Eliminating the gap between the high and low students through meta-cognitive strategy instruction

One important goal of Intelligent Tutoring Systems (ITSs) is to bring students up to the same level of mastery. We showed that an ITS teaching a domain-independent problem-solving strategy indeed closed the gap between High and Low learners, not only in the domain where it was taught (probability) but also in a second domain where it was not taught (physics). The strategy includes two main components: one is solving problems via Backward-Chaining (BC) from goals to givens, named the BC-strategy, and the other is drawing students' attention on the characteristics of each individual domain principle, named the principle-emphasis skill. Evidence suggests that the Low learners transferred the principle-emphasis skill to physics while the High learners seemingly already had such skill and thus mainly transferred the other skill, the BC-strategy. Surprisingly, the former learned just as effectively as the latter in physics. We concluded that the effective element of the taught strategy seemed not to be the BC-Strategy, but the principle-emphasis skill.