Sacred mountains and profane dollars: Discourses about snowmaking on the San Francisco peaks

Ophir Sefiha, Pat Lauderdale

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This research examines media, interview and legal-historical documentation surrounding the current proposal to manufacture snow using reclaimed water at the Snowbowl ski area located on the San Francisco Peaks mountains near Flagstaff, Arizona. The proposal has drawn sharp protest from both American Indian Nations who call the area sacred, and environmentalists who question the safety of the reclaimed water. We examine the process by which local coalitions attempt to define environmental, spiritual, and economic values that will resonate with others. These highly mediated activities create contested territory whereby groups attempt to package and frame specific definitions of these values. This debate exposes hegemonic assumptions that aid us in deconstructing conflicting understandings of colonialism, racism, and other issues that typically go unacknowledged. Weber's discussion of rationality and commensurability is employed for understanding why sacred justice claims continue to be largely ignored. This research indicates that not only is this a case of epistemological incompatibility, but an active attempt to discredit and disenfranchise a specific group. Two interwoven themes emerged from our analysis: 'Indians as Greedy' and 'Indians as Hypocrites'. These themes are also found in the legal history of sacred site protection in the United States. We argue the fundamental lack of acknowledgement of Indian cosmology persists via a dichotomous conception of religion and civic society, which also suggests a separation of dominant forms of civic decision-making.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)491-511
Number of pages21
JournalSocial and Legal Studies
Volume17
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 2008

Fingerprint

dollar
water
discourse
incompatibility
communication research
economic value
American Indian
colonial age
racism
protest
rationality
documentation
coalition
Group
justice
Religion
decision making
lack
history
interview

Keywords

  • American Indian
  • Civic decision-making
  • Colonialism
  • Racism
  • Sacred site protection
  • Water
  • Weber

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Law
  • Social Sciences(all)
  • Sociology and Political Science

Cite this

Sacred mountains and profane dollars : Discourses about snowmaking on the San Francisco peaks. / Sefiha, Ophir; Lauderdale, Pat.

In: Social and Legal Studies, Vol. 17, No. 4, 12.2008, p. 491-511.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{9cfaee7124184d7e9211bd23c7734e33,
title = "Sacred mountains and profane dollars: Discourses about snowmaking on the San Francisco peaks",
abstract = "This research examines media, interview and legal-historical documentation surrounding the current proposal to manufacture snow using reclaimed water at the Snowbowl ski area located on the San Francisco Peaks mountains near Flagstaff, Arizona. The proposal has drawn sharp protest from both American Indian Nations who call the area sacred, and environmentalists who question the safety of the reclaimed water. We examine the process by which local coalitions attempt to define environmental, spiritual, and economic values that will resonate with others. These highly mediated activities create contested territory whereby groups attempt to package and frame specific definitions of these values. This debate exposes hegemonic assumptions that aid us in deconstructing conflicting understandings of colonialism, racism, and other issues that typically go unacknowledged. Weber's discussion of rationality and commensurability is employed for understanding why sacred justice claims continue to be largely ignored. This research indicates that not only is this a case of epistemological incompatibility, but an active attempt to discredit and disenfranchise a specific group. Two interwoven themes emerged from our analysis: 'Indians as Greedy' and 'Indians as Hypocrites'. These themes are also found in the legal history of sacred site protection in the United States. We argue the fundamental lack of acknowledgement of Indian cosmology persists via a dichotomous conception of religion and civic society, which also suggests a separation of dominant forms of civic decision-making.",
keywords = "American Indian, Civic decision-making, Colonialism, Racism, Sacred site protection, Water, Weber",
author = "Ophir Sefiha and Pat Lauderdale",
year = "2008",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1177/0964663908097082",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "17",
pages = "491--511",
journal = "Social and Legal Studies",
issn = "0964-6639",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Sacred mountains and profane dollars

T2 - Discourses about snowmaking on the San Francisco peaks

AU - Sefiha, Ophir

AU - Lauderdale, Pat

PY - 2008/12

Y1 - 2008/12

N2 - This research examines media, interview and legal-historical documentation surrounding the current proposal to manufacture snow using reclaimed water at the Snowbowl ski area located on the San Francisco Peaks mountains near Flagstaff, Arizona. The proposal has drawn sharp protest from both American Indian Nations who call the area sacred, and environmentalists who question the safety of the reclaimed water. We examine the process by which local coalitions attempt to define environmental, spiritual, and economic values that will resonate with others. These highly mediated activities create contested territory whereby groups attempt to package and frame specific definitions of these values. This debate exposes hegemonic assumptions that aid us in deconstructing conflicting understandings of colonialism, racism, and other issues that typically go unacknowledged. Weber's discussion of rationality and commensurability is employed for understanding why sacred justice claims continue to be largely ignored. This research indicates that not only is this a case of epistemological incompatibility, but an active attempt to discredit and disenfranchise a specific group. Two interwoven themes emerged from our analysis: 'Indians as Greedy' and 'Indians as Hypocrites'. These themes are also found in the legal history of sacred site protection in the United States. We argue the fundamental lack of acknowledgement of Indian cosmology persists via a dichotomous conception of religion and civic society, which also suggests a separation of dominant forms of civic decision-making.

AB - This research examines media, interview and legal-historical documentation surrounding the current proposal to manufacture snow using reclaimed water at the Snowbowl ski area located on the San Francisco Peaks mountains near Flagstaff, Arizona. The proposal has drawn sharp protest from both American Indian Nations who call the area sacred, and environmentalists who question the safety of the reclaimed water. We examine the process by which local coalitions attempt to define environmental, spiritual, and economic values that will resonate with others. These highly mediated activities create contested territory whereby groups attempt to package and frame specific definitions of these values. This debate exposes hegemonic assumptions that aid us in deconstructing conflicting understandings of colonialism, racism, and other issues that typically go unacknowledged. Weber's discussion of rationality and commensurability is employed for understanding why sacred justice claims continue to be largely ignored. This research indicates that not only is this a case of epistemological incompatibility, but an active attempt to discredit and disenfranchise a specific group. Two interwoven themes emerged from our analysis: 'Indians as Greedy' and 'Indians as Hypocrites'. These themes are also found in the legal history of sacred site protection in the United States. We argue the fundamental lack of acknowledgement of Indian cosmology persists via a dichotomous conception of religion and civic society, which also suggests a separation of dominant forms of civic decision-making.

KW - American Indian

KW - Civic decision-making

KW - Colonialism

KW - Racism

KW - Sacred site protection

KW - Water

KW - Weber

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=57549106455&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=57549106455&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/0964663908097082

DO - 10.1177/0964663908097082

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:57549106455

VL - 17

SP - 491

EP - 511

JO - Social and Legal Studies

JF - Social and Legal Studies

SN - 0964-6639

IS - 4

ER -