Intentional disruption of path-dependencies in the Anthropocene

Gray versus green water infrastructure regimes in Mexico City, Mexico

David Manuel-Navarrete, Christopher Morehart, Beth Tellman, Hallie Eakin, J. Mario Siqueiros-García, Bertha Hernández Aguilar

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Cities are urged to promote green infrastructures to reduce their global environmental impacts, while simultaneously adapting to the global climatic variability that such impacts generate. Human Niche Construction theory, however, predicts evolutionary pressures acting over social groups that, this paper contends, tend to favor gray over green infrastructure. This conflict is due to competitive advantages of gray infrastructure, such as their higher capacity to concentrate and intensively use natural resources. Cities need to intentionally override these evolutionary pressures to allow emergence of regimes where green solutions are the normal way of responding to infrastructure-related challenges and development. The override calls for understanding how infrastructure regime dynamics are historically constructed, and cultivating collective intentions capable of harnessing such dynamics. After conceptualizing the roles of evolution versus collective intentionality in infrastructure regime dynamics, we apply Foucauldian genealogical analysis to critically understand how and why the superiority of gray infrastructure became naturalized as truth in Mexico City, Mexico. The analysis explores how gray infrastructure momentum was built over history and the sporadic emergence of collective intentions to break it. Findings show that shifting to a green- infrastructure-dominated regime in Mexico City today would benefit from strategies that simultaneously promote technical, political and subjective changes. Purely technical efforts to promote regime shifts are doomed to fail. Decentralization, democratization, and cultivating certain collective intentions are key factors to override evolutionary pressures. In the context of the anthropocene and growing recognition of the importance of artificially created environments, we remphasize subjectivity and intentionality.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number100209
JournalAnthropocene
Volume26
DOIs
StatePublished - Jun 1 2019

Fingerprint

infrastructure
water
Anthropocene
city
democratization
decentralization
niche
momentum
environmental impact
natural resource
history

Keywords

  • Climate variability
  • Deliberate transformations
  • Green
  • Human niche construction theory
  • Infrastructure
  • Mexico City
  • Path-dependencies

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Global and Planetary Change
  • Ecology
  • Earth and Planetary Sciences (miscellaneous)

Cite this

Intentional disruption of path-dependencies in the Anthropocene : Gray versus green water infrastructure regimes in Mexico City, Mexico. / Manuel-Navarrete, David; Morehart, Christopher; Tellman, Beth; Eakin, Hallie; Siqueiros-García, J. Mario; Hernández Aguilar, Bertha.

In: Anthropocene, Vol. 26, 100209, 01.06.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{270cfc9e25894595bde9c40d651575bf,
title = "Intentional disruption of path-dependencies in the Anthropocene: Gray versus green water infrastructure regimes in Mexico City, Mexico",
abstract = "Cities are urged to promote green infrastructures to reduce their global environmental impacts, while simultaneously adapting to the global climatic variability that such impacts generate. Human Niche Construction theory, however, predicts evolutionary pressures acting over social groups that, this paper contends, tend to favor gray over green infrastructure. This conflict is due to competitive advantages of gray infrastructure, such as their higher capacity to concentrate and intensively use natural resources. Cities need to intentionally override these evolutionary pressures to allow emergence of regimes where green solutions are the normal way of responding to infrastructure-related challenges and development. The override calls for understanding how infrastructure regime dynamics are historically constructed, and cultivating collective intentions capable of harnessing such dynamics. After conceptualizing the roles of evolution versus collective intentionality in infrastructure regime dynamics, we apply Foucauldian genealogical analysis to critically understand how and why the superiority of gray infrastructure became naturalized as truth in Mexico City, Mexico. The analysis explores how gray infrastructure momentum was built over history and the sporadic emergence of collective intentions to break it. Findings show that shifting to a green- infrastructure-dominated regime in Mexico City today would benefit from strategies that simultaneously promote technical, political and subjective changes. Purely technical efforts to promote regime shifts are doomed to fail. Decentralization, democratization, and cultivating certain collective intentions are key factors to override evolutionary pressures. In the context of the anthropocene and growing recognition of the importance of artificially created environments, we remphasize subjectivity and intentionality.",
keywords = "Climate variability, Deliberate transformations, Green, Human niche construction theory, Infrastructure, Mexico City, Path-dependencies",
author = "David Manuel-Navarrete and Christopher Morehart and Beth Tellman and Hallie Eakin and Siqueiros-Garc{\'i}a, {J. Mario} and {Hern{\'a}ndez Aguilar}, Bertha",
year = "2019",
month = "6",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.ancene.2019.100209",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "26",
journal = "Anthropocene",
issn = "2213-3054",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Intentional disruption of path-dependencies in the Anthropocene

