Monazite-xenotine thermochronometry: Methodology and an example from the Nepalese Himalaya

K. Viskupic, Kip Hodges

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

69 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Monazite-xenotime thermochronometry involves the integration of petrographic, geochronological, and geochemical techniques to explore the thermal evolution of igneous and metamorphic rocks containing these accessory minerals. The method is illustrated in this paper by application to an orthogneiss sample from the Everest region of the Nepalese Himalaya that contains leucogranitic segregations produced by in-situ anatexis. Observations of phase relationships and the internal structure of accessory minerals made using both transmitted light and electron microscopy revealed the existence of multiple generations of monazite and xenotime and guided microsampling efforts to isolate grain fragments of Himalayan (Tertiary) and pre-Himalayan age. Nearly concordant U-Pb isotopic ratios for 13 single monazite and xenotime grains ranged in age from 28.37 to 17.598 Ma, making determination of the timing of anatexis difficult without additional information. Presuming that monazite and xenotime were in equilibrium over that entire interval, temperatures estimated from the yttrium contents of dated monazites range from 677-535 °C. Only the highest temperatures are consistent with experimental constraints on the conditions necessary to produce anatectic melts of appropriate composition, implying that the Ο25.4-24.8 Ma dates for the grains with high apparent equilibration temperatures provide the best estimates for the age of anatexis. Two monazite crystals yielded 207Pb/235U dates that are statistically indistinguishable from the 207Pb/235U dates of coexisting xenotime crystals, permitting the application of both quantitative Y-partitioning and semi-quantitative Nd-partitioning thermometers as a cross-check for internal consistency. One of these sub-populations of accessory minerals, with a mean 207Pb/235U date of 22.364 ± 0.097 Ma, provides inconsistent Y-partitioning (641 ± 39 °C) and Nd-partitioning (515-560 °C) temperatures. We suspect the discrepancy may be caused by the high Th concentration (6.12 wt% ThO2) in this subpopulation's monazite. The Y-partitioning thermometer was derived from experimental data for the (Ce, Y)PO4 binary and may be inappropriate for application to high-Th monazites. For the other sub-population (mean 207Pb/235U date = 22.11 ± 0.22 Ma), the Y- and Nd-partitioning temperatures are indistinguishable: 535 ± 49 and 525-550 °C, respectively. This consistency strongly suggests that the sample experienced a temperature of Ο535 °C at 22.11 Ma. This finding is tectonically important because temperatures at higher structural levels were much higher (by Ο100 °C) at the same time, lending support to earlier suggestions of a major structural discontinuity within the upper part of the Himalayan metamorphic core at this longitude. An additional finding of uncertain importance is that inherited monazite and xenotime yielded U-Pb discordia with indistinguishable upper intercept ages (465.5 ± 8.7 and 470 ± 11 Ma, respectively) and application of the Y-partitioning thermometer to the inherited monazites produced a restricted range of model temperatures averaging 470 °C. Whether or not these temperatures are geologically meaningful is unclear without independent corroboration of the assumption of equilibrium between the inherited monazites and xenotimes, but it appears that monazite-xenotime thermochronometry may be useful for "seeing through" high-grade metamorphism to extract temperature-time information about inherited mineral suites.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)233-247
Number of pages15
JournalContributions to Mineralogy and Petrology
Volume141
Issue number2
StatePublished - 2001
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

xenotime
monazite
methodology
partitioning
accessory mineral
accessories
anatexis
temperature
thermometers
Minerals
Thermometers
subpopulation
Accessories
minerals
Temperature
crystal
Metamorphic rocks
Igneous rocks
yttrium
orthogneiss

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geochemistry and Petrology
  • Geophysics

Cite this

Monazite-xenotine thermochronometry : Methodology and an example from the Nepalese Himalaya. / Viskupic, K.; Hodges, Kip.

