Somitogenesis in the anole lizard and alligator reveals evolutionary convergence and divergence in the amniote segmentation clock

Walter L. Eckalbar, Eris Lasku, Carlos R. Infante, Ruth M. Elsey, Glenn J. Markov, April N. Allen, Jason J. Corneveaux, Jonathan B. Losos, Dale F. DeNardo, Matthew J. Huentelman, Jeanne Wilson-Rawls, Alan Rawls, Kenro Kusumi

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

34 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The axial skeleton is a defining feature of vertebrates and is patterned during somitogenesis. Cyclically expressed members of the notch and other signaling pathways, described as the 'segmentation clock', regulate the formation of somite boundaries. Comparisons among vertebrate model systems have revealed fundamental shifts in the regulation of expression among critical genes in the notch pathway. However, insights into the evolution of these expression differences have been limited by the lack of information from non-avian reptiles. We analyzed the segmentation clock of the first Lepidosaurian reptile sequenced, the green anole lizard, Anolis carolinensis, for comparison with avian and mammalian models. Using genomic sequence, RNA-Seq transcriptomic data, and in situ hybridization analysis of somite-stage embryos, we carried out comparative analyses of key genes and found that the anole segmentation clock displays features common to both amniote and anamniote vertebrates. Shared features with anamniotes, represented by Xenopus laevis and Danio rerio, include an absence of lunatic fringe (lfng) expression within the presomitic mesoderm (PSM), a hes6a gradient in the PSM not observed in the chicken or mouse, and EGF repeat structure of the divergent notch ligand, dll3. The anole and mouse share cycling expression of dll1 ligand in the PSM. To gain insight from an Archosaurian reptile, we analysed LFNG and DLL1 expressions in the American alligator. LFNG expression was absent in the alligator PSM, like the anole but unlike the chicken. In contrast, DLL1 expression does not cycle in the PSM of the alligator, similar to the chicken but unlike the anole. Thus, our analysis yields novel insights into features of the segmentation clock that are evolutionarily basal to amniotes versus those that are specific to mammals, Lepidosaurian reptiles, or Archosaurian reptiles.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)308-319
Number of pages12
JournalDevelopmental Biology
Volume363
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1 2012

Fingerprint

Alligators and Crocodiles
Reptiles
Lizards
Mesoderm
Vertebrates
Chickens
Somites
Ligands
Xenopus laevis
Zebrafish
Epidermal Growth Factor
Skeleton
Genes
In Situ Hybridization
Mammals
Embryonic Structures

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Developmental Biology
  • Cell Biology
  • Molecular Biology

Cite this

Somitogenesis in the anole lizard and alligator reveals evolutionary convergence and divergence in the amniote segmentation clock. / Eckalbar, Walter L.; Lasku, Eris; Infante, Carlos R.; Elsey, Ruth M.; Markov, Glenn J.; Allen, April N.; Corneveaux, Jason J.; Losos, Jonathan B.; DeNardo, Dale F.; Huentelman, Matthew J.; Wilson-Rawls, Jeanne; Rawls, Alan; Kusumi, Kenro.

In: Developmental Biology, Vol. 363, No. 1, 01.03.2012, p. 308-319.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Eckalbar, Walter L. ; Lasku, Eris ; Infante, Carlos R. ; Elsey, Ruth M. ; Markov, Glenn J. ; Allen, April N. ; Corneveaux, Jason J. ; Losos, Jonathan B. ; DeNardo, Dale F. ; Huentelman, Matthew J. ; Wilson-Rawls, Jeanne ; Rawls, Alan ; Kusumi, Kenro. / Somitogenesis in the anole lizard and alligator reveals evolutionary convergence and divergence in the amniote segmentation clock. In: Developmental Biology. 2012 ; Vol. 363, No. 1. pp. 308-319.
@article{bdc886d7eb9140019994bdc9b741ac38,
title = "Somitogenesis in the anole lizard and alligator reveals evolutionary convergence and divergence in the amniote segmentation clock",
abstract = "The axial skeleton is a defining feature of vertebrates and is patterned during somitogenesis. Cyclically expressed members of the notch and other signaling pathways, described as the 'segmentation clock', regulate the formation of somite boundaries. Comparisons among vertebrate model systems have revealed fundamental shifts in the regulation of expression among critical genes in the notch pathway. However, insights into the evolution of these expression differences have been limited by the lack of information from non-avian reptiles. We analyzed the segmentation clock of the first Lepidosaurian reptile sequenced, the green anole lizard, Anolis carolinensis, for comparison with avian and mammalian models. Using genomic sequence, RNA-Seq transcriptomic data, and in situ hybridization analysis of somite-stage embryos, we carried out comparative analyses of key genes and found that the anole segmentation clock displays features common to both amniote and anamniote vertebrates. Shared features with anamniotes, represented by Xenopus laevis and Danio rerio, include an absence of lunatic fringe (lfng) expression within the presomitic mesoderm (PSM), a hes6a gradient in the PSM not observed in the chicken or mouse, and EGF repeat structure of the divergent notch ligand, dll3. The anole and mouse share cycling expression of dll1 ligand in the PSM. To gain insight from an Archosaurian reptile, we analysed LFNG and DLL1 expressions in the American alligator. LFNG expression was absent in the alligator PSM, like the anole but unlike the chicken. In contrast, DLL1 expression does not cycle in the PSM of the alligator, similar to the chicken but unlike the anole. Thus, our analysis yields novel insights into features of the segmentation clock that are evolutionarily basal to amniotes versus those that are specific to mammals, Lepidosaurian reptiles, or Archosaurian reptiles.",
author = "Eckalbar, {Walter L.} and Eris Lasku and Infante, {Carlos R.} and Elsey, {Ruth M.} and Markov, {Glenn J.} and Allen, {April N.} and Corneveaux, {Jason J.} and Losos, {Jonathan B.} and DeNardo, {Dale F.} and Huentelman, {Matthew J.} and Jeanne Wilson-Rawls and Alan Rawls and Kenro Kusumi",
year = "2012",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.ydbio.2011.11.021",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "363",
pages = "308--319",
journal = "Developmental Biology",
issn = "0012-1606",
publisher = "Academic Press Inc.",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Somitogenesis in the anole lizard and alligator reveals evolutionary convergence and divergence in the amniote segmentation clock

