Hydrocarbon and oxygen transport in the vicinity of a building overlying a NAPL source zone

Hong Luo, Paul Dahlen, Paul C. Johnson

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Within the context of developing guidelines for assessing petroleum-impacted sites for vapor intrusion pathway significance, the concepts of "exclusion criteria" and an "exclusion distance" are often introduced. The concept is that one uses site criteria (i.e. depth to source, soil setting, etc.) to exclude the need to conduct further pathway assessment, rather than sample chemical concentrations in soil gas or indoor air. This is appealing, particularly for petroleum-impacted sites, because modeling results and field studies suggest that there will be some settings where vapor transport is significantly attenuated by aerobic biodegradation. Three-dimensional modeling results have been used by some to propose depth and source concentration combinations that can be assumed to have de minimis risks. The potential weakness of this approach is that base-case simplified geologies are often used and it is assumed that the base-case inputs are inherently conservative. Case studies are needed to validate modeling results and that is the intent of this work. Soil gas concentrations were monitored in the vicinity of a one-story 2100 ft2 building having a basement extending 5 ft below ground surface (BGS). Non aqueous-phase liquid (NAPL) impacted soils are first encountered at about 9.2 m (30 ft) BGS to 10.6 m (35 ft) BGS. The data show relatively uniform and elevated (60-160 mg/L) hydrocarbon vapor concentrations and depleted O2 beneath and around the building foundation, which is not anticipated by simplistic scenario modeling results. Detailed soil respiration and air permeability test results suggest two possible reasons for the observed behavior, a) significant background O2 uptake in surface soils or b) physically limited O2 transport from the atmosphere. Soil O2 uptake rates at four locations at the depth of 0-4.0 ft BGS around building foundation ranged from 2-25 mg-O 2/kg-soil/day. There also was a silt/clay zone between 2-5 ft BGS and 7-8 ft BGS with an air permeability of less than 10-14 m 2. The results from this study showed that simplistic generic scenario modeling results should be used with caution, and that factors reducing O2 transport from the atmosphere to the subsurface can significantly affect the vapor distribution at petroleum hydrocarbon sites.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Title of host publicationAir and Waste Management Association - Vapor Intrusion 2010
Pages155-185
Number of pages31
Volume1
StatePublished - 2010
EventAir and Waste Management Association - Vapor Intrusion 2010 - Chicago, IL, United States
Duration: Sep 29 2010Sep 30 2010

Other

OtherAir and Waste Management Association - Vapor Intrusion 2010
CountryUnited States
CityChicago, IL
Period9/29/109/30/10

Fingerprint

nonaqueous phase liquid
Hydrocarbons
hydrocarbon
Soils
oxygen
Oxygen
Liquids
air permeability
soil gas
Vapors
Air permeability
modeling
Crude oil
soil
petroleum
three-dimensional modeling
atmosphere
soil air
petroleum hydrocarbon
soil respiration

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Environmental Engineering
  • Waste Management and Disposal

Cite this

Luo, H., Dahlen, P., & Johnson, P. C. (2010). Hydrocarbon and oxygen transport in the vicinity of a building overlying a NAPL source zone. In Air and Waste Management Association - Vapor Intrusion 2010 (Vol. 1, pp. 155-185)

Hydrocarbon and oxygen transport in the vicinity of a building overlying a NAPL source zone. / Luo, Hong; Dahlen, Paul; Johnson, Paul C.

Air and Waste Management Association - Vapor Intrusion 2010. Vol. 1 2010. p. 155-185.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Luo, H, Dahlen, P & Johnson, PC 2010, Hydrocarbon and oxygen transport in the vicinity of a building overlying a NAPL source zone. in Air and Waste Management Association - Vapor Intrusion 2010. vol. 1, pp. 155-185, Air and Waste Management Association - Vapor Intrusion 2010, Chicago, IL, United States, 9/29/10.
Luo H, Dahlen P, Johnson PC. Hydrocarbon and oxygen transport in the vicinity of a building overlying a NAPL source zone. In Air and Waste Management Association - Vapor Intrusion 2010. Vol. 1. 2010. p. 155-185
Luo, Hong ; Dahlen, Paul ; Johnson, Paul C. / Hydrocarbon and oxygen transport in the vicinity of a building overlying a NAPL source zone. Air and Waste Management Association - Vapor Intrusion 2010. Vol. 1 2010. pp. 155-185
@inproceedings{4bb2c6ac718f441cbe7da30f40a5ac16,
title = "Hydrocarbon and oxygen transport in the vicinity of a building overlying a NAPL source zone",
abstract = "Within the context of developing guidelines for assessing petroleum-impacted sites for vapor intrusion pathway significance, the concepts of {"}exclusion criteria{"} and an {"}exclusion distance{"} are often introduced. The concept is that one uses site criteria (i.e. depth to source, soil setting, etc.) to exclude the need to conduct further pathway assessment, rather than sample chemical concentrations in soil gas or indoor air. This is appealing, particularly for petroleum-impacted sites, because modeling results and field studies suggest that there will be some settings where vapor transport is significantly attenuated by aerobic biodegradation. Three-dimensional modeling results have been used by some to propose depth and source concentration combinations that can be assumed to have de minimis risks. The potential weakness of this approach is that base-case simplified geologies are often used and it is assumed that the base-case inputs are inherently conservative. Case studies are needed to validate modeling results and that is the intent of this work. Soil gas concentrations were monitored in the vicinity of a one-story 2100 ft2 building having a basement extending 5 ft below ground surface (BGS). Non aqueous-phase liquid (NAPL) impacted soils are first encountered at about 9.2 m (30 ft) BGS to 10.6 m (35 ft) BGS. The data show relatively uniform and elevated (60-160 mg/L) hydrocarbon vapor concentrations and depleted O2 beneath and around the building foundation, which is not anticipated by simplistic scenario modeling results. Detailed soil respiration and air permeability test results suggest two possible reasons for the observed behavior, a) significant background O2 uptake in surface soils or b) physically limited O2 transport from the atmosphere. Soil O2 uptake rates at four locations at the depth of 0-4.0 ft BGS around building foundation ranged from 2-25 mg-O 2/kg-soil/day. There also was a silt/clay zone between 2-5 ft BGS and 7-8 ft BGS with an air permeability of less than 10-14 m 2. The results from this study showed that simplistic generic scenario modeling results should be used with caution, and that factors reducing O2 transport from the atmosphere to the subsurface can significantly affect the vapor distribution at petroleum hydrocarbon sites.",
author = "Hong Luo and Paul Dahlen and Johnson, {Paul C.}",
year = "2010",
language = "English (US)",
isbn = "9781617821707",
volume = "1",
pages = "155--185",
booktitle = "Air and Waste Management Association - Vapor Intrusion 2010",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - Hydrocarbon and oxygen transport in the vicinity of a building overlying a NAPL source zone

