Global assessment of experimental climate warming on tundra vegetation: Heterogeneity over space and time

Sarah C. Elmendorf, Gregory H R Henry, Robert D. Hollister, Robert G. Björk, Anne D. Bjorkman, Terry V. Callaghan, Laura Siegwart Collier, Elisabeth J. Cooper, Johannes H C Cornelissen, Thomas Day, Anna Maria Fosaa, William A. Gould, Járngerur Grétarsdóttir, John Harte, Luise Hermanutz, David S. Hik, Annika Hofgaard, Frith Jarrad, Ingibjörg Svala Jónsdóttir, Frida KeuperKari Klanderud, Julia A. Klein, Saewan Koh, Gaku Kudo, Simone I. Lang, Val Loewen, Jeremy L. May, Joel Mercado, Anders Michelsen, Ulf Molau, Isla H. Myers-Smith, Steven F. Oberbauer, Sara Pieper, Eric Post, Christian Rixen, Clare H. Robinson, Niels Martin Schmidt, Gaius R. Shaver, Anna Stenström, Anne Tolvanen, Ørjan Totland, Tiffany Troxler, Carl Henrik Wahren, Patrick J. Webber, Jeffery M. Welker, Philip A. Wookey

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

449 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Understanding the sensitivity of tundra vegetation to climate warming is critical to forecasting future biodiversity and vegetation feedbacks to climate. In situ warming experiments accelerate climate change on a small scale to forecast responses of local plant communities. Limitations of this approach include the apparent site-specificity of results and uncertainty about the power of short-term studies to anticipate longer term change. We address these issues with a synthesis of 61 experimental warming studies, of up to 20years duration, in tundra sites worldwide. The response of plant groups to warming often differed with ambient summer temperature, soil moisture and experimental duration. Shrubs increased with warming only where ambient temperature was high, whereas graminoids increased primarily in the coldest study sites. Linear increases in effect size over time were frequently observed. There was little indication of saturating or accelerating effects, as would be predicted if negative or positive vegetation feedbacks were common. These results indicate that tundra vegetation exhibits strong regional variation in response to warming, and that in vulnerable regions, cumulative effects of long-term warming on tundra vegetation - and associated ecosystem consequences - have the potential to be much greater than we have observed to date.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)164-175
Number of pages12
JournalEcology Letters
Volume15
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 2012

Fingerprint

tundra
space and time
global warming
warming
vegetation
climate
duration
plant response
long term effects
plant communities
ambient temperature
uncertainty
shrubs
soil water
climate change
long-term change
biodiversity
plant community
synthesis
ecosystems

Keywords

  • Alpine
  • Arctic
  • Climate warming
  • Long-term experiment
  • Meta-analysis
  • Plants

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics

Cite this

Elmendorf, S. C., Henry, G. H. R., Hollister, R. D., Björk, R. G., Bjorkman, A. D., Callaghan, T. V., ... Wookey, P. A. (2012). Global assessment of experimental climate warming on tundra vegetation: Heterogeneity over space and time. Ecology Letters, 15(2), 164-175. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1461-0248.2011.01716.x

Global assessment of experimental climate warming on tundra vegetation : Heterogeneity over space and time. / Elmendorf, Sarah C.; Henry, Gregory H R; Hollister, Robert D.; Björk, Robert G.; Bjorkman, Anne D.; Callaghan, Terry V.; Collier, Laura Siegwart; Cooper, Elisabeth J.; Cornelissen, Johannes H C; Day, Thomas; Fosaa, Anna Maria; Gould, William A.; Grétarsdóttir, Járngerur; Harte, John; Hermanutz, Luise; Hik, David S.; Hofgaard, Annika; Jarrad, Frith; Jónsdóttir, Ingibjörg Svala; Keuper, Frida; Klanderud, Kari; Klein, Julia A.; Koh, Saewan; Kudo, Gaku; Lang, Simone I.; Loewen, Val; May, Jeremy L.; Mercado, Joel; Michelsen, Anders; Molau, Ulf; Myers-Smith, Isla H.; Oberbauer, Steven F.; Pieper, Sara; Post, Eric; Rixen, Christian; Robinson, Clare H.; Schmidt, Niels Martin; Shaver, Gaius R.; Stenström, Anna; Tolvanen, Anne; Totland, Ørjan; Troxler, Tiffany; Wahren, Carl Henrik; Webber, Patrick J.; Welker, Jeffery M.; Wookey, Philip A.

