Productivity metrics in dynamic LCA for whole buildings: Using a post-occupancy evaluation of energy and indoor environmental quality tradeoffs

William O. Collinge, Amy E. Landis, Alex K. Jones, Laura A. Schaefer, Melissa M. Bilec

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

24 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The IEQ + DLCA framework, which integrates indoor environmental quality (IEQ) and dynamic life cycle assessment (DLCA) at the whole-building level, was revised and expanded to consider non-chemical health impacts and productivity/performance impacts. The complete framework was evaluated for a case study of a LEED gold rated university building, supplemented with a post-occupancy evaluation (POE) designed to elicit qualitative feedback on IEQ and productivity impacts specific to the building. Most non-chemical health impacts (e.g. sick building syndrome (SBS), asthma) were not able to be included in the framework, due to potential overlaps with chemical-specific impacts already included in LCA. However, productivity impacts were able to be included in the framework for the purpose of comparing different design and operational choices for a given building. Occupants were also asked to evaluate the anticipated effects on their individual productivity due to IEQ changes associated with hypothetical energy-saving strategies. Results of the POE showed occupants were generally satisfied with IEQ, and considered that increasing summer cooling temperature set points would enhance productivity. Energy savings were calculated using an empirical energy and IEQ model calibrated with sensed data from the building. Evaluation of the full IEQ + DLCA framework suggested potentially significant energy savings potential and possible productivity enhancement, but indicated tradeoffs between internal chemical impact categories related to building ventilation, indoor pollutant generation and outdoor pollutant intake. The tradeoffs and overlaps between internal chemical impact categories themselves, as well as between chemical and non-chemical impact categories such as (SBS) are a challenge for LCA of whole buildings.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)339-348
Number of pages10
JournalBuilding and Environment
Volume82
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 1 2014

Fingerprint

environmental quality
building
Productivity
productivity
energy
evaluation
Life cycle
Energy conservation
life cycle assessment
energy saving
life cycle
health impact
Health
pollutant
asthma
Ventilation
ventilation
Gold
Cooling
health

Keywords

  • Dynamic LCA
  • Indoor air quality
  • Indoor environmental quality
  • Life cycle assessment
  • Post-occupancy evaluation
  • Productivity

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Civil and Structural Engineering
  • Environmental Engineering
  • Geography, Planning and Development
  • Building and Construction

Cite this

Productivity metrics in dynamic LCA for whole buildings : Using a post-occupancy evaluation of energy and indoor environmental quality tradeoffs. / Collinge, William O.; Landis, Amy E.; Jones, Alex K.; Schaefer, Laura A.; Bilec, Melissa M.

In: Building and Environment, Vol. 82, 01.12.2014, p. 339-348.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Collinge, William O. ; Landis, Amy E. ; Jones, Alex K. ; Schaefer, Laura A. ; Bilec, Melissa M. / Productivity metrics in dynamic LCA for whole buildings : Using a post-occupancy evaluation of energy and indoor environmental quality tradeoffs. In: Building and Environment. 2014 ; Vol. 82. pp. 339-348.
@article{65024b6ff28b4975ad718587e33dda37,
title = "Productivity metrics in dynamic LCA for whole buildings: Using a post-occupancy evaluation of energy and indoor environmental quality tradeoffs",
abstract = "The IEQ + DLCA framework, which integrates indoor environmental quality (IEQ) and dynamic life cycle assessment (DLCA) at the whole-building level, was revised and expanded to consider non-chemical health impacts and productivity/performance impacts. The complete framework was evaluated for a case study of a LEED gold rated university building, supplemented with a post-occupancy evaluation (POE) designed to elicit qualitative feedback on IEQ and productivity impacts specific to the building. Most non-chemical health impacts (e.g. sick building syndrome (SBS), asthma) were not able to be included in the framework, due to potential overlaps with chemical-specific impacts already included in LCA. However, productivity impacts were able to be included in the framework for the purpose of comparing different design and operational choices for a given building. Occupants were also asked to evaluate the anticipated effects on their individual productivity due to IEQ changes associated with hypothetical energy-saving strategies. Results of the POE showed occupants were generally satisfied with IEQ, and considered that increasing summer cooling temperature set points would enhance productivity. Energy savings were calculated using an empirical energy and IEQ model calibrated with sensed data from the building. Evaluation of the full IEQ + DLCA framework suggested potentially significant energy savings potential and possible productivity enhancement, but indicated tradeoffs between internal chemical impact categories related to building ventilation, indoor pollutant generation and outdoor pollutant intake. The tradeoffs and overlaps between internal chemical impact categories themselves, as well as between chemical and non-chemical impact categories such as (SBS) are a challenge for LCA of whole buildings.",
keywords = "Dynamic LCA, Indoor air quality, Indoor environmental quality, Life cycle assessment, Post-occupancy evaluation, Productivity",
author = "Collinge, {William O.} and Landis, {Amy E.} and Jones, {Alex K.} and Schaefer, {Laura A.} and Bilec, {Melissa M.}",
year = "2014",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.buildenv.2014.08.032",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "82",
pages = "339--348",
journal = "Building and Environment",
issn = "0360-1323",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Productivity metrics in dynamic LCA for whole buildings

