Expectations of similarity and cultural difference in conceptual models of illness

A comparison of medical staff and Mexican migrants

Jonathan Maupin, Norbert Ross

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Cultural competency has increasingly become a central concept in medical education and practice, focusing on recognizing the variation in patients' health-related beliefs and practices in order to improve cross-cultural communication and health outcomes. While numerous anthropologists critique cultural competency concepts, approaches, and instruments, there is little research regarding the central question of how biomedical providers perceive the health-related beliefs and practices of patients from different cultural backgrounds, how these perceptions compare with patients' own stated beliefs, and how they vary from providers' own concepts of health and illness. Yet, perceptions of difference in conceptual models of health and illness may influence cross-cultural clinical encounters more than measurable variation as they may obscure existing differences while exaggerating others based on notions of cultural difference. We examine these issues by analyzing patterns of variation between Mexican migrants and medical staff in Nashville, Tennessee. Moving beyond comparisons of measurable variation between the two, we explore medical staff's perceptions of migrants' beliefs. While we find significant variation between the two, medical staff do not recognize these differences. While perceiving that migrants hold a similar medial model to their own, medical staff overemphasize the "folky-ness" of folk illnesses which derives from expectations of cultural differences.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)306-316
Number of pages11
JournalHuman Organization
Volume71
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 1 2012

Fingerprint

cultural difference
illness
migrant
staff
health
Cultural Differences
Conceptual Model
Illness
Migrants
Health
Staff
communication
education
Competency

Keywords

  • conceptual models of illness
  • cross-cultural health care
  • cultural competency
  • cultural consensus
  • intercultural variation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Anthropology
  • Social Sciences(all)
  • Arts and Humanities (miscellaneous)

Cite this

Expectations of similarity and cultural difference in conceptual models of illness : A comparison of medical staff and Mexican migrants. / Maupin, Jonathan; Ross, Norbert.

In: Human Organization, Vol. 71, No. 3, 01.09.2012, p. 306-316.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{80c7d26e524a46eba14aa00c20658bbc,
title = "Expectations of similarity and cultural difference in conceptual models of illness: A comparison of medical staff and Mexican migrants",
abstract = "Cultural competency has increasingly become a central concept in medical education and practice, focusing on recognizing the variation in patients' health-related beliefs and practices in order to improve cross-cultural communication and health outcomes. While numerous anthropologists critique cultural competency concepts, approaches, and instruments, there is little research regarding the central question of how biomedical providers perceive the health-related beliefs and practices of patients from different cultural backgrounds, how these perceptions compare with patients' own stated beliefs, and how they vary from providers' own concepts of health and illness. Yet, perceptions of difference in conceptual models of health and illness may influence cross-cultural clinical encounters more than measurable variation as they may obscure existing differences while exaggerating others based on notions of cultural difference. We examine these issues by analyzing patterns of variation between Mexican migrants and medical staff in Nashville, Tennessee. Moving beyond comparisons of measurable variation between the two, we explore medical staff's perceptions of migrants' beliefs. While we find significant variation between the two, medical staff do not recognize these differences. While perceiving that migrants hold a similar medial model to their own, medical staff overemphasize the {"}folky-ness{"} of folk illnesses which derives from expectations of cultural differences.",
keywords = "conceptual models of illness, cross-cultural health care, cultural competency, cultural consensus, intercultural variation",
author = "Jonathan Maupin and Norbert Ross",
year = "2012",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "417344J4U5682210",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "71",
pages = "306--316",
journal = "Human Organization",
issn = "0018-7259",
publisher = "Society for Applied Anthropology",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Expectations of similarity and cultural difference in conceptual models of illness

T2 - A comparison of medical staff and Mexican migrants

AU - Maupin, Jonathan

AU - Ross, Norbert

PY - 2012/9/1

Y1 - 2012/9/1

N2 - Cultural competency has increasingly become a central concept in medical education and practice, focusing on recognizing the variation in patients' health-related beliefs and practices in order to improve cross-cultural communication and health outcomes. While numerous anthropologists critique cultural competency concepts, approaches, and instruments, there is little research regarding the central question of how biomedical providers perceive the health-related beliefs and practices of patients from different cultural backgrounds, how these perceptions compare with patients' own stated beliefs, and how they vary from providers' own concepts of health and illness. Yet, perceptions of difference in conceptual models of health and illness may influence cross-cultural clinical encounters more than measurable variation as they may obscure existing differences while exaggerating others based on notions of cultural difference. We examine these issues by analyzing patterns of variation between Mexican migrants and medical staff in Nashville, Tennessee. Moving beyond comparisons of measurable variation between the two, we explore medical staff's perceptions of migrants' beliefs. While we find significant variation between the two, medical staff do not recognize these differences. While perceiving that migrants hold a similar medial model to their own, medical staff overemphasize the "folky-ness" of folk illnesses which derives from expectations of cultural differences.

AB - Cultural competency has increasingly become a central concept in medical education and practice, focusing on recognizing the variation in patients' health-related beliefs and practices in order to improve cross-cultural communication and health outcomes. While numerous anthropologists critique cultural competency concepts, approaches, and instruments, there is little research regarding the central question of how biomedical providers perceive the health-related beliefs and practices of patients from different cultural backgrounds, how these perceptions compare with patients' own stated beliefs, and how they vary from providers' own concepts of health and illness. Yet, perceptions of difference in conceptual models of health and illness may influence cross-cultural clinical encounters more than measurable variation as they may obscure existing differences while exaggerating others based on notions of cultural difference. We examine these issues by analyzing patterns of variation between Mexican migrants and medical staff in Nashville, Tennessee. Moving beyond comparisons of measurable variation between the two, we explore medical staff's perceptions of migrants' beliefs. While we find significant variation between the two, medical staff do not recognize these differences. While perceiving that migrants hold a similar medial model to their own, medical staff overemphasize the "folky-ness" of folk illnesses which derives from expectations of cultural differences.

KW - conceptual models of illness

KW - cross-cultural health care

KW - cultural competency

KW - cultural consensus

KW - intercultural variation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84867386089&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84867386089&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 417344J4U5682210

DO - 417344J4U5682210

M3 - Article

VL - 71

SP - 306

EP - 316

JO - Human Organization

JF - Human Organization

SN - 0018-7259

IS - 3

ER -