AU - Luo, Hong

AU - Dahlen, Paul

AU - Johnson, Paul C.

PY - 2010

Y1 - 2010

N2 - Within the context of developing guidelines for assessing petroleum-impacted sites for vapor intrusion pathway significance, the concepts of "exclusion criteria" and an "exclusion distance" are often introduced. The concept is that one uses site criteria (i.e. depth to source, soil setting, etc.) to exclude the need to conduct further pathway assessment, rather than sample chemical concentrations in soil gas or indoor air. This is appealing, particularly for petroleum-impacted sites, because modeling results and field studies suggest that there will be some settings where vapor transport is significantly attenuated by aerobic biodegradation. Three-dimensional modeling results have been used by some to propose depth and source concentration combinations that can be assumed to have de minimis risks. The potential weakness of this approach is that base-case simplified geologies are often used and it is assumed that the base-case inputs are inherently conservative. Case studies are needed to validate modeling results and that is the intent of this work. Soil gas concentrations were monitored in the vicinity of a one-story 2100 ft2 building having a basement extending 5 ft below ground surface (BGS). Non aqueous-phase liquid (NAPL) impacted soils are first encountered at about 9.2 m (30 ft) BGS to 10.6 m (35 ft) BGS. The data show relatively uniform and elevated (60-160 mg/L) hydrocarbon vapor concentrations and depleted O2 beneath and around the building foundation, which is not anticipated by simplistic scenario modeling results. Detailed soil respiration and air permeability test results suggest two possible reasons for the observed behavior, a) significant background O2 uptake in surface soils or b) physically limited O2 transport from the atmosphere. Soil O2 uptake rates at four locations at the depth of 0-4.0 ft BGS around building foundation ranged from 2-25 mg-O 2/kg-soil/day. There also was a silt/clay zone between 2-5 ft BGS and 7-8 ft BGS with an air permeability of less than 10-14 m 2. The results from this study showed that simplistic generic scenario modeling results should be used with caution, and that factors reducing O2 transport from the atmosphere to the subsurface can significantly affect the vapor distribution at petroleum hydrocarbon sites.

AB - Within the context of developing guidelines for assessing petroleum-impacted sites for vapor intrusion pathway significance, the concepts of "exclusion criteria" and an "exclusion distance" are often introduced. The concept is that one uses site criteria (i.e. depth to source, soil setting, etc.) to exclude the need to conduct further pathway assessment, rather than sample chemical concentrations in soil gas or indoor air. This is appealing, particularly for petroleum-impacted sites, because modeling results and field studies suggest that there will be some settings where vapor transport is significantly attenuated by aerobic biodegradation. Three-dimensional modeling results have been used by some to propose depth and source concentration combinations that can be assumed to have de minimis risks. The potential weakness of this approach is that base-case simplified geologies are often used and it is assumed that the base-case inputs are inherently conservative. Case studies are needed to validate modeling results and that is the intent of this work. Soil gas concentrations were monitored in the vicinity of a one-story 2100 ft2 building having a basement extending 5 ft below ground surface (BGS). Non aqueous-phase liquid (NAPL) impacted soils are first encountered at about 9.2 m (30 ft) BGS to 10.6 m (35 ft) BGS. The data show relatively uniform and elevated (60-160 mg/L) hydrocarbon vapor concentrations and depleted O2 beneath and around the building foundation, which is not anticipated by simplistic scenario modeling results. Detailed soil respiration and air permeability test results suggest two possible reasons for the observed behavior, a) significant background O2 uptake in surface soils or b) physically limited O2 transport from the atmosphere. Soil O2 uptake rates at four locations at the depth of 0-4.0 ft BGS around building foundation ranged from 2-25 mg-O 2/kg-soil/day. There also was a silt/clay zone between 2-5 ft BGS and 7-8 ft BGS with an air permeability of less than 10-14 m 2. The results from this study showed that simplistic generic scenario modeling results should be used with caution, and that factors reducing O2 transport from the atmosphere to the subsurface can significantly affect the vapor distribution at petroleum hydrocarbon sites.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=79953075415&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=79953075415&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Conference contribution

SN - 9781617821707

VL - 1

SP - 155

EP - 185

BT - Air and Waste Management Association - Vapor Intrusion 2010

ER -