Estimating two-dimensional static stabilities and geomorphic settings of precariously balanced rocks from unconstrained digital photographs

David E. Haddad, Olaf Zielke, Ramon Arrowsmith, Matthew D. Purvance, Amanda G. Haddad, Angela Landgraf

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The need to accurately document the spatiotemporal distribution of earthquakegenerated strong ground motions is essential for evaluating the seismic vulnerability of sites of critical infrastructure. Understanding the threshold for maximum earthquakeinduced ground motions at such sites provides valuable information to seismologists, earthquake engineers, local agencies, and policymakers when determining ground motion hazards of seismically sensitive infrastructures. In this context, fragile geologic features such as precariously balanced rocks (PBRs) serve as negative evidence for earthquake-induced ground motions and provide important physical constraints on the upper limits of ground motions. The three-dimensional (3D) shape of a PBR is a critical factor in determining its static stability and thus susceptibility to toppling during strong ground shaking events. Furthermore, the geomorphic settings of PBRs provide important controls on PBR exhumation histories that are interpreted from surface exposure dating methods. In this paper, we present PBRslenderness, a MATLAB-based program that evaluates the two-dimensional (2D) static stabilities of PBRs from unconstrained digital photographs. The program's graphical user interface allows users to interactively digitize a PBR and calculates the 2D geometric parameters that defi ne its static stability. A reproducibility study showed that our 2D calculations compare well against their counterparts that were computed in 3D (R2=0.77-0.98 for 22 samples). A sensitivity study for single-user and multiuser digitization routines further confi rmed the reproducibility of PBRslenderness estimates (coeffi cients of variation cv=4.3%-6.5% for 100 runs; R2=0.87-0.99 for 20 PBRs). We used PBRslenderness to analyze 261 PBRs in a low-seismicity setting to investigate the local geomorphic controls on PBR stability and preservation. PBRslenderness showed that a PBR's shape strongly controls its static stability and that there is no relationship between a PBR's stability and its geomorphic location in a drainage basin. However, the geomorphic settings of PBRs control their preservation potential by restricting their formation to hillslope gradients <40o and the upper reaches of drainage basins. Such examples of our program's utility have led to its use in archival efforts of PBRs in southern California and Nevada, USA.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1042-1053
Number of pages12
JournalGeosphere
Volume8
Issue number5
DOIs
StatePublished - 2012

Fingerprint

photograph
rock
ground motion
drainage basin
infrastructure
toppling
earthquake
digitization
dating method
hillslope
exhumation
seismicity
vulnerability
hazard
history

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geology
  • Stratigraphy

Cite this

Estimating two-dimensional static stabilities and geomorphic settings of precariously balanced rocks from unconstrained digital photographs. / Haddad, David E.; Zielke, Olaf; Arrowsmith, Ramon; Purvance, Matthew D.; Haddad, Amanda G.; Landgraf, Angela.

In: Geosphere, Vol. 8, No. 5, 2012, p. 1042-1053.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Haddad, David E. ; Zielke, Olaf ; Arrowsmith, Ramon ; Purvance, Matthew D. ; Haddad, Amanda G. ; Landgraf, Angela. / Estimating two-dimensional static stabilities and geomorphic settings of precariously balanced rocks from unconstrained digital photographs. In: Geosphere. 2012 ; Vol. 8, No. 5. pp. 1042-1053.
@article{cff21cd2c0554d27839aa133c7732fba,
title = "Estimating two-dimensional static stabilities and geomorphic settings of precariously balanced rocks from unconstrained digital photographs",
abstract = "The need to accurately document the spatiotemporal distribution of earthquakegenerated strong ground motions is essential for evaluating the seismic vulnerability of sites of critical infrastructure. Understanding the threshold for maximum earthquakeinduced ground motions at such sites provides valuable information to seismologists, earthquake engineers, local agencies, and policymakers when determining ground motion hazards of seismically sensitive infrastructures. In this context, fragile geologic features such as precariously balanced rocks (PBRs) serve as negative evidence for earthquake-induced ground motions and provide important physical constraints on the upper limits of ground motions. The three-dimensional (3D) shape of a PBR is a critical factor in determining its static stability and thus susceptibility to toppling during strong ground shaking events. Furthermore, the geomorphic settings of PBRs provide important controls on PBR exhumation histories that are interpreted from surface exposure dating methods. In this paper, we present PBRslenderness, a MATLAB-based program that evaluates the two-dimensional (2D) static stabilities of PBRs from unconstrained digital photographs. The program's graphical user interface allows users to interactively digitize a PBR and calculates the 2D geometric parameters that defi ne its static stability. A reproducibility study showed that our 2D calculations compare well against their counterparts that were computed in 3D (R2=0.77-0.98 for 22 samples). A sensitivity study for single-user and multiuser digitization routines further confi rmed the reproducibility of PBRslenderness estimates (coeffi cients of variation cv=4.3{\%}-6.5{\%} for 100 runs; R2=0.87-0.99 for 20 PBRs). We used PBRslenderness to analyze 261 PBRs in a low-seismicity setting to investigate the local geomorphic controls on PBR stability and preservation. PBRslenderness showed that a PBR's shape strongly controls its static stability and that there is no relationship between a PBR's stability and its geomorphic location in a drainage basin. However, the geomorphic settings of PBRs control their preservation potential by restricting their formation to hillslope gradients <40o and the upper reaches of drainage basins. Such examples of our program's utility have led to its use in archival efforts of PBRs in southern California and Nevada, USA.",
author = "Haddad, {David E.} and Olaf Zielke and Ramon Arrowsmith and Purvance, {Matthew D.} and Haddad, {Amanda G.} and Angela Landgraf",
year = "2012",
doi = "10.1130/GES00788.1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "8",
pages = "1042--1053",
journal = "Geosphere",
issn = "1553-040X",
publisher = "Geological Society of America",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Estimating two-dimensional static stabilities and geomorphic settings of precariously balanced rocks from unconstrained digital photographs

