Middle-range theories of land system change

P. Meyfroidt, R. Roy Chowdhury, A. de Bremond, E. C. Ellis, K. H. Erb, T. Filatova, R. D. Garrett, J. M. Grove, A. Heinimann, T. Kuemmerle, C. A. Kull, E. F. Lambin, Y. Landon, Y. le Polain de Waroux, P. Messerli, D. Müller, J. Nielsen, G. D. Peterson, V. Rodriguez García, M. SchlüterBillie Turner, P. H. Verburg

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

38 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Changes in land systems generate many sustainability challenges. Identifying more sustainable land-use alternatives requires solid theoretical foundations on the causes of land-use/cover changes. Land system science is a maturing field that has produced a wealth of methodological innovations and empirical observations on land-cover and land-use change, from patterns and processes to causes. We take stock of this knowledge by reviewing and synthesizing the theories that explain the causal mechanisms of land-use change, including systemic linkages between distant land-use changes, with a focus on agriculture and forestry processes. We first review theories explaining changes in land-use extent, such as agricultural expansion, deforestation, frontier development, and land abandonment, and changes in land-use intensity, such as agricultural intensification and disintensification. We then synthesize theories of higher-level land system change processes, focusing on: (i) land-use spillovers, including land sparing and rebound effects with intensification, leakage, indirect land-use change, and land-use displacement, and (ii) land-use transitions, defined as structural non-linear changes in land systems, including forest transitions. Theories focusing on the causes of land system changes span theoretically and epistemologically disparate knowledge domains and build from deductive, abductive, and inductive approaches. A grand, integrated theory of land system change remains elusive. Yet, we show that middle-range theories – defined here as contextual generalizations that describe chains of causal mechanisms explaining a well-bounded range of phenomena, as well as the conditions that trigger, enable, or prevent these causal chains –, provide a path towards generalized knowledge of land systems. This knowledge can support progress towards sustainable social-ecological systems.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)52-67
Number of pages16
JournalGlobal Environmental Change
Volume53
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 1 2018

Fingerprint

system change
land use
land use change
cause
land
agricultural intensification
ecological system
deforestation
leakage
forestry
land cover
social system
innovation
sustainability
agriculture

Keywords

  • Box and arrow framework
  • Deforestation
  • Human-environment systems
  • Indirect land-use change
  • Land-use intensification
  • Land-use spillover
  • Urban dynamics

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Global and Planetary Change
  • Geography, Planning and Development
  • Ecology
  • Management, Monitoring, Policy and Law

Cite this

Meyfroidt, P., Roy Chowdhury, R., de Bremond, A., Ellis, E. C., Erb, K. H., Filatova, T., ... Verburg, P. H. (2018). Middle-range theories of land system change. Global Environmental Change, 53, 52-67. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2018.08.006

Middle-range theories of land system change. / Meyfroidt, P.; Roy Chowdhury, R.; de Bremond, A.; Ellis, E. C.; Erb, K. H.; Filatova, T.; Garrett, R. D.; Grove, J. M.; Heinimann, A.; Kuemmerle, T.; Kull, C. A.; Lambin, E. F.; Landon, Y.; le Polain de Waroux, Y.; Messerli, P.; Müller, D.; Nielsen, J.; Peterson, G. D.; Rodriguez García, V.; Schlüter, M.; Turner, Billie; Verburg, P. H.

In: Global Environmental Change, Vol. 53, 01.11.2018, p. 52-67.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Meyfroidt, P, Roy Chowdhury, R, de Bremond, A, Ellis, EC, Erb, KH, Filatova, T, Garrett, RD, Grove, JM, Heinimann, A, Kuemmerle, T, Kull, CA, Lambin, EF, Landon, Y, le Polain de Waroux, Y, Messerli, P, Müller, D, Nielsen, J, Peterson, GD, Rodriguez García, V, Schlüter, M, Turner, B & Verburg, PH 2018, 'Middle-range theories of land system change', Global Environmental Change, vol. 53, pp. 52-67. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2018.08.006
Meyfroidt P, Roy Chowdhury R, de Bremond A, Ellis EC, Erb KH, Filatova T et al. Middle-range theories of land system change. Global Environmental Change. 2018 Nov 1;53:52-67. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2018.08.006
Meyfroidt, P. ; Roy Chowdhury, R. ; de Bremond, A. ; Ellis, E. C. ; Erb, K. H. ; Filatova, T. ; Garrett, R. D. ; Grove, J. M. ; Heinimann, A. ; Kuemmerle, T. ; Kull, C. A. ; Lambin, E. F. ; Landon, Y. ; le Polain de Waroux, Y. ; Messerli, P. ; Müller, D. ; Nielsen, J. ; Peterson, G. D. ; Rodriguez García, V. ; Schlüter, M. ; Turner, Billie ; Verburg, P. H. / Middle-range theories of land system change. In: Global Environmental Change. 2018 ; Vol. 53. pp. 52-67.
@article{ce536ed5fb76441c8cd3fee06468c58e,
title = "Middle-range theories of land system change",
abstract = "Changes in land systems generate many sustainability challenges. Identifying more sustainable land-use alternatives requires solid theoretical foundations on the causes of land-use/cover changes. Land system science is a maturing field that has produced a wealth of methodological innovations and empirical observations on land-cover and land-use change, from patterns and processes to causes. We take stock of this knowledge by reviewing and synthesizing the theories that explain the causal mechanisms of land-use change, including systemic linkages between distant land-use changes, with a focus on agriculture and forestry processes. We first review theories explaining changes in land-use extent, such as agricultural expansion, deforestation, frontier development, and land abandonment, and changes in land-use intensity, such as agricultural intensification and disintensification. We then synthesize theories of higher-level land system change processes, focusing on: (i) land-use spillovers, including land sparing and rebound effects with intensification, leakage, indirect land-use change, and land-use displacement, and (ii) land-use transitions, defined as structural non-linear changes in land systems, including forest transitions. Theories focusing on the causes of land system changes span theoretically and epistemologically disparate knowledge domains and build from deductive, abductive, and inductive approaches. A grand, integrated theory of land system change remains elusive. Yet, we show that middle-range theories – defined here as contextual generalizations that describe chains of causal mechanisms explaining a well-bounded range of phenomena, as well as the conditions that trigger, enable, or prevent these causal chains –, provide a path towards generalized knowledge of land systems. This knowledge can support progress towards sustainable social-ecological systems.",
keywords = "Box and arrow framework, Deforestation, Human-environment systems, Indirect land-use change, Land-use intensification, Land-use spillover, Urban dynamics",
author = "P. Meyfroidt and {Roy Chowdhury}, R. and {de Bremond}, A. and Ellis, {E. C.} and Erb, {K. H.} and T. Filatova and Garrett, {R. D.} and Grove, {J. M.} and A. Heinimann and T. Kuemmerle and Kull, {C. A.} and Lambin, {E. F.} and Y. Landon and {le Polain de Waroux}, Y. and P. Messerli and D. M{\"u}ller and J. Nielsen and Peterson, {G. D.} and {Rodriguez Garc{\'i}a}, V. and M. Schl{\"u}ter and Billie Turner and Verburg, {P. H.}",
year = "2018",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2018.08.006",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "53",
pages = "52--67",
journal = "Global Environmental Change",
issn = "0959-3780",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Middle-range theories of land system change

