Reply to 'Comment on "The beginnings of hydrous mantle wedge melting" by Till et al.' by Stalder

Christy Till, Timothy L. Grove, Anthony C. Withers

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The comment of Stalder raises three main concerns regarding the interpretation of the experiments presented by Till et al. (2012): (1) our inability to uniquely distinguish between high-pressure hydrous silicate melt and solute-rich aqueous fluid leads to the incorrect interpretation of phase relations, (2) the temperature interval over which hydrous melting takes places is inordinately large and contrary to expectations, and/or (3) the possibility that the system may be above the second critical end point (SCEP) in this H2O-rich silicate system has been insufficiently discussed. In this reply, we provide clarification on these concerns and argue that with the extent of knowledge available today, the chemical characteristics of our experimental products at 3. 2 and 4 GPa evince the presence of a silicate melt at temperatures <1,000 °C and we are below the SCEP in the peridotite-H2O system at the P-T conditions of our experiments. If in fact the quench observed in our experiments does represent that of a supercritical (SC) fluid, then our data suggest Mg and Fe are highly soluble in SC fluids at the P-T conditions of the base of the mantle wedge below arc volcanoes. Therefore, our results would require a significant change in thinking about the chemical compositional characteristics of SC fluids.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1073-1076
Number of pages4
JournalContributions to Mineralogy and Petrology
Volume164
Issue number6
DOIs
StatePublished - 2012
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Silicates
Supercritical fluids
supercritical fluids
wedges
silicates
Earth mantle
Melting
melting
mantle
fluid
silicate melt
P-T conditions
Volcanoes
peridotite
Experiments
volcanoes
experiment
solutes
arcs
intervals

Keywords

  • Chlorite
  • HO-saturated
  • Hydrous melting
  • Peridotite solidus
  • Second critical end point

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geochemistry and Petrology
  • Geophysics

Cite this

Reply to 'Comment on "The beginnings of hydrous mantle wedge melting" by Till et al.' by Stalder. / Till, Christy; Grove, Timothy L.; Withers, Anthony C.

In: Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology, Vol. 164, No. 6, 2012, p. 1073-1076.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{bdb4c2310e28486ea9a224ac026e4031,
title = "Reply to 'Comment on {"}The beginnings of hydrous mantle wedge melting{"} by Till et al.' by Stalder",
abstract = "The comment of Stalder raises three main concerns regarding the interpretation of the experiments presented by Till et al. (2012): (1) our inability to uniquely distinguish between high-pressure hydrous silicate melt and solute-rich aqueous fluid leads to the incorrect interpretation of phase relations, (2) the temperature interval over which hydrous melting takes places is inordinately large and contrary to expectations, and/or (3) the possibility that the system may be above the second critical end point (SCEP) in this H2O-rich silicate system has been insufficiently discussed. In this reply, we provide clarification on these concerns and argue that with the extent of knowledge available today, the chemical characteristics of our experimental products at 3. 2 and 4 GPa evince the presence of a silicate melt at temperatures <1,000 °C and we are below the SCEP in the peridotite-H2O system at the P-T conditions of our experiments. If in fact the quench observed in our experiments does represent that of a supercritical (SC) fluid, then our data suggest Mg and Fe are highly soluble in SC fluids at the P-T conditions of the base of the mantle wedge below arc volcanoes. Therefore, our results would require a significant change in thinking about the chemical compositional characteristics of SC fluids.",
keywords = "Chlorite, HO-saturated, Hydrous melting, Peridotite solidus, Second critical end point",
author = "Christy Till and Grove, {Timothy L.} and Withers, {Anthony C.}",
year = "2012",
doi = "10.1007/s00410-012-0797-6",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "164",
pages = "1073--1076",
journal = "Contributions of Mineralogy and Petrology",
issn = "0010-7999",
publisher = "Springer Verlag",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reply to 'Comment on "The beginnings of hydrous mantle wedge melting" by Till et al.' by Stalder

AU - Till, Christy

AU - Grove, Timothy L.

AU - Withers, Anthony C.

PY - 2012

Y1 - 2012

N2 - The comment of Stalder raises three main concerns regarding the interpretation of the experiments presented by Till et al. (2012): (1) our inability to uniquely distinguish between high-pressure hydrous silicate melt and solute-rich aqueous fluid leads to the incorrect interpretation of phase relations, (2) the temperature interval over which hydrous melting takes places is inordinately large and contrary to expectations, and/or (3) the possibility that the system may be above the second critical end point (SCEP) in this H2O-rich silicate system has been insufficiently discussed. In this reply, we provide clarification on these concerns and argue that with the extent of knowledge available today, the chemical characteristics of our experimental products at 3. 2 and 4 GPa evince the presence of a silicate melt at temperatures <1,000 °C and we are below the SCEP in the peridotite-H2O system at the P-T conditions of our experiments. If in fact the quench observed in our experiments does represent that of a supercritical (SC) fluid, then our data suggest Mg and Fe are highly soluble in SC fluids at the P-T conditions of the base of the mantle wedge below arc volcanoes. Therefore, our results would require a significant change in thinking about the chemical compositional characteristics of SC fluids.

AB - The comment of Stalder raises three main concerns regarding the interpretation of the experiments presented by Till et al. (2012): (1) our inability to uniquely distinguish between high-pressure hydrous silicate melt and solute-rich aqueous fluid leads to the incorrect interpretation of phase relations, (2) the temperature interval over which hydrous melting takes places is inordinately large and contrary to expectations, and/or (3) the possibility that the system may be above the second critical end point (SCEP) in this H2O-rich silicate system has been insufficiently discussed. In this reply, we provide clarification on these concerns and argue that with the extent of knowledge available today, the chemical characteristics of our experimental products at 3. 2 and 4 GPa evince the presence of a silicate melt at temperatures <1,000 °C and we are below the SCEP in the peridotite-H2O system at the P-T conditions of our experiments. If in fact the quench observed in our experiments does represent that of a supercritical (SC) fluid, then our data suggest Mg and Fe are highly soluble in SC fluids at the P-T conditions of the base of the mantle wedge below arc volcanoes. Therefore, our results would require a significant change in thinking about the chemical compositional characteristics of SC fluids.

KW - Chlorite

KW - HO-saturated

KW - Hydrous melting

KW - Peridotite solidus

KW - Second critical end point

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84869154209&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84869154209&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s00410-012-0797-6

DO - 10.1007/s00410-012-0797-6

M3 - Article

VL - 164

SP - 1073

EP - 1076

JO - Contributions of Mineralogy and Petrology

JF - Contributions of Mineralogy and Petrology

SN - 0010-7999

IS - 6

ER -