Error analysis of speed of sound reconstruction in ultrasound limited angle transmission tomography

Rungroj Jintamethasawat, Won Mean Lee, Paul L. Carson, Fong Ming Hooi, J. Brian Fowlkes, Mitchell M. Goodsitt, Richard Sampson, Thomas F. Wenisch, Siyuan Wei, Jian Zhou, Chaitali Chakrabarti, Oliver D. Kripfgans

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

We have investigated limited angle transmission tomography to estimate speed of sound (SOS) distributions for breast cancer detection. That requires both accurate delineations of major tissues, in this case by segmentation of prior B-mode images, and calibration of the relative positions of the opposed transducers. Experimental sensitivity evaluation of the reconstructions with respect to segmentation and calibration errors is difficult with our current system. Therefore, parametric studies of SOS errors in our bent-ray reconstructions were simulated. They included mis-segmentation of an object of interest or a nearby object, and miscalibration of relative transducer positions in 3D. Close correspondence of reconstruction accuracy was verified in the simplest case, a cylindrical object in homogeneous background with induced segmentation and calibration inaccuracies. Simulated mis-segmentation in object size and lateral location produced maximum SOS errors of 6.3% within 10 mm diameter change and 9.1% within 5 mm shift, respectively. Modest errors in assumed transducer separation produced the maximum SOS error from miscalibrations (57.3% within 5 mm shift), still, correction of this type of error can easily be achieved in the clinic. This study should aid in designing adequate transducer mounts and calibration procedures, and in specification of B-mode image quality and segmentation algorithms for limited angle transmission tomography relying on ray tracing algorithms.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)174-184
Number of pages11
JournalUltrasonics
Volume88
DOIs
StatePublished - Aug 1 2018

Fingerprint

error analysis
tomography
acoustics
transducers
delineation
shift
ray tracing
breast
specifications
rays
cancer
evaluation
estimates

Keywords

  • Breast ultrasound
  • Medical imaging
  • Medical transducers

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Acoustics and Ultrasonics

Cite this

Jintamethasawat, R., Lee, W. M., Carson, P. L., Hooi, F. M., Fowlkes, J. B., Goodsitt, M. M., ... Kripfgans, O. D. (2018). Error analysis of speed of sound reconstruction in ultrasound limited angle transmission tomography. Ultrasonics, 88, 174-184. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ultras.2018.03.016

Error analysis of speed of sound reconstruction in ultrasound limited angle transmission tomography. / Jintamethasawat, Rungroj; Lee, Won Mean; Carson, Paul L.; Hooi, Fong Ming; Fowlkes, J. Brian; Goodsitt, Mitchell M.; Sampson, Richard; Wenisch, Thomas F.; Wei, Siyuan; Zhou, Jian; Chakrabarti, Chaitali; Kripfgans, Oliver D.

In: Ultrasonics, Vol. 88, 01.08.2018, p. 174-184.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Jintamethasawat, R, Lee, WM, Carson, PL, Hooi, FM, Fowlkes, JB, Goodsitt, MM, Sampson, R, Wenisch, TF, Wei, S, Zhou, J, Chakrabarti, C & Kripfgans, OD 2018, 'Error analysis of speed of sound reconstruction in ultrasound limited angle transmission tomography', Ultrasonics, vol. 88, pp. 174-184. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ultras.2018.03.016
Jintamethasawat R, Lee WM, Carson PL, Hooi FM, Fowlkes JB, Goodsitt MM et al. Error analysis of speed of sound reconstruction in ultrasound limited angle transmission tomography. Ultrasonics. 2018 Aug 1;88:174-184. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ultras.2018.03.016
Jintamethasawat, Rungroj ; Lee, Won Mean ; Carson, Paul L. ; Hooi, Fong Ming ; Fowlkes, J. Brian ; Goodsitt, Mitchell M. ; Sampson, Richard ; Wenisch, Thomas F. ; Wei, Siyuan ; Zhou, Jian ; Chakrabarti, Chaitali ; Kripfgans, Oliver D. / Error analysis of speed of sound reconstruction in ultrasound limited angle transmission tomography. In: Ultrasonics. 2018 ; Vol. 88. pp. 174-184.
@article{333668d5934b4fcc97f589676c6952eb,
title = "Error analysis of speed of sound reconstruction in ultrasound limited angle transmission tomography",
abstract = "We have investigated limited angle transmission tomography to estimate speed of sound (SOS) distributions for breast cancer detection. That requires both accurate delineations of major tissues, in this case by segmentation of prior B-mode images, and calibration of the relative positions of the opposed transducers. Experimental sensitivity evaluation of the reconstructions with respect to segmentation and calibration errors is difficult with our current system. Therefore, parametric studies of SOS errors in our bent-ray reconstructions were simulated. They included mis-segmentation of an object of interest or a nearby object, and miscalibration of relative transducer positions in 3D. Close correspondence of reconstruction accuracy was verified in the simplest case, a cylindrical object in homogeneous background with induced segmentation and calibration inaccuracies. Simulated mis-segmentation in object size and lateral location produced maximum SOS errors of 6.3{\%} within 10 mm diameter change and 9.1{\%} within 5 mm shift, respectively. Modest errors in assumed transducer separation produced the maximum SOS error from miscalibrations (57.3{\%} within 5 mm shift), still, correction of this type of error can easily be achieved in the clinic. This study should aid in designing adequate transducer mounts and calibration procedures, and in specification of B-mode image quality and segmentation algorithms for limited angle transmission tomography relying on ray tracing algorithms.",
keywords = "Breast ultrasound, Medical imaging, Medical transducers",
author = "Rungroj Jintamethasawat and Lee, {Won Mean} and Carson, {Paul L.} and Hooi, {Fong Ming} and Fowlkes, {J. Brian} and Goodsitt, {Mitchell M.} and Richard Sampson and Wenisch, {Thomas F.} and Siyuan Wei and Jian Zhou and Chaitali Chakrabarti and Kripfgans, {Oliver D.}",
year = "2018",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.ultras.2018.03.016",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "88",
pages = "174--184",
journal = "Ultrasonics",
issn = "0041-624X",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Error analysis of speed of sound reconstruction in ultrasound limited angle transmission tomography