AU - Eckalbar, Walter L.

AU - Lasku, Eris

AU - Infante, Carlos R.

AU - Elsey, Ruth M.

AU - Markov, Glenn J.

AU - Allen, April N.

AU - Corneveaux, Jason J.

AU - Losos, Jonathan B.

AU - DeNardo, Dale F.

AU - Huentelman, Matthew J.

AU - Wilson-Rawls, Jeanne

AU - Rawls, Alan

AU - Kusumi, Kenro

PY - 2012/3/1

Y1 - 2012/3/1

N2 - The axial skeleton is a defining feature of vertebrates and is patterned during somitogenesis. Cyclically expressed members of the notch and other signaling pathways, described as the 'segmentation clock', regulate the formation of somite boundaries. Comparisons among vertebrate model systems have revealed fundamental shifts in the regulation of expression among critical genes in the notch pathway. However, insights into the evolution of these expression differences have been limited by the lack of information from non-avian reptiles. We analyzed the segmentation clock of the first Lepidosaurian reptile sequenced, the green anole lizard, Anolis carolinensis, for comparison with avian and mammalian models. Using genomic sequence, RNA-Seq transcriptomic data, and in situ hybridization analysis of somite-stage embryos, we carried out comparative analyses of key genes and found that the anole segmentation clock displays features common to both amniote and anamniote vertebrates. Shared features with anamniotes, represented by Xenopus laevis and Danio rerio, include an absence of lunatic fringe (lfng) expression within the presomitic mesoderm (PSM), a hes6a gradient in the PSM not observed in the chicken or mouse, and EGF repeat structure of the divergent notch ligand, dll3. The anole and mouse share cycling expression of dll1 ligand in the PSM. To gain insight from an Archosaurian reptile, we analysed LFNG and DLL1 expressions in the American alligator. LFNG expression was absent in the alligator PSM, like the anole but unlike the chicken. In contrast, DLL1 expression does not cycle in the PSM of the alligator, similar to the chicken but unlike the anole. Thus, our analysis yields novel insights into features of the segmentation clock that are evolutionarily basal to amniotes versus those that are specific to mammals, Lepidosaurian reptiles, or Archosaurian reptiles.

AB - The axial skeleton is a defining feature of vertebrates and is patterned during somitogenesis. Cyclically expressed members of the notch and other signaling pathways, described as the 'segmentation clock', regulate the formation of somite boundaries. Comparisons among vertebrate model systems have revealed fundamental shifts in the regulation of expression among critical genes in the notch pathway. However, insights into the evolution of these expression differences have been limited by the lack of information from non-avian reptiles. We analyzed the segmentation clock of the first Lepidosaurian reptile sequenced, the green anole lizard, Anolis carolinensis, for comparison with avian and mammalian models. Using genomic sequence, RNA-Seq transcriptomic data, and in situ hybridization analysis of somite-stage embryos, we carried out comparative analyses of key genes and found that the anole segmentation clock displays features common to both amniote and anamniote vertebrates. Shared features with anamniotes, represented by Xenopus laevis and Danio rerio, include an absence of lunatic fringe (lfng) expression within the presomitic mesoderm (PSM), a hes6a gradient in the PSM not observed in the chicken or mouse, and EGF repeat structure of the divergent notch ligand, dll3. The anole and mouse share cycling expression of dll1 ligand in the PSM. To gain insight from an Archosaurian reptile, we analysed LFNG and DLL1 expressions in the American alligator. LFNG expression was absent in the alligator PSM, like the anole but unlike the chicken. In contrast, DLL1 expression does not cycle in the PSM of the alligator, similar to the chicken but unlike the anole. Thus, our analysis yields novel insights into features of the segmentation clock that are evolutionarily basal to amniotes versus those that are specific to mammals, Lepidosaurian reptiles, or Archosaurian reptiles.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84857029629&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84857029629&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.ydbio.2011.11.021

DO - 10.1016/j.ydbio.2011.11.021

M3 - Article

C2 - 22178152

AN - SCOPUS:84857029629

VL - 363

SP - 308

EP - 319

JO - Developmental Biology

JF - Developmental Biology

SN - 0012-1606

IS - 1

ER -