Maximally dense random packings of spherocylinders

Lingyi Meng, Yang Jiao, Shuixiang Li

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

26 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

A spherocylinder, a convex 3D object consisting of a cylinder with two hemispherical ends, can possess a wide range of aspect ratios and is one of the most studied non-spherical particle shapes. Previous investigations on disordered spherocylinder packings yielded inconsistent packing characteristics, especially the packing density φ, indicating that density alone is not sufficient to uniquely characterize a packing. In this paper, we delineate in the density-order-metric diagram (i.e. order map) the border curve that separates geometrically feasible and infeasible packings of congruent spherocylinders via the geometric-structure approach, i.e., by generating and analyzing a large number of packing configurations with a diversity of densities and degrees of order generated via a relaxation algorithm. We find that the border curve possesses a sharp transition as the packing density increases, i.e., the initial increase of φ is not associated with any notable increase of the degree of order, while beyond a threshold φ value, the increase of density is strongly positively correlated with the increase of order. This allows us to propose the concept of maximally dense random packing (MDRP) state for spherocylinders, which corresponds to the transition point in the boarder curve and characterizes the on-set of nontrivial spatial correlations among the particles. It can also be considered as the maximally dense packing arrangement of spherocylinders without nontrivial spatial correlations. The degree of order of a spherocylinder packing is quantified via the nematic order parameter (S) and the local order metric (SLocal), which respectively characterize the level of global orientational order and local order in particle clusters. The latter metric SLocal, which measures the average order in the neighborhoods of particles with the second Legendre polynomial, is a new order metric for spherocylinder systems. We find that the packing density of the MDRPs initially increases with the increase of the aspect ratio w from 0, and reaches the maximal value of 0.725 when w = 0.5, then drops with further increase of w. The MDRP at w = 0.5 is verified to be jammed via a Monte Carlo jamming-testing algorithm and thus, should also represent the maximally random jammed (MRJ) packing state as well.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)176-185
Number of pages10
JournalPowder Technology
Volume292
DOIs
StatePublished - May 1 2016

Fingerprint

Aspect ratio
Jamming
Polynomials
Testing

Keywords

  • Geometric packing
  • Maximally dense random packing (MDRP)
  • Order map
  • Spherocylinder

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Chemical Engineering(all)

Cite this

Maximally dense random packings of spherocylinders. / Meng, Lingyi; Jiao, Yang; Li, Shuixiang.

In: Powder Technology, Vol. 292, 01.05.2016, p. 176-185.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Meng, Lingyi ; Jiao, Yang ; Li, Shuixiang. / Maximally dense random packings of spherocylinders. In: Powder Technology. 2016 ; Vol. 292. pp. 176-185.
@article{1e9ee08d85f242adad04ef1ed5c6c2d8,
title = "Maximally dense random packings of spherocylinders",
abstract = "A spherocylinder, a convex 3D object consisting of a cylinder with two hemispherical ends, can possess a wide range of aspect ratios and is one of the most studied non-spherical particle shapes. Previous investigations on disordered spherocylinder packings yielded inconsistent packing characteristics, especially the packing density φ, indicating that density alone is not sufficient to uniquely characterize a packing. In this paper, we delineate in the density-order-metric diagram (i.e. order map) the border curve that separates geometrically feasible and infeasible packings of congruent spherocylinders via the geometric-structure approach, i.e., by generating and analyzing a large number of packing configurations with a diversity of densities and degrees of order generated via a relaxation algorithm. We find that the border curve possesses a sharp transition as the packing density increases, i.e., the initial increase of φ is not associated with any notable increase of the degree of order, while beyond a threshold φ value, the increase of density is strongly positively correlated with the increase of order. This allows us to propose the concept of maximally dense random packing (MDRP) state for spherocylinders, which corresponds to the transition point in the boarder curve and characterizes the on-set of nontrivial spatial correlations among the particles. It can also be considered as the maximally dense packing arrangement of spherocylinders without nontrivial spatial correlations. The degree of order of a spherocylinder packing is quantified via the nematic order parameter (S) and the local order metric (SLocal), which respectively characterize the level of global orientational order and local order in particle clusters. The latter metric SLocal, which measures the average order in the neighborhoods of particles with the second Legendre polynomial, is a new order metric for spherocylinder systems. We find that the packing density of the MDRPs initially increases with the increase of the aspect ratio w from 0, and reaches the maximal value of 0.725 when w = 0.5, then drops with further increase of w. The MDRP at w = 0.5 is verified to be jammed via a Monte Carlo jamming-testing algorithm and thus, should also represent the maximally random jammed (MRJ) packing state as well.",
keywords = "Geometric packing, Maximally dense random packing (MDRP), Order map, Spherocylinder",
author = "Lingyi Meng and Yang Jiao and Shuixiang Li",
year = "2016",
month = "5",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.powtec.2016.01.036",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "292",
pages = "176--185",
journal = "Powder Technology",
issn = "0032-5910",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Maximally dense random packings of spherocylinders