T2 - Using a post-occupancy evaluation of energy and indoor environmental quality tradeoffs

AU - Collinge, William O.

AU - Landis, Amy E.

AU - Jones, Alex K.

AU - Schaefer, Laura A.

AU - Bilec, Melissa M.

PY - 2014/12/1

Y1 - 2014/12/1

N2 - The IEQ + DLCA framework, which integrates indoor environmental quality (IEQ) and dynamic life cycle assessment (DLCA) at the whole-building level, was revised and expanded to consider non-chemical health impacts and productivity/performance impacts. The complete framework was evaluated for a case study of a LEED gold rated university building, supplemented with a post-occupancy evaluation (POE) designed to elicit qualitative feedback on IEQ and productivity impacts specific to the building. Most non-chemical health impacts (e.g. sick building syndrome (SBS), asthma) were not able to be included in the framework, due to potential overlaps with chemical-specific impacts already included in LCA. However, productivity impacts were able to be included in the framework for the purpose of comparing different design and operational choices for a given building. Occupants were also asked to evaluate the anticipated effects on their individual productivity due to IEQ changes associated with hypothetical energy-saving strategies. Results of the POE showed occupants were generally satisfied with IEQ, and considered that increasing summer cooling temperature set points would enhance productivity. Energy savings were calculated using an empirical energy and IEQ model calibrated with sensed data from the building. Evaluation of the full IEQ + DLCA framework suggested potentially significant energy savings potential and possible productivity enhancement, but indicated tradeoffs between internal chemical impact categories related to building ventilation, indoor pollutant generation and outdoor pollutant intake. The tradeoffs and overlaps between internal chemical impact categories themselves, as well as between chemical and non-chemical impact categories such as (SBS) are a challenge for LCA of whole buildings.

AB - The IEQ + DLCA framework, which integrates indoor environmental quality (IEQ) and dynamic life cycle assessment (DLCA) at the whole-building level, was revised and expanded to consider non-chemical health impacts and productivity/performance impacts. The complete framework was evaluated for a case study of a LEED gold rated university building, supplemented with a post-occupancy evaluation (POE) designed to elicit qualitative feedback on IEQ and productivity impacts specific to the building. Most non-chemical health impacts (e.g. sick building syndrome (SBS), asthma) were not able to be included in the framework, due to potential overlaps with chemical-specific impacts already included in LCA. However, productivity impacts were able to be included in the framework for the purpose of comparing different design and operational choices for a given building. Occupants were also asked to evaluate the anticipated effects on their individual productivity due to IEQ changes associated with hypothetical energy-saving strategies. Results of the POE showed occupants were generally satisfied with IEQ, and considered that increasing summer cooling temperature set points would enhance productivity. Energy savings were calculated using an empirical energy and IEQ model calibrated with sensed data from the building. Evaluation of the full IEQ + DLCA framework suggested potentially significant energy savings potential and possible productivity enhancement, but indicated tradeoffs between internal chemical impact categories related to building ventilation, indoor pollutant generation and outdoor pollutant intake. The tradeoffs and overlaps between internal chemical impact categories themselves, as well as between chemical and non-chemical impact categories such as (SBS) are a challenge for LCA of whole buildings.

KW - Dynamic LCA

KW - Indoor air quality

KW - Indoor environmental quality

KW - Life cycle assessment

KW - Post-occupancy evaluation

KW - Productivity

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84907532767&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84907532767&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.buildenv.2014.08.032

DO - 10.1016/j.buildenv.2014.08.032

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84907532767

VL - 82

SP - 339

EP - 348

JO - Building and Environment

JF - Building and Environment

SN - 0360-1323

ER -