In: Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology, Vol. 141, No. 2, 2001, p. 233-247.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{2ee8519da127453d9e21370cadaa62d6,
title = "Monazite-xenotine thermochronometry: Methodology and an example from the Nepalese Himalaya",
abstract = "Monazite-xenotime thermochronometry involves the integration of petrographic, geochronological, and geochemical techniques to explore the thermal evolution of igneous and metamorphic rocks containing these accessory minerals. The method is illustrated in this paper by application to an orthogneiss sample from the Everest region of the Nepalese Himalaya that contains leucogranitic segregations produced by in-situ anatexis. Observations of phase relationships and the internal structure of accessory minerals made using both transmitted light and electron microscopy revealed the existence of multiple generations of monazite and xenotime and guided microsampling efforts to isolate grain fragments of Himalayan (Tertiary) and pre-Himalayan age. Nearly concordant U-Pb isotopic ratios for 13 single monazite and xenotime grains ranged in age from 28.37 to 17.598 Ma, making determination of the timing of anatexis difficult without additional information. Presuming that monazite and xenotime were in equilibrium over that entire interval, temperatures estimated from the yttrium contents of dated monazites range from 677-535 °C. Only the highest temperatures are consistent with experimental constraints on the conditions necessary to produce anatectic melts of appropriate composition, implying that the Ο25.4-24.8 Ma dates for the grains with high apparent equilibration temperatures provide the best estimates for the age of anatexis. Two monazite crystals yielded 207Pb/235U dates that are statistically indistinguishable from the 207Pb/235U dates of coexisting xenotime crystals, permitting the application of both quantitative Y-partitioning and semi-quantitative Nd-partitioning thermometers as a cross-check for internal consistency. One of these sub-populations of accessory minerals, with a mean 207Pb/235U date of 22.364 ± 0.097 Ma, provides inconsistent Y-partitioning (641 ± 39 °C) and Nd-partitioning (515-560 °C) temperatures. We suspect the discrepancy may be caused by the high Th concentration (6.12 wt{\%} ThO2) in this subpopulation's monazite. The Y-partitioning thermometer was derived from experimental data for the (Ce, Y)PO4 binary and may be inappropriate for application to high-Th monazites. For the other sub-population (mean 207Pb/235U date = 22.11 ± 0.22 Ma), the Y- and Nd-partitioning temperatures are indistinguishable: 535 ± 49 and 525-550 °C, respectively. This consistency strongly suggests that the sample experienced a temperature of Ο535 °C at 22.11 Ma. This finding is tectonically important because temperatures at higher structural levels were much higher (by Ο100 °C) at the same time, lending support to earlier suggestions of a major structural discontinuity within the upper part of the Himalayan metamorphic core at this longitude. An additional finding of uncertain importance is that inherited monazite and xenotime yielded U-Pb discordia with indistinguishable upper intercept ages (465.5 ± 8.7 and 470 ± 11 Ma, respectively) and application of the Y-partitioning thermometer to the inherited monazites produced a restricted range of model temperatures averaging 470 °C. Whether or not these temperatures are geologically meaningful is unclear without independent corroboration of the assumption of equilibrium between the inherited monazites and xenotimes, but it appears that monazite-xenotime thermochronometry may be useful for {"}seeing through{"} high-grade metamorphism to extract temperature-time information about inherited mineral suites.",
author = "K. Viskupic and Kip Hodges",
year = "2001",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "141",
pages = "233--247",
journal = "Contributions of Mineralogy and Petrology",
issn = "0010-7999",
publisher = "Springer Verlag",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Monazite-xenotine thermochronometry

T2 - Methodology and an example from the Nepalese Himalaya

AU - Viskupic, K.

AU - Hodges, Kip

PY - 2001

Y1 - 2001

N2 - Monazite-xenotime thermochronometry involves the integration of petrographic, geochronological, and geochemical techniques to explore the thermal evolution of igneous and metamorphic rocks containing these accessory minerals. The method is illustrated in this paper by application to an orthogneiss sample from the Everest region of the Nepalese Himalaya that contains leucogranitic segregations produced by in-situ anatexis. Observations of phase relationships and the internal structure of accessory minerals made using both transmitted light and electron microscopy revealed the existence of multiple generations of monazite and xenotime and guided microsampling efforts to isolate grain fragments of Himalayan (Tertiary) and pre-Himalayan age. Nearly concordant U-Pb isotopic ratios for 13 single monazite and xenotime grains ranged in age from 28.37 to 17.598 Ma, making determination of the timing of anatexis difficult without additional information. Presuming that monazite and xenotime were in equilibrium over that entire interval, temperatures estimated from the yttrium contents of dated monazites range from 677-535 °C. Only the highest temperatures are consistent with experimental constraints on the conditions necessary to produce anatectic melts of appropriate composition, implying that the Ο25.4-24.8 Ma dates for the grains with high apparent equilibration temperatures provide the best estimates for the age of anatexis. Two monazite crystals yielded 207Pb/235U dates that are statistically indistinguishable from the 207Pb/235U dates of coexisting xenotime crystals, permitting the application of both quantitative Y-partitioning and semi-quantitative Nd-partitioning thermometers as a cross-check for internal consistency. One of these sub-populations of accessory minerals, with a mean 207Pb/235U date of 22.364 ± 0.097 Ma, provides inconsistent Y-partitioning (641 ± 39 °C) and Nd-partitioning (515-560 °C) temperatures. We suspect the discrepancy may be caused by the high Th concentration (6.12 wt% ThO2) in this subpopulation's monazite. The Y-partitioning thermometer was derived from experimental data for the (Ce, Y)PO4 binary and may be inappropriate for application to high-Th monazites. For the other sub-population (mean 207Pb/235U date = 22.11 ± 0.22 Ma), the Y- and Nd-partitioning temperatures are indistinguishable: 535 ± 49 and 525-550 °C, respectively. This consistency strongly suggests that the sample experienced a temperature of Ο535 °C at 22.11 Ma. This finding is tectonically important because temperatures at higher structural levels were much higher (by Ο100 °C) at the same time, lending support to earlier suggestions of a major structural discontinuity within the upper part of the Himalayan metamorphic core at this longitude. An additional finding of uncertain importance is that inherited monazite and xenotime yielded U-Pb discordia with indistinguishable upper intercept ages (465.5 ± 8.7 and 470 ± 11 Ma, respectively) and application of the Y-partitioning thermometer to the inherited monazites produced a restricted range of model temperatures averaging 470 °C. Whether or not these temperatures are geologically meaningful is unclear without independent corroboration of the assumption of equilibrium between the inherited monazites and xenotimes, but it appears that monazite-xenotime thermochronometry may be useful for "seeing through" high-grade metamorphism to extract temperature-time information about inherited mineral suites.

