summer months, providing a context that contributes to explain these patterns. These results contradict previous interpretations suggesting that the archaeological record from the highlands is more directly tied to human groups inhabiting the eastern lowlands during most of the year. Beyond the geographic debate, this issue has an impact on the subsistence organization of the incoming groups, on the socio-economic role of the highlands, and on the demographic contexts leading to trajectories of economic intensification in both Andean slopes. This research contributes to build a framework for comparative research on human use of highland environments.

KW - Andean highlands

KW - Ceramic styles

KW - Human biogeography

KW - Obsidian geochemistry

KW - Stable isotopes and human paleomobility

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85020129850&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85020129850&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.jasrep.2017.05.047

DO - 10.1016/j.jasrep.2017.05.047

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85020129850

JO - Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports

JF - Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports

SN - 2352-409X

ER -