AU - Meyfroidt, P.

AU - Roy Chowdhury, R.

AU - de Bremond, A.

AU - Ellis, E. C.

AU - Erb, K. H.

AU - Filatova, T.

AU - Garrett, R. D.

AU - Grove, J. M.

AU - Heinimann, A.

AU - Kuemmerle, T.

AU - Kull, C. A.

AU - Lambin, E. F.

AU - Landon, Y.

AU - le Polain de Waroux, Y.

AU - Messerli, P.

AU - Müller, D.

AU - Nielsen, J.

AU - Peterson, G. D.

AU - Rodriguez García, V.

AU - Schlüter, M.

AU - Turner, Billie

AU - Verburg, P. H.

PY - 2018/11/1

Y1 - 2018/11/1

N2 - Changes in land systems generate many sustainability challenges. Identifying more sustainable land-use alternatives requires solid theoretical foundations on the causes of land-use/cover changes. Land system science is a maturing field that has produced a wealth of methodological innovations and empirical observations on land-cover and land-use change, from patterns and processes to causes. We take stock of this knowledge by reviewing and synthesizing the theories that explain the causal mechanisms of land-use change, including systemic linkages between distant land-use changes, with a focus on agriculture and forestry processes. We first review theories explaining changes in land-use extent, such as agricultural expansion, deforestation, frontier development, and land abandonment, and changes in land-use intensity, such as agricultural intensification and disintensification. We then synthesize theories of higher-level land system change processes, focusing on: (i) land-use spillovers, including land sparing and rebound effects with intensification, leakage, indirect land-use change, and land-use displacement, and (ii) land-use transitions, defined as structural non-linear changes in land systems, including forest transitions. Theories focusing on the causes of land system changes span theoretically and epistemologically disparate knowledge domains and build from deductive, abductive, and inductive approaches. A grand, integrated theory of land system change remains elusive. Yet, we show that middle-range theories – defined here as contextual generalizations that describe chains of causal mechanisms explaining a well-bounded range of phenomena, as well as the conditions that trigger, enable, or prevent these causal chains –, provide a path towards generalized knowledge of land systems. This knowledge can support progress towards sustainable social-ecological systems.

AB - Changes in land systems generate many sustainability challenges. Identifying more sustainable land-use alternatives requires solid theoretical foundations on the causes of land-use/cover changes. Land system science is a maturing field that has produced a wealth of methodological innovations and empirical observations on land-cover and land-use change, from patterns and processes to causes. We take stock of this knowledge by reviewing and synthesizing the theories that explain the causal mechanisms of land-use change, including systemic linkages between distant land-use changes, with a focus on agriculture and forestry processes. We first review theories explaining changes in land-use extent, such as agricultural expansion, deforestation, frontier development, and land abandonment, and changes in land-use intensity, such as agricultural intensification and disintensification. We then synthesize theories of higher-level land system change processes, focusing on: (i) land-use spillovers, including land sparing and rebound effects with intensification, leakage, indirect land-use change, and land-use displacement, and (ii) land-use transitions, defined as structural non-linear changes in land systems, including forest transitions. Theories focusing on the causes of land system changes span theoretically and epistemologically disparate knowledge domains and build from deductive, abductive, and inductive approaches. A grand, integrated theory of land system change remains elusive. Yet, we show that middle-range theories – defined here as contextual generalizations that describe chains of causal mechanisms explaining a well-bounded range of phenomena, as well as the conditions that trigger, enable, or prevent these causal chains –, provide a path towards generalized knowledge of land systems. This knowledge can support progress towards sustainable social-ecological systems.

KW - Box and arrow framework

KW - Deforestation

KW - Human-environment systems

KW - Indirect land-use change

KW - Land-use intensification

KW - Land-use spillover

KW - Urban dynamics

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85053189401&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85053189401&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2018.08.006

DO - 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2018.08.006

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85053189401

VL - 53

SP - 52

EP - 67

JO - Global Environmental Change

JF - Global Environmental Change

SN - 0959-3780

ER -