The hydrogen epoch of reionization array dish III: measuring chromaticity of prototype element with reflectometry

Nipanjana Patra, Aaron R. Parsons, David R. DeBoer, Nithyanandan Thyagarajan, Aaron Ewall-Wice, Gilbert Hsyu, Tsz Kuk Leung, Cherie K. Day, Eloy de Lera Acedo, James E. Aguirre, Paul Alexander, Zaki S. Ali, Adam P. Beardsley, Judd Bowman, Richard F. Bradley, Chris L. Carilli, Carina Cheng, Joshua S. Dillon, Gcobisa Fadana, Nicolas FagnoniRandall Fritz, Steve R. Furlanetto, Brian Glendenning, Bradley Greig, Jasper Grobbelaar, Bryna J. Hazelton, Daniel Jacobs, Austin Julius, Mac Calvin Kariseb, Saul A. Kohn, Anna Lebedeva, Telalo Lekalake, Adrian Liu, Anita Loots, David MacMahon, Lourence Malan, Cresshim Malgas, Matthys Maree, Zachary Martinot, Nathan Mathison, Eunice Matsetela, Andrei Mesinger, Miguel F. Morales, Abraham R. Neben, Samantha Pieterse, Jonathan C. Pober, Nima Razavi-Ghods, Jon Ringuette, James Robnett, Kathryn Rosie, Raddwine Sell, Craig Smith, Angelo Syce, Max Tegmark, Peter K.G. Williams, Haoxuan Zheng

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Spectral structures due to the instrument response is the current limiting factor for the experiments attempting to detect the redshifted 21 cm signal from the Epoch of Reionization (EoR). Recent advances in the delay spectrum methodology for measuring the redshifted 21 cm EoR power spectrum brought new attention to the impact of an antenna’s frequency response on the viability of making this challenging measurement. The delay spectrum methodology provides a somewhat straightforward relationship between the time-domain response of an instrument that can be directly measured and the power spectrum modes accessible to a 21 cm EoR experiment. In this paper, we derive the explicit relationship between antenna reflection coefficient (S11) measurements made by a Vector Network Analyzer (VNA) and the extent of additional foreground contaminations in delay space. In the light of this mathematical framework, we examine the chromaticity of a prototype antenna element that will constitute the Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array (HERA) between 100 and 200 MHz. These reflectometry measurements exhibit additional structures relative to electromagnetic simulations, but we find that even without any further design improvement, such an antenna element will support measuring spatial k modes with line-of-sight components of k > 0.2h Mpc− 1. We also find that when combined with the powerful inverse covariance weighting method used in optimal quadratic estimation of redshifted 21 cm power spectra the HERA prototype elements can successfully measure the power spectrum at spatial modes as low as k > 0.1h Mpc− 1. This work represents a major step toward understanding the HERA antenna element and highlights a straightforward method for characterizing instrument response for future experiments designed to detect the 21 cm EoR power spectrum.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)177-199
Number of pages23
JournalExperimental Astronomy
Volume45
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 1 2018

Fingerprint

reflectometry
parabolic reflectors
prototypes
time measurement
hydrogen
antenna
power spectra
antennas
methodology
experiment
antenna arrays
measuring
viability
limiting factor
frequency response
line of sight
analyzers
contamination
electromagnetism
reflectance

Keywords

  • 21 cm cosmology
  • Astronomical instrumentation
  • Delay spectrum technique–EoR power spectrum
  • Methods and techniques
  • wideband radio interferometry

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • Space and Planetary Science

Cite this

Patra, N., Parsons, A. R., DeBoer, D. R., Thyagarajan, N., Ewall-Wice, A., Hsyu, G., ... Zheng, H. (2018). The hydrogen epoch of reionization array dish III: measuring chromaticity of prototype element with reflectometry. Experimental Astronomy, 45(2), 177-199. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10686-017-9563-0

