"Now I Ain't Sayin' she a gold digger"

Wal-mart shoppers, welfare queens, and other gendered stereotypes of poor women in the big curriculum of consumption

Jennifer Sandlin, Jennie Stearns, Julie Garlen Maudlin, Jake Burdick

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In this article, which we present in a format informed by critical performance ethnography/pedagogy, we take up the issue of how we are "taught into" the ideology of consumerism through examining the dominant discourses about (poor) women as shoppers that circulate in popular and political discourses and that work to uphold particular hegemonic ideologies about how to consume and how to behave as consumers within a capitalist economic system. We specifically examine the historical construction of shopping and consumption as "feminine" domains and the consequent negative perception of women as consumers that continues to inform popular discourses about poor women, poor African American women, and women on welfare. We perform a juxtaposed space of academic literature, popular culture representations of female consumers, and interview data from women living in poverty to reconstruct the ways in which dominant discourses about poor women as consumers operate as "controlling images" (Collins, 2000) that perpetuate a "politics of disgust" (Hancock, 2004) that demeans and oppresses poor women. Additionally, we argue that these dominant discourses teach us all the ideology of capitalism, as we learn what is considered "proper" and "improper" economic behavior and use the negative portrayals of women on welfare as foils to justify our own consumptive practices.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)464-482
Number of pages19
JournalCultural Studies - Critical Methodologies
Volume11
Issue number5
DOIs
StatePublished - Oct 2011

Fingerprint

gold
stereotype
welfare
curriculum
discourse
ideology
Stereotypes
Curriculum
economic behavior
economic system
popular culture
Ideologies
ethnography
capitalist society
poverty
Discourse
politics
interview
Ideology

Keywords

  • consumerism
  • curriculum theory
  • discourses of shopping
  • gender analysis
  • performance pedagogy
  • popular culture
  • public pedagogy

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Cultural Studies
  • Arts and Humanities (miscellaneous)

Cite this

"Now I Ain't Sayin' she a gold digger" : Wal-mart shoppers, welfare queens, and other gendered stereotypes of poor women in the big curriculum of consumption. / Sandlin, Jennifer; Stearns, Jennie; Maudlin, Julie Garlen; Burdick, Jake.

In: Cultural Studies - Critical Methodologies, Vol. 11, No. 5, 10.2011, p. 464-482.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{96e8622c1192407483d9e9e4920be272,
title = "{"}Now I Ain't Sayin' she a gold digger{"}: Wal-mart shoppers, welfare queens, and other gendered stereotypes of poor women in the big curriculum of consumption",
abstract = "In this article, which we present in a format informed by critical performance ethnography/pedagogy, we take up the issue of how we are {"}taught into{"} the ideology of consumerism through examining the dominant discourses about (poor) women as shoppers that circulate in popular and political discourses and that work to uphold particular hegemonic ideologies about how to consume and how to behave as consumers within a capitalist economic system. We specifically examine the historical construction of shopping and consumption as {"}feminine{"} domains and the consequent negative perception of women as consumers that continues to inform popular discourses about poor women, poor African American women, and women on welfare. We perform a juxtaposed space of academic literature, popular culture representations of female consumers, and interview data from women living in poverty to reconstruct the ways in which dominant discourses about poor women as consumers operate as {"}controlling images{"} (Collins, 2000) that perpetuate a {"}politics of disgust{"} (Hancock, 2004) that demeans and oppresses poor women. Additionally, we argue that these dominant discourses teach us all the ideology of capitalism, as we learn what is considered {"}proper{"} and {"}improper{"} economic behavior and use the negative portrayals of women on welfare as foils to justify our own consumptive practices.",
keywords = "consumerism, curriculum theory, discourses of shopping, gender analysis, performance pedagogy, popular culture, public pedagogy",
author = "Jennifer Sandlin and Jennie Stearns and Maudlin, {Julie Garlen} and Jake Burdick",
year = "2011",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1177/1532708611423210",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "11",
pages = "464--482",
journal = "Cultural Studies - Critical Methodologies",
issn = "1532-7086",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Inc.",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - "Now I Ain't Sayin' she a gold digger"

T2 - Wal-mart shoppers, welfare queens, and other gendered stereotypes of poor women in the big curriculum of consumption

AU - Sandlin, Jennifer

AU - Stearns, Jennie

AU - Maudlin, Julie Garlen

AU - Burdick, Jake

PY - 2011/10

Y1 - 2011/10

N2 - In this article, which we present in a format informed by critical performance ethnography/pedagogy, we take up the issue of how we are "taught into" the ideology of consumerism through examining the dominant discourses about (poor) women as shoppers that circulate in popular and political discourses and that work to uphold particular hegemonic ideologies about how to consume and how to behave as consumers within a capitalist economic system. We specifically examine the historical construction of shopping and consumption as "feminine" domains and the consequent negative perception of women as consumers that continues to inform popular discourses about poor women, poor African American women, and women on welfare. We perform a juxtaposed space of academic literature, popular culture representations of female consumers, and interview data from women living in poverty to reconstruct the ways in which dominant discourses about poor women as consumers operate as "controlling images" (Collins, 2000) that perpetuate a "politics of disgust" (Hancock, 2004) that demeans and oppresses poor women. Additionally, we argue that these dominant discourses teach us all the ideology of capitalism, as we learn what is considered "proper" and "improper" economic behavior and use the negative portrayals of women on welfare as foils to justify our own consumptive practices.

AB - In this article, which we present in a format informed by critical performance ethnography/pedagogy, we take up the issue of how we are "taught into" the ideology of consumerism through examining the dominant discourses about (poor) women as shoppers that circulate in popular and political discourses and that work to uphold particular hegemonic ideologies about how to consume and how to behave as consumers within a capitalist economic system. We specifically examine the historical construction of shopping and consumption as "feminine" domains and the consequent negative perception of women as consumers that continues to inform popular discourses about poor women, poor African American women, and women on welfare. We perform a juxtaposed space of academic literature, popular culture representations of female consumers, and interview data from women living in poverty to reconstruct the ways in which dominant discourses about poor women as consumers operate as "controlling images" (Collins, 2000) that perpetuate a "politics of disgust" (Hancock, 2004) that demeans and oppresses poor women. Additionally, we argue that these dominant discourses teach us all the ideology of capitalism, as we learn what is considered "proper" and "improper" economic behavior and use the negative portrayals of women on welfare as foils to justify our own consumptive practices.

KW - consumerism

KW - curriculum theory

KW - discourses of shopping

KW - gender analysis

KW - performance pedagogy

KW - popular culture

KW - public pedagogy

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84855240095&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84855240095&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/1532708611423210

DO - 10.1177/1532708611423210

M3 - Article

VL - 11

SP - 464

EP - 482

JO - Cultural Studies - Critical Methodologies

JF - Cultural Studies - Critical Methodologies

SN - 1532-7086

IS - 5

ER -