T2 - Gray versus green water infrastructure regimes in Mexico City, Mexico

AU - Manuel-Navarrete, David

AU - Morehart, Christopher

AU - Tellman, Beth

AU - Eakin, Hallie

AU - Siqueiros-García, J. Mario

AU - Hernández Aguilar, Bertha

PY - 2019/6/1

Y1 - 2019/6/1

N2 - Cities are urged to promote green infrastructures to reduce their global environmental impacts, while simultaneously adapting to the global climatic variability that such impacts generate. Human Niche Construction theory, however, predicts evolutionary pressures acting over social groups that, this paper contends, tend to favor gray over green infrastructure. This conflict is due to competitive advantages of gray infrastructure, such as their higher capacity to concentrate and intensively use natural resources. Cities need to intentionally override these evolutionary pressures to allow emergence of regimes where green solutions are the normal way of responding to infrastructure-related challenges and development. The override calls for understanding how infrastructure regime dynamics are historically constructed, and cultivating collective intentions capable of harnessing such dynamics. After conceptualizing the roles of evolution versus collective intentionality in infrastructure regime dynamics, we apply Foucauldian genealogical analysis to critically understand how and why the superiority of gray infrastructure became naturalized as truth in Mexico City, Mexico. The analysis explores how gray infrastructure momentum was built over history and the sporadic emergence of collective intentions to break it. Findings show that shifting to a green- infrastructure-dominated regime in Mexico City today would benefit from strategies that simultaneously promote technical, political and subjective changes. Purely technical efforts to promote regime shifts are doomed to fail. Decentralization, democratization, and cultivating certain collective intentions are key factors to override evolutionary pressures. In the context of the anthropocene and growing recognition of the importance of artificially created environments, we remphasize subjectivity and intentionality.

AB - Cities are urged to promote green infrastructures to reduce their global environmental impacts, while simultaneously adapting to the global climatic variability that such impacts generate. Human Niche Construction theory, however, predicts evolutionary pressures acting over social groups that, this paper contends, tend to favor gray over green infrastructure. This conflict is due to competitive advantages of gray infrastructure, such as their higher capacity to concentrate and intensively use natural resources. Cities need to intentionally override these evolutionary pressures to allow emergence of regimes where green solutions are the normal way of responding to infrastructure-related challenges and development. The override calls for understanding how infrastructure regime dynamics are historically constructed, and cultivating collective intentions capable of harnessing such dynamics. After conceptualizing the roles of evolution versus collective intentionality in infrastructure regime dynamics, we apply Foucauldian genealogical analysis to critically understand how and why the superiority of gray infrastructure became naturalized as truth in Mexico City, Mexico. The analysis explores how gray infrastructure momentum was built over history and the sporadic emergence of collective intentions to break it. Findings show that shifting to a green- infrastructure-dominated regime in Mexico City today would benefit from strategies that simultaneously promote technical, political and subjective changes. Purely technical efforts to promote regime shifts are doomed to fail. Decentralization, democratization, and cultivating certain collective intentions are key factors to override evolutionary pressures. In the context of the anthropocene and growing recognition of the importance of artificially created environments, we remphasize subjectivity and intentionality.

KW - Climate variability

KW - Deliberate transformations

KW - Green

KW - Human niche construction theory

KW - Infrastructure

KW - Mexico City

KW - Path-dependencies

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85065164046&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85065164046&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.ancene.2019.100209

DO - 10.1016/j.ancene.2019.100209

M3 - Article

VL - 26

JO - Anthropocene

JF - Anthropocene

SN - 2213-3054

M1 - 100209

ER -