The hydrogen epoch of reionization array dish III : measuring chromaticity of prototype element with reflectometry. / Patra, Nipanjana; Parsons, Aaron R.; DeBoer, David R.; Thyagarajan, Nithyanandan; Ewall-Wice, Aaron; Hsyu, Gilbert; Leung, Tsz Kuk; Day, Cherie K.; de Lera Acedo, Eloy; Aguirre, James E.; Alexander, Paul; Ali, Zaki S.; Beardsley, Adam P.; Bowman, Judd; Bradley, Richard F.; Carilli, Chris L.; Cheng, Carina; Dillon, Joshua S.; Fadana, Gcobisa; Fagnoni, Nicolas; Fritz, Randall; Furlanetto, Steve R.; Glendenning, Brian; Greig, Bradley; Grobbelaar, Jasper; Hazelton, Bryna J.; Jacobs, Daniel; Julius, Austin; Kariseb, Mac Calvin; Kohn, Saul A.; Lebedeva, Anna; Lekalake, Telalo; Liu, Adrian; Loots, Anita; MacMahon, David; Malan, Lourence; Malgas, Cresshim; Maree, Matthys; Martinot, Zachary; Mathison, Nathan; Matsetela, Eunice; Mesinger, Andrei; Morales, Miguel F.; Neben, Abraham R.; Pieterse, Samantha; Pober, Jonathan C.; Razavi-Ghods, Nima; Ringuette, Jon; Robnett, James; Rosie, Kathryn; Sell, Raddwine; Smith, Craig; Syce, Angelo; Tegmark, Max; Williams, Peter K.G.; Zheng, Haoxuan.

