Experimental determination of pyrite and molybdenite oxidation kinetics at nanomolar oxygen concentrations

Aleisha C. Johnson, Stephen J. Romaniello, Christopher T. Reinhard, Daniel D. Gregory, Emilio Garcia-Robledo, Niels Peter Revsbech, Donald E. Canfield, Timothy W. Lyons, Ariel Anbar

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Constraining the rate at which sulfide minerals undergo oxidative weathering at low atmospheric O2 is crucial for understanding the evolution of the Archean and Proterozoic biosphere when O2 was a trace atmospheric gas. However, recent studies attempting to constrain sulfide oxidation rates, atmospheric O2 sinks, and trace metal delivery to seawater under Archean conditions are limited by the need to extrapolate from experimental pyrite oxidation kinetics determined at much higher O2 levels. Extrapolation of those data sets to Archean levels of O2 (<10−5 present atmospheric level or PAL prior to 2.4 Ga) leads to more than an order of magnitude uncertainty in sulfide mineral oxidation rates, hampering efforts to quantify oxidative weathering under early Earth conditions. To quantify sulfide oxidation kinetics at low pO2, we conducted aqueous pyrite and molybdenite oxidation experiments at ∼2–1200 nM dissolved O2 and pH values 1.83, 5.08, and 8.58. Our experimental approach used LUMOS O2 sensors to extend the pO2 range explored by oxidation experiments down to 10−5 PAL pO2, the limit of the sensors, which is up to three orders of magnitude lower than the pO2 range explored in previous work. From these experiments, we use 28 independent rate measurements to derive a new rate law for the oxidation of pyrite as a function of pO2: rpyrite=10-8.83(±0.27)O2 0.50±0.04H+ -0.25±0.02, Where rpyrite is the rate of oxidation in mol/m2 sec, and the activities of dissolved [O2] and [H+] are in (mol/L). Our results most closely match the previous rate law presented by Williamson and Rimstidt (1994), but indicate a stronger pH dependence than previous studies. We also present the first kinetic rate law for molybdenite oxidation at low O2, based on 13 independent rate measurements: rmolybdenite=10-8.3(±2.3)O2 0.5±0.3, Where rmolybdenite is the rate of oxidation in mol/m2 sec, and the activity of dissolved [O2] is in (mol/L). We find molybdenite oxidation to be nearly as rapid as pyrite oxidation even at low concentrations of dissolved O2 (equivalent to <10−5 PAL pO2), in contrast to previous work which argued for a threshold effect for molybdenite oxidation. Both pyrite and molybdenite oxidation kinetics exhibit a constant half-order dependence on dissolved O2 down to nanomolar levels of O2. We show that this behavior is best explained by a reaction mechanism in which O2 undergoes dissociative adsorption to the sulfide mineral surface. This mechanism helps to resolve major uncertainties regarding the reaction mechanism of O2 with pyrite and molybdenite mineral surfaces and provides a strong theoretical basis for the robust extrapolation of present results to higher and lower O2 concentrations.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)160-172
Number of pages13
JournalGeochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
Volume249
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 15 2019

Fingerprint

molybdenite
pyrite
Oxygen
oxidation
kinetics
Oxidation
oxygen
Kinetics
Sulfide minerals
sulfide
Archean
Sulfides
mineral
Weathering
Extrapolation
weathering
rate
sensor
early Earth
atmospheric gas

Keywords

  • Archean
  • Oxidation Kinetics
  • Oxidative Weathering
  • Pyrite, Molybdenite

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geochemistry and Petrology

Cite this

Johnson, A. C., Romaniello, S. J., Reinhard, C. T., Gregory, D. D., Garcia-Robledo, E., Revsbech, N. P., ... Anbar, A. (2019). Experimental determination of pyrite and molybdenite oxidation kinetics at nanomolar oxygen concentrations. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 249, 160-172. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gca.2019.01.022

Experimental determination of pyrite and molybdenite oxidation kinetics at nanomolar oxygen concentrations. / Johnson, Aleisha C.; Romaniello, Stephen J.; Reinhard, Christopher T.; Gregory, Daniel D.; Garcia-Robledo, Emilio; Revsbech, Niels Peter; Canfield, Donald E.; Lyons, Timothy W.; Anbar, Ariel.