In: Ecology Letters, Vol. 15, No. 2, 02.2012, p. 164-175.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Elmendorf, SC, Henry, GHR, Hollister, RD, Björk, RG, Bjorkman, AD, Callaghan, TV, Collier, LS, Cooper, EJ, Cornelissen, JHC, Day, T, Fosaa, AM, Gould, WA, Grétarsdóttir, J, Harte, J, Hermanutz, L, Hik, DS, Hofgaard, A, Jarrad, F, Jónsdóttir, IS, Keuper, F, Klanderud, K, Klein, JA, Koh, S, Kudo, G, Lang, SI, Loewen, V, May, JL, Mercado, J, Michelsen, A, Molau, U, Myers-Smith, IH, Oberbauer, SF, Pieper, S, Post, E, Rixen, C, Robinson, CH, Schmidt, NM, Shaver, GR, Stenström, A, Tolvanen, A, Totland, Ø, Troxler, T, Wahren, CH, Webber, PJ, Welker, JM & Wookey, PA 2012, 'Global assessment of experimental climate warming on tundra vegetation: Heterogeneity over space and time', Ecology Letters, vol. 15, no. 2, pp. 164-175. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1461-0248.2011.01716.x
Elmendorf, Sarah C. ; Henry, Gregory H R ; Hollister, Robert D. ; Björk, Robert G. ; Bjorkman, Anne D. ; Callaghan, Terry V. ; Collier, Laura Siegwart ; Cooper, Elisabeth J. ; Cornelissen, Johannes H C ; Day, Thomas ; Fosaa, Anna Maria ; Gould, William A. ; Grétarsdóttir, Járngerur ; Harte, John ; Hermanutz, Luise ; Hik, David S. ; Hofgaard, Annika ; Jarrad, Frith ; Jónsdóttir, Ingibjörg Svala ; Keuper, Frida ; Klanderud, Kari ; Klein, Julia A. ; Koh, Saewan ; Kudo, Gaku ; Lang, Simone I. ; Loewen, Val ; May, Jeremy L. ; Mercado, Joel ; Michelsen, Anders ; Molau, Ulf ; Myers-Smith, Isla H. ; Oberbauer, Steven F. ; Pieper, Sara ; Post, Eric ; Rixen, Christian ; Robinson, Clare H. ; Schmidt, Niels Martin ; Shaver, Gaius R. ; Stenström, Anna ; Tolvanen, Anne ; Totland, Ørjan ; Troxler, Tiffany ; Wahren, Carl Henrik ; Webber, Patrick J. ; Welker, Jeffery M. ; Wookey, Philip A. / Global assessment of experimental climate warming on tundra vegetation : Heterogeneity over space and time. In: Ecology Letters. 2012 ; Vol. 15, No. 2. pp. 164-175.
@article{a6070892170a4869aad8cfd342e5e153,
title = "Global assessment of experimental climate warming on tundra vegetation: Heterogeneity over space and time",
abstract = "Understanding the sensitivity of tundra vegetation to climate warming is critical to forecasting future biodiversity and vegetation feedbacks to climate. In situ warming experiments accelerate climate change on a small scale to forecast responses of local plant communities. Limitations of this approach include the apparent site-specificity of results and uncertainty about the power of short-term studies to anticipate longer term change. We address these issues with a synthesis of 61 experimental warming studies, of up to 20years duration, in tundra sites worldwide. The response of plant groups to warming often differed with ambient summer temperature, soil moisture and experimental duration. Shrubs increased with warming only where ambient temperature was high, whereas graminoids increased primarily in the coldest study sites. Linear increases in effect size over time were frequently observed. There was little indication of saturating or accelerating effects, as would be predicted if negative or positive vegetation feedbacks were common. These results indicate that tundra vegetation exhibits strong regional variation in response to warming, and that in vulnerable regions, cumulative effects of long-term warming on tundra vegetation - and associated ecosystem consequences - have the potential to be much greater than we have observed to date.",
keywords = "Alpine, Arctic, Climate warming, Long-term experiment, Meta-analysis, Plants",
author = "Elmendorf, {Sarah C.} and Henry, {Gregory H R} and Hollister, {Robert D.} and Bj{\"o}rk, {Robert G.} and Bjorkman, {Anne D.} and Callaghan, {Terry V.} and Collier, {Laura Siegwart} and Cooper, {Elisabeth J.} and Cornelissen, {Johannes H C} and Thomas Day and Fosaa, {Anna Maria} and Gould, {William A.} and J{\'a}rngerur Gr{\'e}tarsd{\'o}ttir and John Harte and Luise Hermanutz and Hik, {David S.} and Annika Hofgaard and Frith Jarrad and J{\'o}nsd{\'o}ttir, {Ingibj{\"o}rg Svala} and Frida Keuper and Kari Klanderud and Klein, {Julia A.} and Saewan Koh and Gaku Kudo and Lang, {Simone I.} and Val Loewen and May, {Jeremy L.} and Joel Mercado and Anders Michelsen and Ulf Molau and Myers-Smith, {Isla H.} and Oberbauer, {Steven F.} and Sara Pieper and Eric Post and Christian Rixen and Robinson, {Clare H.} and Schmidt, {Niels Martin} and Shaver, {Gaius R.} and Anna Stenstr{\"o}m and Anne Tolvanen and {\O}rjan Totland and Tiffany Troxler and Wahren, {Carl Henrik} and Webber, {Patrick J.} and Welker, {Jeffery M.} and Wookey, {Philip A.}",
year = "2012",
month = "2",
doi = "10.1111/j.1461-0248.2011.01716.x",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "15",
pages = "164--175",
journal = "Ecology Letters",
issn = "1461-023X",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Global assessment of experimental climate warming on tundra vegetation

T2 - Heterogeneity over space and time

AU - Elmendorf, Sarah C.

