Search for the Hidden Punishments

An Alternative Approach to Studying Alternative Sanctions

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objectives: Most existing studies of sentencing focus on the decision of whether or not to incarcerate a convicted individual. However, many cases do not involve incarceration, and there is a considerable amount of freedom to mete out alternative sanctions as part of a sentencing decision. This study addresses this gap in the literature by investigating the patterns of sentences among those individuals not sentenced to prison. Methods: This study used latent class analysis (LCA) to identify unobserved “classes” based on packages of sentences, which may involve both jail and non-incarceration alternative sanctions imposed on defendants not sentenced to prison. This study also demonstrates the potential use of LCA by (1) comparing and contrasting the results of LCA and the sentence severity scale approach, and (2) investigating how class membership could be explained by legal and extralegal characteristics of the cases. Results: LCA identified four latent classes among individuals who were not sentenced to prison, two of which could not be differentiated by the severity scale approach. Regression models demonstrated that legal variables were better at explaining the incarceration decision, whereas extralegal variables were better at explaining some of the margins between the classes. Conclusion: Compared with the incarceration models and severity scales, LCA revealed variations that could not be detected by either of the approaches. LCA also has the potential to be a helpful tool in future analysis of sentencing decisions utilizing large-scale, administrative datasets.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1-24
Number of pages24
JournalJournal of Quantitative Criminology
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Dec 24 2015
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Punishment
Prisons
sanction
penalty
Decision Support Techniques
correctional institution
class membership
regression

Keywords

  • Alternative sanctions
  • Discretion
  • Latent class analysis
  • Sentence severity scales

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Pathology and Forensic Medicine
  • Law

Cite this

@article{f5aa36263917418295f7c445306e4b9a,
title = "Search for the Hidden Punishments: An Alternative Approach to Studying Alternative Sanctions",
abstract = "Objectives: Most existing studies of sentencing focus on the decision of whether or not to incarcerate a convicted individual. However, many cases do not involve incarceration, and there is a considerable amount of freedom to mete out alternative sanctions as part of a sentencing decision. This study addresses this gap in the literature by investigating the patterns of sentences among those individuals not sentenced to prison. Methods: This study used latent class analysis (LCA) to identify unobserved “classes” based on packages of sentences, which may involve both jail and non-incarceration alternative sanctions imposed on defendants not sentenced to prison. This study also demonstrates the potential use of LCA by (1) comparing and contrasting the results of LCA and the sentence severity scale approach, and (2) investigating how class membership could be explained by legal and extralegal characteristics of the cases. Results: LCA identified four latent classes among individuals who were not sentenced to prison, two of which could not be differentiated by the severity scale approach. Regression models demonstrated that legal variables were better at explaining the incarceration decision, whereas extralegal variables were better at explaining some of the margins between the classes. Conclusion: Compared with the incarceration models and severity scales, LCA revealed variations that could not be detected by either of the approaches. LCA also has the potential to be a helpful tool in future analysis of sentencing decisions utilizing large-scale, administrative datasets.",
keywords = "Alternative sanctions, Discretion, Latent class analysis, Sentence severity scales",
author = "Shi Yan",
year = "2015",
month = "12",
day = "24",
doi = "10.1007/s10940-015-9275-4",
language = "English (US)",
pages = "1--24",
journal = "Journal of Quantitative Criminology",
issn = "0748-4518",
publisher = "Springer New York",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Search for the Hidden Punishments

T2 - An Alternative Approach to Studying Alternative Sanctions

AU - Yan, Shi

PY - 2015/12/24

Y1 - 2015/12/24

N2 - Objectives: Most existing studies of sentencing focus on the decision of whether or not to incarcerate a convicted individual. However, many cases do not involve incarceration, and there is a considerable amount of freedom to mete out alternative sanctions as part of a sentencing decision. This study addresses this gap in the literature by investigating the patterns of sentences among those individuals not sentenced to prison. Methods: This study used latent class analysis (LCA) to identify unobserved “classes” based on packages of sentences, which may involve both jail and non-incarceration alternative sanctions imposed on defendants not sentenced to prison. This study also demonstrates the potential use of LCA by (1) comparing and contrasting the results of LCA and the sentence severity scale approach, and (2) investigating how class membership could be explained by legal and extralegal characteristics of the cases. Results: LCA identified four latent classes among individuals who were not sentenced to prison, two of which could not be differentiated by the severity scale approach. Regression models demonstrated that legal variables were better at explaining the incarceration decision, whereas extralegal variables were better at explaining some of the margins between the classes. Conclusion: Compared with the incarceration models and severity scales, LCA revealed variations that could not be detected by either of the approaches. LCA also has the potential to be a helpful tool in future analysis of sentencing decisions utilizing large-scale, administrative datasets.

AB - Objectives: Most existing studies of sentencing focus on the decision of whether or not to incarcerate a convicted individual. However, many cases do not involve incarceration, and there is a considerable amount of freedom to mete out alternative sanctions as part of a sentencing decision. This study addresses this gap in the literature by investigating the patterns of sentences among those individuals not sentenced to prison. Methods: This study used latent class analysis (LCA) to identify unobserved “classes” based on packages of sentences, which may involve both jail and non-incarceration alternative sanctions imposed on defendants not sentenced to prison. This study also demonstrates the potential use of LCA by (1) comparing and contrasting the results of LCA and the sentence severity scale approach, and (2) investigating how class membership could be explained by legal and extralegal characteristics of the cases. Results: LCA identified four latent classes among individuals who were not sentenced to prison, two of which could not be differentiated by the severity scale approach. Regression models demonstrated that legal variables were better at explaining the incarceration decision, whereas extralegal variables were better at explaining some of the margins between the classes. Conclusion: Compared with the incarceration models and severity scales, LCA revealed variations that could not be detected by either of the approaches. LCA also has the potential to be a helpful tool in future analysis of sentencing decisions utilizing large-scale, administrative datasets.

KW - Alternative sanctions

KW - Discretion

KW - Latent class analysis

KW - Sentence severity scales

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84951811252&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84951811252&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s10940-015-9275-4

DO - 10.1007/s10940-015-9275-4

M3 - Article

SP - 1

EP - 24

JO - Journal of Quantitative Criminology

JF - Journal of Quantitative Criminology

SN - 0748-4518

ER -