In: Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, Vol. 249, 15.03.2019, p. 160-172.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Johnson, AC, Romaniello, SJ, Reinhard, CT, Gregory, DD, Garcia-Robledo, E, Revsbech, NP, Canfield, DE, Lyons, TW & Anbar, A 2019, 'Experimental determination of pyrite and molybdenite oxidation kinetics at nanomolar oxygen concentrations', Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, vol. 249, pp. 160-172. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gca.2019.01.022
Johnson, Aleisha C. ; Romaniello, Stephen J. ; Reinhard, Christopher T. ; Gregory, Daniel D. ; Garcia-Robledo, Emilio ; Revsbech, Niels Peter ; Canfield, Donald E. ; Lyons, Timothy W. ; Anbar, Ariel. / Experimental determination of pyrite and molybdenite oxidation kinetics at nanomolar oxygen concentrations. In: Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta. 2019 ; Vol. 249. pp. 160-172.
@article{886afa3501cf4a3d82a897f4b7aae315,
title = "Experimental determination of pyrite and molybdenite oxidation kinetics at nanomolar oxygen concentrations",
abstract = "Constraining the rate at which sulfide minerals undergo oxidative weathering at low atmospheric O2 is crucial for understanding the evolution of the Archean and Proterozoic biosphere when O2 was a trace atmospheric gas. However, recent studies attempting to constrain sulfide oxidation rates, atmospheric O2 sinks, and trace metal delivery to seawater under Archean conditions are limited by the need to extrapolate from experimental pyrite oxidation kinetics determined at much higher O2 levels. Extrapolation of those data sets to Archean levels of O2 (<10−5 present atmospheric level or PAL prior to 2.4 Ga) leads to more than an order of magnitude uncertainty in sulfide mineral oxidation rates, hampering efforts to quantify oxidative weathering under early Earth conditions. To quantify sulfide oxidation kinetics at low pO2, we conducted aqueous pyrite and molybdenite oxidation experiments at ∼2–1200 nM dissolved O2 and pH values 1.83, 5.08, and 8.58. Our experimental approach used LUMOS O2 sensors to extend the pO2 range explored by oxidation experiments down to 10−5 PAL pO2, the limit of the sensors, which is up to three orders of magnitude lower than the pO2 range explored in previous work. From these experiments, we use 28 independent rate measurements to derive a new rate law for the oxidation of pyrite as a function of pO2: rpyrite=10-8.83(±0.27)O2 0.50±0.04H+ -0.25±0.02, Where rpyrite is the rate of oxidation in mol/m2 sec, and the activities of dissolved [O2] and [H+] are in (mol/L). Our results most closely match the previous rate law presented by Williamson and Rimstidt (1994), but indicate a stronger pH dependence than previous studies. We also present the first kinetic rate law for molybdenite oxidation at low O2, based on 13 independent rate measurements: rmolybdenite=10-8.3(±2.3)O2 0.5±0.3, Where rmolybdenite is the rate of oxidation in mol/m2 sec, and the activity of dissolved [O2] is in (mol/L). We find molybdenite oxidation to be nearly as rapid as pyrite oxidation even at low concentrations of dissolved O2 (equivalent to <10−5 PAL pO2), in contrast to previous work which argued for a threshold effect for molybdenite oxidation. Both pyrite and molybdenite oxidation kinetics exhibit a constant half-order dependence on dissolved O2 down to nanomolar levels of O2. We show that this behavior is best explained by a reaction mechanism in which O2 undergoes dissociative adsorption to the sulfide mineral surface. This mechanism helps to resolve major uncertainties regarding the reaction mechanism of O2 with pyrite and molybdenite mineral surfaces and provides a strong theoretical basis for the robust extrapolation of present results to higher and lower O2 concentrations.",
keywords = "Archean, Oxidation Kinetics, Oxidative Weathering, Pyrite, Molybdenite",
author = "Johnson, {Aleisha C.} and Romaniello, {Stephen J.} and Reinhard, {Christopher T.} and Gregory, {Daniel D.} and Emilio Garcia-Robledo and Revsbech, {Niels Peter} and Canfield, {Donald E.} and Lyons, {Timothy W.} and Ariel Anbar",
year = "2019",
month = "3",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1016/j.gca.2019.01.022",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "249",
pages = "160--172",
journal = "Geochmica et Cosmochimica Acta",
issn = "0016-7037",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Experimental determination of pyrite and molybdenite oxidation kinetics at nanomolar oxygen concentrations

AU - Johnson, Aleisha C.

AU - Romaniello, Stephen J.

AU - Reinhard, Christopher T.

AU - Gregory, Daniel D.

AU - Garcia-Robledo, Emilio

AU - Revsbech, Niels Peter

AU - Canfield, Donald E.

AU - Lyons, Timothy W.