AU - Haddad, David E.

AU - Zielke, Olaf

AU - Arrowsmith, Ramon

AU - Purvance, Matthew D.

AU - Haddad, Amanda G.

AU - Landgraf, Angela

PY - 2012

Y1 - 2012

N2 - The need to accurately document the spatiotemporal distribution of earthquakegenerated strong ground motions is essential for evaluating the seismic vulnerability of sites of critical infrastructure. Understanding the threshold for maximum earthquakeinduced ground motions at such sites provides valuable information to seismologists, earthquake engineers, local agencies, and policymakers when determining ground motion hazards of seismically sensitive infrastructures. In this context, fragile geologic features such as precariously balanced rocks (PBRs) serve as negative evidence for earthquake-induced ground motions and provide important physical constraints on the upper limits of ground motions. The three-dimensional (3D) shape of a PBR is a critical factor in determining its static stability and thus susceptibility to toppling during strong ground shaking events. Furthermore, the geomorphic settings of PBRs provide important controls on PBR exhumation histories that are interpreted from surface exposure dating methods. In this paper, we present PBRslenderness, a MATLAB-based program that evaluates the two-dimensional (2D) static stabilities of PBRs from unconstrained digital photographs. The program's graphical user interface allows users to interactively digitize a PBR and calculates the 2D geometric parameters that defi ne its static stability. A reproducibility study showed that our 2D calculations compare well against their counterparts that were computed in 3D (R2=0.77-0.98 for 22 samples). A sensitivity study for single-user and multiuser digitization routines further confi rmed the reproducibility of PBRslenderness estimates (coeffi cients of variation cv=4.3%-6.5% for 100 runs; R2=0.87-0.99 for 20 PBRs). We used PBRslenderness to analyze 261 PBRs in a low-seismicity setting to investigate the local geomorphic controls on PBR stability and preservation. PBRslenderness showed that a PBR's shape strongly controls its static stability and that there is no relationship between a PBR's stability and its geomorphic location in a drainage basin. However, the geomorphic settings of PBRs control their preservation potential by restricting their formation to hillslope gradients <40o and the upper reaches of drainage basins. Such examples of our program's utility have led to its use in archival efforts of PBRs in southern California and Nevada, USA.

AB - The need to accurately document the spatiotemporal distribution of earthquakegenerated strong ground motions is essential for evaluating the seismic vulnerability of sites of critical infrastructure. Understanding the threshold for maximum earthquakeinduced ground motions at such sites provides valuable information to seismologists, earthquake engineers, local agencies, and policymakers when determining ground motion hazards of seismically sensitive infrastructures. In this context, fragile geologic features such as precariously balanced rocks (PBRs) serve as negative evidence for earthquake-induced ground motions and provide important physical constraints on the upper limits of ground motions. The three-dimensional (3D) shape of a PBR is a critical factor in determining its static stability and thus susceptibility to toppling during strong ground shaking events. Furthermore, the geomorphic settings of PBRs provide important controls on PBR exhumation histories that are interpreted from surface exposure dating methods. In this paper, we present PBRslenderness, a MATLAB-based program that evaluates the two-dimensional (2D) static stabilities of PBRs from unconstrained digital photographs. The program's graphical user interface allows users to interactively digitize a PBR and calculates the 2D geometric parameters that defi ne its static stability. A reproducibility study showed that our 2D calculations compare well against their counterparts that were computed in 3D (R2=0.77-0.98 for 22 samples). A sensitivity study for single-user and multiuser digitization routines further confi rmed the reproducibility of PBRslenderness estimates (coeffi cients of variation cv=4.3%-6.5% for 100 runs; R2=0.87-0.99 for 20 PBRs). We used PBRslenderness to analyze 261 PBRs in a low-seismicity setting to investigate the local geomorphic controls on PBR stability and preservation. PBRslenderness showed that a PBR's shape strongly controls its static stability and that there is no relationship between a PBR's stability and its geomorphic location in a drainage basin. However, the geomorphic settings of PBRs control their preservation potential by restricting their formation to hillslope gradients <40o and the upper reaches of drainage basins. Such examples of our program's utility have led to its use in archival efforts of PBRs in southern California and Nevada, USA.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84870352477&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84870352477&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1130/GES00788.1

DO - 10.1130/GES00788.1

M3 - Article

VL - 8

SP - 1042

EP - 1053

JO - Geosphere

JF - Geosphere

SN - 1553-040X

IS - 5

ER -