“Just Say no?” The Economic and Political Realities of a Small City's Investment in Minor League Baseball

Mark S. Rosentraub, David Swindell

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

23 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The magical aura which encases sports in our society continues to encourage cities to offer inducements to attract franchises. Now, even minor league franchises have become coveted assets by smaller cities seeking the same “glamour” that major league teams give larger cities. Smaller cities are seemingly mesmerized by the idea, “build it and they will come.” The “they” is the anticipated economic impact and benefits of the team. This article analyzed one city's decision by measuring the substitution effects and real growth impact of a team on the local economy. Given the tax structure in the community and the marginal impact of the team, the city and the private sector made the correct decision in not offering substantial inducements; net gains were too small for all concerned. The small impact also suggests no natural constituency existed to support the needed investments. Finally, some have argued economic analyses are not the most important element in considering whether or not to invest in sports since baseball is a form of escapism and publicity. If these are valued ideas it remains for city councils and voters to decide if the “Boys of Summer” really define a community's image, culture, placement in the fabric of American society, and the quality of life. Or, is a minor league baseball team simply an example of “big boys wanting big toys” at someone else's expense.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)152-167
Number of pages16
JournalEconomic Development Quarterly
Volume5
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - 1991
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

economics
Sports
escapism
sport
municipal council
toy
local economy
publicity
large city
economic impact
taxes
substitution
community
private sector
quality of life
assets
city
Baseball
Economics
summer

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Economics and Econometrics
  • Urban Studies
  • Development

Cite this

“Just Say no?” The Economic and Political Realities of a Small City's Investment in Minor League Baseball. / Rosentraub, Mark S.; Swindell, David.

In: Economic Development Quarterly, Vol. 5, No. 2, 1991, p. 152-167.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{e04a143087d046fd9ac74bb60baebaee,
title = "“Just Say no?” The Economic and Political Realities of a Small City's Investment in Minor League Baseball",
abstract = "The magical aura which encases sports in our society continues to encourage cities to offer inducements to attract franchises. Now, even minor league franchises have become coveted assets by smaller cities seeking the same “glamour” that major league teams give larger cities. Smaller cities are seemingly mesmerized by the idea, “build it and they will come.” The “they” is the anticipated economic impact and benefits of the team. This article analyzed one city's decision by measuring the substitution effects and real growth impact of a team on the local economy. Given the tax structure in the community and the marginal impact of the team, the city and the private sector made the correct decision in not offering substantial inducements; net gains were too small for all concerned. The small impact also suggests no natural constituency existed to support the needed investments. Finally, some have argued economic analyses are not the most important element in considering whether or not to invest in sports since baseball is a form of escapism and publicity. If these are valued ideas it remains for city councils and voters to decide if the “Boys of Summer” really define a community's image, culture, placement in the fabric of American society, and the quality of life. Or, is a minor league baseball team simply an example of “big boys wanting big toys” at someone else's expense.",
author = "Rosentraub, {Mark S.} and David Swindell",
year = "1991",
doi = "10.1177/089124249100500206",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "5",
pages = "152--167",
journal = "Economic Development Quarterly",
issn = "0891-2424",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Inc.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - “Just Say no?” The Economic and Political Realities of a Small City's Investment in Minor League Baseball

AU - Rosentraub, Mark S.

AU - Swindell, David

PY - 1991

Y1 - 1991

N2 - The magical aura which encases sports in our society continues to encourage cities to offer inducements to attract franchises. Now, even minor league franchises have become coveted assets by smaller cities seeking the same “glamour” that major league teams give larger cities. Smaller cities are seemingly mesmerized by the idea, “build it and they will come.” The “they” is the anticipated economic impact and benefits of the team. This article analyzed one city's decision by measuring the substitution effects and real growth impact of a team on the local economy. Given the tax structure in the community and the marginal impact of the team, the city and the private sector made the correct decision in not offering substantial inducements; net gains were too small for all concerned. The small impact also suggests no natural constituency existed to support the needed investments. Finally, some have argued economic analyses are not the most important element in considering whether or not to invest in sports since baseball is a form of escapism and publicity. If these are valued ideas it remains for city councils and voters to decide if the “Boys of Summer” really define a community's image, culture, placement in the fabric of American society, and the quality of life. Or, is a minor league baseball team simply an example of “big boys wanting big toys” at someone else's expense.

AB - The magical aura which encases sports in our society continues to encourage cities to offer inducements to attract franchises. Now, even minor league franchises have become coveted assets by smaller cities seeking the same “glamour” that major league teams give larger cities. Smaller cities are seemingly mesmerized by the idea, “build it and they will come.” The “they” is the anticipated economic impact and benefits of the team. This article analyzed one city's decision by measuring the substitution effects and real growth impact of a team on the local economy. Given the tax structure in the community and the marginal impact of the team, the city and the private sector made the correct decision in not offering substantial inducements; net gains were too small for all concerned. The small impact also suggests no natural constituency existed to support the needed investments. Finally, some have argued economic analyses are not the most important element in considering whether or not to invest in sports since baseball is a form of escapism and publicity. If these are valued ideas it remains for city councils and voters to decide if the “Boys of Summer” really define a community's image, culture, placement in the fabric of American society, and the quality of life. Or, is a minor league baseball team simply an example of “big boys wanting big toys” at someone else's expense.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84972668315&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84972668315&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/089124249100500206

DO - 10.1177/089124249100500206

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84972668315

VL - 5

SP - 152

EP - 167

JO - Economic Development Quarterly

JF - Economic Development Quarterly

SN - 0891-2424

IS - 2

ER -