In: Experimental Astronomy, Vol. 45, No. 2, 01.04.2018, p. 177-199.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Patra, N, Parsons, AR, DeBoer, DR, Thyagarajan, N, Ewall-Wice, A, Hsyu, G, Leung, TK, Day, CK, de Lera Acedo, E, Aguirre, JE, Alexander, P, Ali, ZS, Beardsley, AP, Bowman, J, Bradley, RF, Carilli, CL, Cheng, C, Dillon, JS, Fadana, G, Fagnoni, N, Fritz, R, Furlanetto, SR, Glendenning, B, Greig, B, Grobbelaar, J, Hazelton, BJ, Jacobs, D, Julius, A, Kariseb, MC, Kohn, SA, Lebedeva, A, Lekalake, T, Liu, A, Loots, A, MacMahon, D, Malan, L, Malgas, C, Maree, M, Martinot, Z, Mathison, N, Matsetela, E, Mesinger, A, Morales, MF, Neben, AR, Pieterse, S, Pober, JC, Razavi-Ghods, N, Ringuette, J, Robnett, J, Rosie, K, Sell, R, Smith, C, Syce, A, Tegmark, M, Williams, PKG & Zheng, H 2018, 'The hydrogen epoch of reionization array dish III: measuring chromaticity of prototype element with reflectometry', Experimental Astronomy, vol. 45, no. 2, pp. 177-199. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10686-017-9563-0
Patra, Nipanjana ; Parsons, Aaron R. ; DeBoer, David R. ; Thyagarajan, Nithyanandan ; Ewall-Wice, Aaron ; Hsyu, Gilbert ; Leung, Tsz Kuk ; Day, Cherie K. ; de Lera Acedo, Eloy ; Aguirre, James E. ; Alexander, Paul ; Ali, Zaki S. ; Beardsley, Adam P. ; Bowman, Judd ; Bradley, Richard F. ; Carilli, Chris L. ; Cheng, Carina ; Dillon, Joshua S. ; Fadana, Gcobisa ; Fagnoni, Nicolas ; Fritz, Randall ; Furlanetto, Steve R. ; Glendenning, Brian ; Greig, Bradley ; Grobbelaar, Jasper ; Hazelton, Bryna J. ; Jacobs, Daniel ; Julius, Austin ; Kariseb, Mac Calvin ; Kohn, Saul A. ; Lebedeva, Anna ; Lekalake, Telalo ; Liu, Adrian ; Loots, Anita ; MacMahon, David ; Malan, Lourence ; Malgas, Cresshim ; Maree, Matthys ; Martinot, Zachary ; Mathison, Nathan ; Matsetela, Eunice ; Mesinger, Andrei ; Morales, Miguel F. ; Neben, Abraham R. ; Pieterse, Samantha ; Pober, Jonathan C. ; Razavi-Ghods, Nima ; Ringuette, Jon ; Robnett, James ; Rosie, Kathryn ; Sell, Raddwine ; Smith, Craig ; Syce, Angelo ; Tegmark, Max ; Williams, Peter K.G. ; Zheng, Haoxuan. / The hydrogen epoch of reionization array dish III : measuring chromaticity of prototype element with reflectometry. In: Experimental Astronomy. 2018 ; Vol. 45, No. 2. pp. 177-199.
@article{8bf9fe10878b45c7af8ca955190d8954,
title = "The hydrogen epoch of reionization array dish III: measuring chromaticity of prototype element with reflectometry",
abstract = "Spectral structures due to the instrument response is the current limiting factor for the experiments attempting to detect the redshifted 21 cm signal from the Epoch of Reionization (EoR). Recent advances in the delay spectrum methodology for measuring the redshifted 21 cm EoR power spectrum brought new attention to the impact of an antenna’s frequency response on the viability of making this challenging measurement. The delay spectrum methodology provides a somewhat straightforward relationship between the time-domain response of an instrument that can be directly measured and the power spectrum modes accessible to a 21 cm EoR experiment. In this paper, we derive the explicit relationship between antenna reflection coefficient (S11) measurements made by a Vector Network Analyzer (VNA) and the extent of additional foreground contaminations in delay space. In the light of this mathematical framework, we examine the chromaticity of a prototype antenna element that will constitute the Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array (HERA) between 100 and 200 MHz. These reflectometry measurements exhibit additional structures relative to electromagnetic simulations, but we find that even without any further design improvement, such an antenna element will support measuring spatial k modes with line-of-sight components of k∥ > 0.2h Mpc− 1. We also find that when combined with the powerful inverse covariance weighting method used in optimal quadratic estimation of redshifted 21 cm power spectra the HERA prototype elements can successfully measure the power spectrum at spatial modes as low as k∥ > 0.1h Mpc− 1. This work represents a major step toward understanding the HERA antenna element and highlights a straightforward method for characterizing instrument response for future experiments designed to detect the 21 cm EoR power spectrum.",
keywords = "21 cm cosmology, Astronomical instrumentation, Delay spectrum technique–EoR power spectrum, Methods and techniques, wideband radio interferometry",
author = "Nipanjana Patra and Parsons, {Aaron R.} and DeBoer, {David R.} and Nithyanandan Thyagarajan and Aaron Ewall-Wice and Gilbert Hsyu and Leung, {Tsz Kuk} and Day, {Cherie K.} and {de Lera Acedo}, Eloy and Aguirre, {James E.} and Paul Alexander and Ali, {Zaki S.} and Beardsley, {Adam P.} and Judd Bowman and Bradley, {Richard F.} and Carilli, {Chris L.} and Carina Cheng and Dillon, {Joshua S.} and Gcobisa Fadana and Nicolas Fagnoni and Randall Fritz and Furlanetto, {Steve R.} and Brian Glendenning and Bradley Greig and Jasper Grobbelaar and Hazelton, {Bryna J.} and Daniel Jacobs and Austin Julius and Kariseb, {Mac Calvin} and Kohn, {Saul A.} and Anna Lebedeva and Telalo Lekalake and Adrian Liu and Anita Loots and David MacMahon and Lourence Malan and Cresshim Malgas and Matthys Maree and Zachary Martinot and Nathan Mathison and Eunice Matsetela and Andrei Mesinger and Morales, {Miguel F.} and Neben, {Abraham R.} and Samantha Pieterse and Pober, {Jonathan C.} and Nima Razavi-Ghods and Jon Ringuette and James Robnett and Kathryn Rosie and Raddwine Sell and Craig Smith and Angelo Syce and Max Tegmark and Williams, {Peter K.G.} and Haoxuan Zheng",
year = "2018",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s10686-017-9563-0",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "45",
pages = "177--199",
journal = "Experimental Astronomy",
issn = "0922-6435",
publisher = "Springer Netherlands",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The hydrogen epoch of reionization array dish III

T2 - measuring chromaticity of prototype element with reflectometry

AU - Patra, Nipanjana

AU - Parsons, Aaron R.

AU - DeBoer, David R.

AU - Thyagarajan, Nithyanandan

AU - Ewall-Wice, Aaron

AU - Hsyu, Gilbert

AU - Leung, Tsz Kuk

AU - Day, Cherie K.

AU - de Lera Acedo, Eloy

AU - Aguirre, James E.

AU - Alexander, Paul

AU - Ali, Zaki S.

AU - Beardsley, Adam P.

AU - Bowman, Judd

AU - Bradley, Richard F.

AU - Carilli, Chris L.

AU - Cheng, Carina

AU - Dillon, Joshua S.

AU - Fadana, Gcobisa

AU - Fagnoni, Nicolas

AU - Fritz, Randall

AU - Furlanetto, Steve R.

AU - Glendenning, Brian

AU - Greig, Bradley

AU - Grobbelaar, Jasper

AU - Hazelton, Bryna J.