AU - Jintamethasawat, Rungroj

AU - Lee, Won Mean

AU - Carson, Paul L.

AU - Hooi, Fong Ming

AU - Fowlkes, J. Brian

AU - Goodsitt, Mitchell M.

AU - Sampson, Richard

AU - Wenisch, Thomas F.

AU - Wei, Siyuan

AU - Zhou, Jian

AU - Chakrabarti, Chaitali

AU - Kripfgans, Oliver D.

PY - 2018/8/1

Y1 - 2018/8/1

N2 - We have investigated limited angle transmission tomography to estimate speed of sound (SOS) distributions for breast cancer detection. That requires both accurate delineations of major tissues, in this case by segmentation of prior B-mode images, and calibration of the relative positions of the opposed transducers. Experimental sensitivity evaluation of the reconstructions with respect to segmentation and calibration errors is difficult with our current system. Therefore, parametric studies of SOS errors in our bent-ray reconstructions were simulated. They included mis-segmentation of an object of interest or a nearby object, and miscalibration of relative transducer positions in 3D. Close correspondence of reconstruction accuracy was verified in the simplest case, a cylindrical object in homogeneous background with induced segmentation and calibration inaccuracies. Simulated mis-segmentation in object size and lateral location produced maximum SOS errors of 6.3% within 10 mm diameter change and 9.1% within 5 mm shift, respectively. Modest errors in assumed transducer separation produced the maximum SOS error from miscalibrations (57.3% within 5 mm shift), still, correction of this type of error can easily be achieved in the clinic. This study should aid in designing adequate transducer mounts and calibration procedures, and in specification of B-mode image quality and segmentation algorithms for limited angle transmission tomography relying on ray tracing algorithms.

AB - We have investigated limited angle transmission tomography to estimate speed of sound (SOS) distributions for breast cancer detection. That requires both accurate delineations of major tissues, in this case by segmentation of prior B-mode images, and calibration of the relative positions of the opposed transducers. Experimental sensitivity evaluation of the reconstructions with respect to segmentation and calibration errors is difficult with our current system. Therefore, parametric studies of SOS errors in our bent-ray reconstructions were simulated. They included mis-segmentation of an object of interest or a nearby object, and miscalibration of relative transducer positions in 3D. Close correspondence of reconstruction accuracy was verified in the simplest case, a cylindrical object in homogeneous background with induced segmentation and calibration inaccuracies. Simulated mis-segmentation in object size and lateral location produced maximum SOS errors of 6.3% within 10 mm diameter change and 9.1% within 5 mm shift, respectively. Modest errors in assumed transducer separation produced the maximum SOS error from miscalibrations (57.3% within 5 mm shift), still, correction of this type of error can easily be achieved in the clinic. This study should aid in designing adequate transducer mounts and calibration procedures, and in specification of B-mode image quality and segmentation algorithms for limited angle transmission tomography relying on ray tracing algorithms.

KW - Breast ultrasound

KW - Medical imaging

KW - Medical transducers

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85045429587&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85045429587&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.ultras.2018.03.016

DO - 10.1016/j.ultras.2018.03.016

M3 - Article

C2 - 29674228

AN - SCOPUS:85045429587

VL - 88

SP - 174

EP - 184

JO - Ultrasonics

JF - Ultrasonics

SN - 0041-624X

ER -