The morality, politics, and irony of war: Recovering Reinhold Niebuhr's ethical realism

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

9 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The American experience of war is ironic. That is, there is often an intimate and unexamined relationship between seemingly contrary elements in war such as morality and politics. This article argues that without understanding such irony, we are unlikely to reflect in morally comprehensive ways on past, present, or future wars. Traditional schools of thought, however, such as moralism and political realism, reinforce these apparent contradictions. I propose, then, an alternative - "ethical realism" as informed by Reinhold Niebuhr - that better explains the irony of war. Through an ethical realist examination of the U.S. Civil War, World War II, and the Iraq War, I consider how American political interests have been inextricably linked with deep moral concerns. Ethical realism charts a middle path that ennobles traditional realpolitik while eschewing certain perfectionist tendencies of moralism. Ethical realism provides a conceptual framework for evaluating these other frameworks - a distinct form of moral-political deliberation about war.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)619-651
Number of pages33
JournalJournal of Religious Ethics
Volume36
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 2008

Fingerprint

Realism
Irony
Morality
Reinhold Niebuhr
Moralism
Charts
Schools of Thought
Second World War
Iraq War
Political Realism
Conceptual Framework
Civil War
Deliberation
Realist

Keywords

  • Ethical realism
  • Iraq war
  • Just war
  • Moralism
  • Reinhold Niebuhr
  • U.S. civil war
  • World war II

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Religious studies

Cite this

The morality, politics, and irony of war : Recovering Reinhold Niebuhr's ethical realism. / Carlson, John.

In: Journal of Religious Ethics, Vol. 36, No. 4, 12.2008, p. 619-651.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{3e4cf3ece8604906826482b68cec38d7,
title = "The morality, politics, and irony of war: Recovering Reinhold Niebuhr's ethical realism",
abstract = "The American experience of war is ironic. That is, there is often an intimate and unexamined relationship between seemingly contrary elements in war such as morality and politics. This article argues that without understanding such irony, we are unlikely to reflect in morally comprehensive ways on past, present, or future wars. Traditional schools of thought, however, such as moralism and political realism, reinforce these apparent contradictions. I propose, then, an alternative - {"}ethical realism{"} as informed by Reinhold Niebuhr - that better explains the irony of war. Through an ethical realist examination of the U.S. Civil War, World War II, and the Iraq War, I consider how American political interests have been inextricably linked with deep moral concerns. Ethical realism charts a middle path that ennobles traditional realpolitik while eschewing certain perfectionist tendencies of moralism. Ethical realism provides a conceptual framework for evaluating these other frameworks - a distinct form of moral-political deliberation about war.",
keywords = "Ethical realism, Iraq war, Just war, Moralism, Reinhold Niebuhr, U.S. civil war, World war II",
author = "John Carlson",
year = "2008",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1111/j.1467-9795.2008.00365.x",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "36",
pages = "619--651",
journal = "Journal of Religious Ethics",
issn = "0384-9694",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The morality, politics, and irony of war

T2 - Recovering Reinhold Niebuhr's ethical realism

AU - Carlson, John

PY - 2008/12

Y1 - 2008/12

N2 - The American experience of war is ironic. That is, there is often an intimate and unexamined relationship between seemingly contrary elements in war such as morality and politics. This article argues that without understanding such irony, we are unlikely to reflect in morally comprehensive ways on past, present, or future wars. Traditional schools of thought, however, such as moralism and political realism, reinforce these apparent contradictions. I propose, then, an alternative - "ethical realism" as informed by Reinhold Niebuhr - that better explains the irony of war. Through an ethical realist examination of the U.S. Civil War, World War II, and the Iraq War, I consider how American political interests have been inextricably linked with deep moral concerns. Ethical realism charts a middle path that ennobles traditional realpolitik while eschewing certain perfectionist tendencies of moralism. Ethical realism provides a conceptual framework for evaluating these other frameworks - a distinct form of moral-political deliberation about war.

AB - The American experience of war is ironic. That is, there is often an intimate and unexamined relationship between seemingly contrary elements in war such as morality and politics. This article argues that without understanding such irony, we are unlikely to reflect in morally comprehensive ways on past, present, or future wars. Traditional schools of thought, however, such as moralism and political realism, reinforce these apparent contradictions. I propose, then, an alternative - "ethical realism" as informed by Reinhold Niebuhr - that better explains the irony of war. Through an ethical realist examination of the U.S. Civil War, World War II, and the Iraq War, I consider how American political interests have been inextricably linked with deep moral concerns. Ethical realism charts a middle path that ennobles traditional realpolitik while eschewing certain perfectionist tendencies of moralism. Ethical realism provides a conceptual framework for evaluating these other frameworks - a distinct form of moral-political deliberation about war.

KW - Ethical realism

KW - Iraq war

KW - Just war

KW - Moralism

KW - Reinhold Niebuhr

KW - U.S. civil war

KW - World war II

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=61149138094&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=61149138094&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/j.1467-9795.2008.00365.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1467-9795.2008.00365.x

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:61149138094

VL - 36

SP - 619

EP - 651

JO - Journal of Religious Ethics

JF - Journal of Religious Ethics

SN - 0384-9694

IS - 4

ER -