AU - Anbar, Ariel

PY - 2019/3/15

Y1 - 2019/3/15

N2 - Constraining the rate at which sulfide minerals undergo oxidative weathering at low atmospheric O2 is crucial for understanding the evolution of the Archean and Proterozoic biosphere when O2 was a trace atmospheric gas. However, recent studies attempting to constrain sulfide oxidation rates, atmospheric O2 sinks, and trace metal delivery to seawater under Archean conditions are limited by the need to extrapolate from experimental pyrite oxidation kinetics determined at much higher O2 levels. Extrapolation of those data sets to Archean levels of O2 (<10−5 present atmospheric level or PAL prior to 2.4 Ga) leads to more than an order of magnitude uncertainty in sulfide mineral oxidation rates, hampering efforts to quantify oxidative weathering under early Earth conditions. To quantify sulfide oxidation kinetics at low pO2, we conducted aqueous pyrite and molybdenite oxidation experiments at ∼2–1200 nM dissolved O2 and pH values 1.83, 5.08, and 8.58. Our experimental approach used LUMOS O2 sensors to extend the pO2 range explored by oxidation experiments down to 10−5 PAL pO2, the limit of the sensors, which is up to three orders of magnitude lower than the pO2 range explored in previous work. From these experiments, we use 28 independent rate measurements to derive a new rate law for the oxidation of pyrite as a function of pO2: rpyrite=10-8.83(±0.27)O2 0.50±0.04H+ -0.25±0.02, Where rpyrite is the rate of oxidation in mol/m2 sec, and the activities of dissolved [O2] and [H+] are in (mol/L). Our results most closely match the previous rate law presented by Williamson and Rimstidt (1994), but indicate a stronger pH dependence than previous studies. We also present the first kinetic rate law for molybdenite oxidation at low O2, based on 13 independent rate measurements: rmolybdenite=10-8.3(±2.3)O2 0.5±0.3, Where rmolybdenite is the rate of oxidation in mol/m2 sec, and the activity of dissolved [O2] is in (mol/L). We find molybdenite oxidation to be nearly as rapid as pyrite oxidation even at low concentrations of dissolved O2 (equivalent to <10−5 PAL pO2), in contrast to previous work which argued for a threshold effect for molybdenite oxidation. Both pyrite and molybdenite oxidation kinetics exhibit a constant half-order dependence on dissolved O2 down to nanomolar levels of O2. We show that this behavior is best explained by a reaction mechanism in which O2 undergoes dissociative adsorption to the sulfide mineral surface. This mechanism helps to resolve major uncertainties regarding the reaction mechanism of O2 with pyrite and molybdenite mineral surfaces and provides a strong theoretical basis for the robust extrapolation of present results to higher and lower O2 concentrations.

AB - Constraining the rate at which sulfide minerals undergo oxidative weathering at low atmospheric O2 is crucial for understanding the evolution of the Archean and Proterozoic biosphere when O2 was a trace atmospheric gas. However, recent studies attempting to constrain sulfide oxidation rates, atmospheric O2 sinks, and trace metal delivery to seawater under Archean conditions are limited by the need to extrapolate from experimental pyrite oxidation kinetics determined at much higher O2 levels. Extrapolation of those data sets to Archean levels of O2 (<10−5 present atmospheric level or PAL prior to 2.4 Ga) leads to more than an order of magnitude uncertainty in sulfide mineral oxidation rates, hampering efforts to quantify oxidative weathering under early Earth conditions. To quantify sulfide oxidation kinetics at low pO2, we conducted aqueous pyrite and molybdenite oxidation experiments at ∼2–1200 nM dissolved O2 and pH values 1.83, 5.08, and 8.58. Our experimental approach used LUMOS O2 sensors to extend the pO2 range explored by oxidation experiments down to 10−5 PAL pO2, the limit of the sensors, which is up to three orders of magnitude lower than the pO2 range explored in previous work. From these experiments, we use 28 independent rate measurements to derive a new rate law for the oxidation of pyrite as a function of pO2: rpyrite=10-8.83(±0.27)O2 0.50±0.04H+ -0.25±0.02, Where rpyrite is the rate of oxidation in mol/m2 sec, and the activities of dissolved [O2] and [H+] are in (mol/L). Our results most closely match the previous rate law presented by Williamson and Rimstidt (1994), but indicate a stronger pH dependence than previous studies. We also present the first kinetic rate law for molybdenite oxidation at low O2, based on 13 independent rate measurements: rmolybdenite=10-8.3(±2.3)O2 0.5±0.3, Where rmolybdenite is the rate of oxidation in mol/m2 sec, and the activity of dissolved [O2] is in (mol/L). We find molybdenite oxidation to be nearly as rapid as pyrite oxidation even at low concentrations of dissolved O2 (equivalent to <10−5 PAL pO2), in contrast to previous work which argued for a threshold effect for molybdenite oxidation. Both pyrite and molybdenite oxidation kinetics exhibit a constant half-order dependence on dissolved O2 down to nanomolar levels of O2. We show that this behavior is best explained by a reaction mechanism in which O2 undergoes dissociative adsorption to the sulfide mineral surface. This mechanism helps to resolve major uncertainties regarding the reaction mechanism of O2 with pyrite and molybdenite mineral surfaces and provides a strong theoretical basis for the robust extrapolation of present results to higher and lower O2 concentrations.

KW - Archean

KW - Oxidation Kinetics

KW - Oxidative Weathering

KW - Pyrite, Molybdenite

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85061150479&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85061150479&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.gca.2019.01.022

DO - 10.1016/j.gca.2019.01.022

M3 - Article

VL - 249

SP - 160

EP - 172

JO - Geochmica et Cosmochimica Acta

JF - Geochmica et Cosmochimica Acta

SN - 0016-7037

ER -