Relationship between small group problem-solving activity and lectures in health science curricula

Vimla Patel, Jose F. Arocha, Timothy Branch, Daniel R. Karlin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

16 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Components of problem-based education, such as small group teaching, are being implemented in diverse health curricula. Implementation, however, is often motivated by the intuitive appeal of many problem-based learning components, when what is needed is the detailed examination of how these components support students' integration of knowledge as well as continuity of their learning experiences. This study presents an investigation of the relationship between lecture and small group teaching (SGT) in a medical curriculum. Four problem-oriented SGT sessions representing diverse topics in the first-year curriculum and their corresponding lectures were videotaped and analyzed using techniques of concept mapping, where the broad concepts from the lectures were identified and matched to the case-specific concepts in the small group sessions. The results show that lectures function as an anchor for the students' discussion of issues relevant to clinical problem-solving and interventions in small group sessions. These discussions extended to contextual aspects of clinical practice that were not dealt with in the lectures, such as ethical/cultural issues around the treatment of patients. Furthermore, small group environments were found to promote discussions that allowed the integration of information from different sources and encompassed concepts across a number of disciplines. These results suggest that carefully designed small group sessions serve the purposes of 1) illustrating broader concepts in lectures to case-specific, clinically relevant problem-solving and 2) promoting knowledge integration from diverse sources of information. The implications of these results for learning and reasoning in health science curricula are discussed.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1058-1080
Number of pages23
JournalJournal of Dental Education
Volume68
Issue number10
StatePublished - Oct 1 2004
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

health science
Curriculum
small group
curriculum
Teaching
Health
Learning
Students
Problem-Based Learning
Ethics
learning
Education
source of information
knowledge
appeal
continuity
student
examination
health
Therapeutics

Keywords

  • Biomedical knowledge
  • Clinical knowledge
  • Health education
  • Knowledge integration
  • Small group teaching

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Patel, V., Arocha, J. F., Branch, T., & Karlin, D. R. (2004). Relationship between small group problem-solving activity and lectures in health science curricula. Journal of Dental Education, 68(10), 1058-1080.

Relationship between small group problem-solving activity and lectures in health science curricula. / Patel, Vimla; Arocha, Jose F.; Branch, Timothy; Karlin, Daniel R.

In: Journal of Dental Education, Vol. 68, No. 10, 01.10.2004, p. 1058-1080.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Patel, V, Arocha, JF, Branch, T & Karlin, DR 2004, 'Relationship between small group problem-solving activity and lectures in health science curricula', Journal of Dental Education, vol. 68, no. 10, pp. 1058-1080.
Patel, Vimla ; Arocha, Jose F. ; Branch, Timothy ; Karlin, Daniel R. / Relationship between small group problem-solving activity and lectures in health science curricula. In: Journal of Dental Education. 2004 ; Vol. 68, No. 10. pp. 1058-1080.
@article{784e52f112ac4aea95b476c466ec6d6b,
title = "Relationship between small group problem-solving activity and lectures in health science curricula",
abstract = "Components of problem-based education, such as small group teaching, are being implemented in diverse health curricula. Implementation, however, is often motivated by the intuitive appeal of many problem-based learning components, when what is needed is the detailed examination of how these components support students' integration of knowledge as well as continuity of their learning experiences. This study presents an investigation of the relationship between lecture and small group teaching (SGT) in a medical curriculum. Four problem-oriented SGT sessions representing diverse topics in the first-year curriculum and their corresponding lectures were videotaped and analyzed using techniques of concept mapping, where the broad concepts from the lectures were identified and matched to the case-specific concepts in the small group sessions. The results show that lectures function as an anchor for the students' discussion of issues relevant to clinical problem-solving and interventions in small group sessions. These discussions extended to contextual aspects of clinical practice that were not dealt with in the lectures, such as ethical/cultural issues around the treatment of patients. Furthermore, small group environments were found to promote discussions that allowed the integration of information from different sources and encompassed concepts across a number of disciplines. These results suggest that carefully designed small group sessions serve the purposes of 1) illustrating broader concepts in lectures to case-specific, clinically relevant problem-solving and 2) promoting knowledge integration from diverse sources of information. The implications of these results for learning and reasoning in health science curricula are discussed.",
keywords = "Biomedical knowledge, Clinical knowledge, Health education, Knowledge integration, Small group teaching",
author = "Vimla Patel and Arocha, {Jose F.} and Timothy Branch and Karlin, {Daniel R.}",
year = "2004",
month = "10",
day = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "68",
pages = "1058--1080",
journal = "Journal of Dental Education",
issn = "0022-0337",
publisher = "American Dental Education Association",
number = "10",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Relationship between small group problem-solving activity and lectures in health science curricula

AU - Patel, Vimla

AU - Arocha, Jose F.

AU - Branch, Timothy

AU - Karlin, Daniel R.

PY - 2004/10/1

Y1 - 2004/10/1

N2 - Components of problem-based education, such as small group teaching, are being implemented in diverse health curricula. Implementation, however, is often motivated by the intuitive appeal of many problem-based learning components, when what is needed is the detailed examination of how these components support students' integration of knowledge as well as continuity of their learning experiences. This study presents an investigation of the relationship between lecture and small group teaching (SGT) in a medical curriculum. Four problem-oriented SGT sessions representing diverse topics in the first-year curriculum and their corresponding lectures were videotaped and analyzed using techniques of concept mapping, where the broad concepts from the lectures were identified and matched to the case-specific concepts in the small group sessions. The results show that lectures function as an anchor for the students' discussion of issues relevant to clinical problem-solving and interventions in small group sessions. These discussions extended to contextual aspects of clinical practice that were not dealt with in the lectures, such as ethical/cultural issues around the treatment of patients. Furthermore, small group environments were found to promote discussions that allowed the integration of information from different sources and encompassed concepts across a number of disciplines. These results suggest that carefully designed small group sessions serve the purposes of 1) illustrating broader concepts in lectures to case-specific, clinically relevant problem-solving and 2) promoting knowledge integration from diverse sources of information. The implications of these results for learning and reasoning in health science curricula are discussed.

AB - Components of problem-based education, such as small group teaching, are being implemented in diverse health curricula. Implementation, however, is often motivated by the intuitive appeal of many problem-based learning components, when what is needed is the detailed examination of how these components support students' integration of knowledge as well as continuity of their learning experiences. This study presents an investigation of the relationship between lecture and small group teaching (SGT) in a medical curriculum. Four problem-oriented SGT sessions representing diverse topics in the first-year curriculum and their corresponding lectures were videotaped and analyzed using techniques of concept mapping, where the broad concepts from the lectures were identified and matched to the case-specific concepts in the small group sessions. The results show that lectures function as an anchor for the students' discussion of issues relevant to clinical problem-solving and interventions in small group sessions. These discussions extended to contextual aspects of clinical practice that were not dealt with in the lectures, such as ethical/cultural issues around the treatment of patients. Furthermore, small group environments were found to promote discussions that allowed the integration of information from different sources and encompassed concepts across a number of disciplines. These results suggest that carefully designed small group sessions serve the purposes of 1) illustrating broader concepts in lectures to case-specific, clinically relevant problem-solving and 2) promoting knowledge integration from diverse sources of information. The implications of these results for learning and reasoning in health science curricula are discussed.

KW - Biomedical knowledge

KW - Clinical knowledge

KW - Health education

KW - Knowledge integration

KW - Small group teaching

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=6944250400&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=6944250400&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 68

SP - 1058

EP - 1080

JO - Journal of Dental Education

JF - Journal of Dental Education

SN - 0022-0337

IS - 10

ER -