AU - Jacobs, Daniel

AU - Julius, Austin

AU - Kariseb, Mac Calvin

AU - Kohn, Saul A.

AU - Lebedeva, Anna

AU - Lekalake, Telalo

AU - Liu, Adrian

AU - Loots, Anita

AU - MacMahon, David

AU - Malan, Lourence

AU - Malgas, Cresshim

AU - Maree, Matthys

AU - Martinot, Zachary

AU - Mathison, Nathan

AU - Matsetela, Eunice

AU - Mesinger, Andrei

AU - Morales, Miguel F.

AU - Neben, Abraham R.

AU - Pieterse, Samantha

AU - Pober, Jonathan C.

AU - Razavi-Ghods, Nima

AU - Ringuette, Jon

AU - Robnett, James

AU - Rosie, Kathryn

AU - Sell, Raddwine

AU - Smith, Craig

AU - Syce, Angelo

AU - Tegmark, Max

AU - Williams, Peter K.G.

AU - Zheng, Haoxuan

PY - 2018/4/1

Y1 - 2018/4/1

N2 - Spectral structures due to the instrument response is the current limiting factor for the experiments attempting to detect the redshifted 21 cm signal from the Epoch of Reionization (EoR). Recent advances in the delay spectrum methodology for measuring the redshifted 21 cm EoR power spectrum brought new attention to the impact of an antenna’s frequency response on the viability of making this challenging measurement. The delay spectrum methodology provides a somewhat straightforward relationship between the time-domain response of an instrument that can be directly measured and the power spectrum modes accessible to a 21 cm EoR experiment. In this paper, we derive the explicit relationship between antenna reflection coefficient (S11) measurements made by a Vector Network Analyzer (VNA) and the extent of additional foreground contaminations in delay space. In the light of this mathematical framework, we examine the chromaticity of a prototype antenna element that will constitute the Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array (HERA) between 100 and 200 MHz. These reflectometry measurements exhibit additional structures relative to electromagnetic simulations, but we find that even without any further design improvement, such an antenna element will support measuring spatial k modes with line-of-sight components of k∥ > 0.2h Mpc− 1. We also find that when combined with the powerful inverse covariance weighting method used in optimal quadratic estimation of redshifted 21 cm power spectra the HERA prototype elements can successfully measure the power spectrum at spatial modes as low as k∥ > 0.1h Mpc− 1. This work represents a major step toward understanding the HERA antenna element and highlights a straightforward method for characterizing instrument response for future experiments designed to detect the 21 cm EoR power spectrum.

AB - Spectral structures due to the instrument response is the current limiting factor for the experiments attempting to detect the redshifted 21 cm signal from the Epoch of Reionization (EoR). Recent advances in the delay spectrum methodology for measuring the redshifted 21 cm EoR power spectrum brought new attention to the impact of an antenna’s frequency response on the viability of making this challenging measurement. The delay spectrum methodology provides a somewhat straightforward relationship between the time-domain response of an instrument that can be directly measured and the power spectrum modes accessible to a 21 cm EoR experiment. In this paper, we derive the explicit relationship between antenna reflection coefficient (S11) measurements made by a Vector Network Analyzer (VNA) and the extent of additional foreground contaminations in delay space. In the light of this mathematical framework, we examine the chromaticity of a prototype antenna element that will constitute the Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array (HERA) between 100 and 200 MHz. These reflectometry measurements exhibit additional structures relative to electromagnetic simulations, but we find that even without any further design improvement, such an antenna element will support measuring spatial k modes with line-of-sight components of k∥ > 0.2h Mpc− 1. We also find that when combined with the powerful inverse covariance weighting method used in optimal quadratic estimation of redshifted 21 cm power spectra the HERA prototype elements can successfully measure the power spectrum at spatial modes as low as k∥ > 0.1h Mpc− 1. This work represents a major step toward understanding the HERA antenna element and highlights a straightforward method for characterizing instrument response for future experiments designed to detect the 21 cm EoR power spectrum.

KW - 21 cm cosmology

KW - Astronomical instrumentation

KW - Delay spectrum technique–EoR power spectrum

KW - Methods and techniques

KW - wideband radio interferometry

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85045044446&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85045044446&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s10686-017-9563-0

DO - 10.1007/s10686-017-9563-0

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85045044446

VL - 45

SP - 177

EP - 199

JO - Experimental Astronomy

JF - Experimental Astronomy

SN - 0922-6435

IS - 2

ER -