AB - Monazite-xenotime thermochronometry involves the integration of petrographic, geochronological, and geochemical techniques to explore the thermal evolution of igneous and metamorphic rocks containing these accessory minerals. The method is illustrated in this paper by application to an orthogneiss sample from the Everest region of the Nepalese Himalaya that contains leucogranitic segregations produced by in-situ anatexis. Observations of phase relationships and the internal structure of accessory minerals made using both transmitted light and electron microscopy revealed the existence of multiple generations of monazite and xenotime and guided microsampling efforts to isolate grain fragments of Himalayan (Tertiary) and pre-Himalayan age. Nearly concordant U-Pb isotopic ratios for 13 single monazite and xenotime grains ranged in age from 28.37 to 17.598 Ma, making determination of the timing of anatexis difficult without additional information. Presuming that monazite and xenotime were in equilibrium over that entire interval, temperatures estimated from the yttrium contents of dated monazites range from 677-535 °C. Only the highest temperatures are consistent with experimental constraints on the conditions necessary to produce anatectic melts of appropriate composition, implying that the Ο25.4-24.8 Ma dates for the grains with high apparent equilibration temperatures provide the best estimates for the age of anatexis. Two monazite crystals yielded 207Pb/235U dates that are statistically indistinguishable from the 207Pb/235U dates of coexisting xenotime crystals, permitting the application of both quantitative Y-partitioning and semi-quantitative Nd-partitioning thermometers as a cross-check for internal consistency. One of these sub-populations of accessory minerals, with a mean 207Pb/235U date of 22.364 ± 0.097 Ma, provides inconsistent Y-partitioning (641 ± 39 °C) and Nd-partitioning (515-560 °C) temperatures. We suspect the discrepancy may be caused by the high Th concentration (6.12 wt% ThO2) in this subpopulation's monazite. The Y-partitioning thermometer was derived from experimental data for the (Ce, Y)PO4 binary and may be inappropriate for application to high-Th monazites. For the other sub-population (mean 207Pb/235U date = 22.11 ± 0.22 Ma), the Y- and Nd-partitioning temperatures are indistinguishable: 535 ± 49 and 525-550 °C, respectively. This consistency strongly suggests that the sample experienced a temperature of Ο535 °C at 22.11 Ma. This finding is tectonically important because temperatures at higher structural levels were much higher (by Ο100 °C) at the same time, lending support to earlier suggestions of a major structural discontinuity within the upper part of the Himalayan metamorphic core at this longitude. An additional finding of uncertain importance is that inherited monazite and xenotime yielded U-Pb discordia with indistinguishable upper intercept ages (465.5 ± 8.7 and 470 ± 11 Ma, respectively) and application of the Y-partitioning thermometer to the inherited monazites produced a restricted range of model temperatures averaging 470 °C. Whether or not these temperatures are geologically meaningful is unclear without independent corroboration of the assumption of equilibrium between the inherited monazites and xenotimes, but it appears that monazite-xenotime thermochronometry may be useful for "seeing through" high-grade metamorphism to extract temperature-time information about inherited mineral suites.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0035014245&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0035014245&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:0035014245

VL - 141

SP - 233

EP - 247

JO - Contributions of Mineralogy and Petrology

JF - Contributions of Mineralogy and Petrology

SN - 0010-7999

IS - 2

ER -