AU - Meng, Lingyi

AU - Jiao, Yang

AU - Li, Shuixiang

PY - 2016/5/1

Y1 - 2016/5/1

N2 - A spherocylinder, a convex 3D object consisting of a cylinder with two hemispherical ends, can possess a wide range of aspect ratios and is one of the most studied non-spherical particle shapes. Previous investigations on disordered spherocylinder packings yielded inconsistent packing characteristics, especially the packing density φ, indicating that density alone is not sufficient to uniquely characterize a packing. In this paper, we delineate in the density-order-metric diagram (i.e. order map) the border curve that separates geometrically feasible and infeasible packings of congruent spherocylinders via the geometric-structure approach, i.e., by generating and analyzing a large number of packing configurations with a diversity of densities and degrees of order generated via a relaxation algorithm. We find that the border curve possesses a sharp transition as the packing density increases, i.e., the initial increase of φ is not associated with any notable increase of the degree of order, while beyond a threshold φ value, the increase of density is strongly positively correlated with the increase of order. This allows us to propose the concept of maximally dense random packing (MDRP) state for spherocylinders, which corresponds to the transition point in the boarder curve and characterizes the on-set of nontrivial spatial correlations among the particles. It can also be considered as the maximally dense packing arrangement of spherocylinders without nontrivial spatial correlations. The degree of order of a spherocylinder packing is quantified via the nematic order parameter (S) and the local order metric (SLocal), which respectively characterize the level of global orientational order and local order in particle clusters. The latter metric SLocal, which measures the average order in the neighborhoods of particles with the second Legendre polynomial, is a new order metric for spherocylinder systems. We find that the packing density of the MDRPs initially increases with the increase of the aspect ratio w from 0, and reaches the maximal value of 0.725 when w = 0.5, then drops with further increase of w. The MDRP at w = 0.5 is verified to be jammed via a Monte Carlo jamming-testing algorithm and thus, should also represent the maximally random jammed (MRJ) packing state as well.

AB - A spherocylinder, a convex 3D object consisting of a cylinder with two hemispherical ends, can possess a wide range of aspect ratios and is one of the most studied non-spherical particle shapes. Previous investigations on disordered spherocylinder packings yielded inconsistent packing characteristics, especially the packing density φ, indicating that density alone is not sufficient to uniquely characterize a packing. In this paper, we delineate in the density-order-metric diagram (i.e. order map) the border curve that separates geometrically feasible and infeasible packings of congruent spherocylinders via the geometric-structure approach, i.e., by generating and analyzing a large number of packing configurations with a diversity of densities and degrees of order generated via a relaxation algorithm. We find that the border curve possesses a sharp transition as the packing density increases, i.e., the initial increase of φ is not associated with any notable increase of the degree of order, while beyond a threshold φ value, the increase of density is strongly positively correlated with the increase of order. This allows us to propose the concept of maximally dense random packing (MDRP) state for spherocylinders, which corresponds to the transition point in the boarder curve and characterizes the on-set of nontrivial spatial correlations among the particles. It can also be considered as the maximally dense packing arrangement of spherocylinders without nontrivial spatial correlations. The degree of order of a spherocylinder packing is quantified via the nematic order parameter (S) and the local order metric (SLocal), which respectively characterize the level of global orientational order and local order in particle clusters. The latter metric SLocal, which measures the average order in the neighborhoods of particles with the second Legendre polynomial, is a new order metric for spherocylinder systems. We find that the packing density of the MDRPs initially increases with the increase of the aspect ratio w from 0, and reaches the maximal value of 0.725 when w = 0.5, then drops with further increase of w. The MDRP at w = 0.5 is verified to be jammed via a Monte Carlo jamming-testing algorithm and thus, should also represent the maximally random jammed (MRJ) packing state as well.

KW - Geometric packing

KW - Maximally dense random packing (MDRP)

KW - Order map

KW - Spherocylinder

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84958753574&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84958753574&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.powtec.2016.01.036

DO - 10.1016/j.powtec.2016.01.036

M3 - Article

VL - 292

SP - 176

EP - 185

JO - Powder Technology

JF - Powder Technology

SN - 0032-5910

ER -