AU - Henry, Gregory H R

AU - Hollister, Robert D.

AU - Björk, Robert G.

AU - Bjorkman, Anne D.

AU - Callaghan, Terry V.

AU - Collier, Laura Siegwart

AU - Cooper, Elisabeth J.

AU - Cornelissen, Johannes H C

AU - Day, Thomas

AU - Fosaa, Anna Maria

AU - Gould, William A.

AU - Grétarsdóttir, Járngerur

AU - Harte, John

AU - Hermanutz, Luise

AU - Hik, David S.

AU - Hofgaard, Annika

AU - Jarrad, Frith

AU - Jónsdóttir, Ingibjörg Svala

AU - Keuper, Frida

AU - Klanderud, Kari

AU - Klein, Julia A.

AU - Koh, Saewan

AU - Kudo, Gaku

AU - Lang, Simone I.

AU - Loewen, Val

AU - May, Jeremy L.

AU - Mercado, Joel

AU - Michelsen, Anders

AU - Molau, Ulf

AU - Myers-Smith, Isla H.

AU - Oberbauer, Steven F.

AU - Pieper, Sara

AU - Post, Eric

AU - Rixen, Christian

AU - Robinson, Clare H.

AU - Schmidt, Niels Martin

AU - Shaver, Gaius R.

AU - Stenström, Anna

AU - Tolvanen, Anne

AU - Totland, Ørjan

AU - Troxler, Tiffany

AU - Wahren, Carl Henrik

AU - Webber, Patrick J.

AU - Welker, Jeffery M.

AU - Wookey, Philip A.

PY - 2012/2

Y1 - 2012/2

N2 - Understanding the sensitivity of tundra vegetation to climate warming is critical to forecasting future biodiversity and vegetation feedbacks to climate. In situ warming experiments accelerate climate change on a small scale to forecast responses of local plant communities. Limitations of this approach include the apparent site-specificity of results and uncertainty about the power of short-term studies to anticipate longer term change. We address these issues with a synthesis of 61 experimental warming studies, of up to 20years duration, in tundra sites worldwide. The response of plant groups to warming often differed with ambient summer temperature, soil moisture and experimental duration. Shrubs increased with warming only where ambient temperature was high, whereas graminoids increased primarily in the coldest study sites. Linear increases in effect size over time were frequently observed. There was little indication of saturating or accelerating effects, as would be predicted if negative or positive vegetation feedbacks were common. These results indicate that tundra vegetation exhibits strong regional variation in response to warming, and that in vulnerable regions, cumulative effects of long-term warming on tundra vegetation - and associated ecosystem consequences - have the potential to be much greater than we have observed to date.

AB - Understanding the sensitivity of tundra vegetation to climate warming is critical to forecasting future biodiversity and vegetation feedbacks to climate. In situ warming experiments accelerate climate change on a small scale to forecast responses of local plant communities. Limitations of this approach include the apparent site-specificity of results and uncertainty about the power of short-term studies to anticipate longer term change. We address these issues with a synthesis of 61 experimental warming studies, of up to 20years duration, in tundra sites worldwide. The response of plant groups to warming often differed with ambient summer temperature, soil moisture and experimental duration. Shrubs increased with warming only where ambient temperature was high, whereas graminoids increased primarily in the coldest study sites. Linear increases in effect size over time were frequently observed. There was little indication of saturating or accelerating effects, as would be predicted if negative or positive vegetation feedbacks were common. These results indicate that tundra vegetation exhibits strong regional variation in response to warming, and that in vulnerable regions, cumulative effects of long-term warming on tundra vegetation - and associated ecosystem consequences - have the potential to be much greater than we have observed to date.

KW - Alpine

KW - Arctic

KW - Climate warming

KW - Long-term experiment

KW - Meta-analysis

KW - Plants

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84855459967&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84855459967&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/j.1461-0248.2011.01716.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1461-0248.2011.01716.x

M3 - Article

C2 - 22136670

AN - SCOPUS:84855459967

VL - 15

SP - 164

EP - 175

JO - Ecology Letters

JF - Ecology Letters

SN - 1461-023X

IS - 2

ER -