Defining biominerals and organominerals: Direct and indirect indicators of life

Randall S. Perry, Nicola Mcloughlin, Bridget Y. Lynne, Mark A. Sephton, Joan D. Oliver, Carole C. Perry, Kathleen Campbell, Michael H. Engel, Jack Farmer, Martin D. Brasier, James T. Staley

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

82 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

By introducing the new term 'organomineral' to apply to minerals that are affected by organics, mostly life-related, but not directly produced by living cells, we hope to increase the accuracy of the terminology in present usage. We believe that the term 'biomineral' does not describe all mineral deposits precisely enough and offer case studies to support instances where the use of the new term 'organomineral' is more appropriate. We provide examples of some materials that are biominerals such as those in diatoms and human bones and which perform a functional purpose. We then attempt to show that terminology can sometimes mislead investigators, drive the direction and prejudice interpretations of scientific investigation. This is achieved by presenting case studies of minerals that have been investigated as biominerals although they may not actually be directly controlled by biology. For this reason we pay special attention to desert varnish, hot-spring siliceous deposits, stromatolites, and bacterial encrustations. We go on to explain why we regard biominerals as direct indictors of life whereas organominerals should be treated as indirect indicators of life that require careful characterization to establish the origin of contained organics and whether these are biotic in origin. How organic compounds are preserved and transformed in sedimentary environments and in the mineral matrix is as highly relevant to the study of modern Earth environments as it is in the search for the oldest evidence of life in the terrestrial rock record. It is also important to many disciplines such as microbiology and archaeology and especially to scientists planning missions to look for evidence of 'life' on other planetary surfaces.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)157-179
Number of pages23
JournalSedimentary Geology
Volume201
Issue number1-2
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 1 2007

Fingerprint

terminology
mineral
siliceous deposit
encrustation
planetary surface
microbiology
mineral deposit
thermal spring
archaeology
bone
organic compound
diatom
desert
matrix
rock
indicator
planning
varnish
material

Keywords

  • Bacterial encrustations
  • Biominerals
  • Desert varnish
  • Hot-spring
  • Micro-fossils
  • Organominerals
  • Philosophy of science
  • Science definitions
  • Science language
  • Silica sinter
  • Stromatolites
  • Terminology

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geology
  • Stratigraphy

Cite this

Perry, R. S., Mcloughlin, N., Lynne, B. Y., Sephton, M. A., Oliver, J. D., Perry, C. C., ... Staley, J. T. (2007). Defining biominerals and organominerals: Direct and indirect indicators of life. Sedimentary Geology, 201(1-2), 157-179. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sedgeo.2007.05.014

Defining biominerals and organominerals : Direct and indirect indicators of life. / Perry, Randall S.; Mcloughlin, Nicola; Lynne, Bridget Y.; Sephton, Mark A.; Oliver, Joan D.; Perry, Carole C.; Campbell, Kathleen; Engel, Michael H.; Farmer, Jack; Brasier, Martin D.; Staley, James T.

In: Sedimentary Geology, Vol. 201, No. 1-2, 01.09.2007, p. 157-179.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Perry, RS, Mcloughlin, N, Lynne, BY, Sephton, MA, Oliver, JD, Perry, CC, Campbell, K, Engel, MH, Farmer, J, Brasier, MD & Staley, JT 2007, 'Defining biominerals and organominerals: Direct and indirect indicators of life', Sedimentary Geology, vol. 201, no. 1-2, pp. 157-179. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sedgeo.2007.05.014
Perry RS, Mcloughlin N, Lynne BY, Sephton MA, Oliver JD, Perry CC et al. Defining biominerals and organominerals: Direct and indirect indicators of life. Sedimentary Geology. 2007 Sep 1;201(1-2):157-179. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sedgeo.2007.05.014
Perry, Randall S. ; Mcloughlin, Nicola ; Lynne, Bridget Y. ; Sephton, Mark A. ; Oliver, Joan D. ; Perry, Carole C. ; Campbell, Kathleen ; Engel, Michael H. ; Farmer, Jack ; Brasier, Martin D. ; Staley, James T. / Defining biominerals and organominerals : Direct and indirect indicators of life. In: Sedimentary Geology. 2007 ; Vol. 201, No. 1-2. pp. 157-179.
@article{f40136f66f4242a2a0624d3de7aefa3a,
title = "Defining biominerals and organominerals: Direct and indirect indicators of life",
abstract = "By introducing the new term 'organomineral' to apply to minerals that are affected by organics, mostly life-related, but not directly produced by living cells, we hope to increase the accuracy of the terminology in present usage. We believe that the term 'biomineral' does not describe all mineral deposits precisely enough and offer case studies to support instances where the use of the new term 'organomineral' is more appropriate. We provide examples of some materials that are biominerals such as those in diatoms and human bones and which perform a functional purpose. We then attempt to show that terminology can sometimes mislead investigators, drive the direction and prejudice interpretations of scientific investigation. This is achieved by presenting case studies of minerals that have been investigated as biominerals although they may not actually be directly controlled by biology. For this reason we pay special attention to desert varnish, hot-spring siliceous deposits, stromatolites, and bacterial encrustations. We go on to explain why we regard biominerals as direct indictors of life whereas organominerals should be treated as indirect indicators of life that require careful characterization to establish the origin of contained organics and whether these are biotic in origin. How organic compounds are preserved and transformed in sedimentary environments and in the mineral matrix is as highly relevant to the study of modern Earth environments as it is in the search for the oldest evidence of life in the terrestrial rock record. It is also important to many disciplines such as microbiology and archaeology and especially to scientists planning missions to look for evidence of 'life' on other planetary surfaces.",
keywords = "Bacterial encrustations, Biominerals, Desert varnish, Hot-spring, Micro-fossils, Organominerals, Philosophy of science, Science definitions, Science language, Silica sinter, Stromatolites, Terminology",
author = "Perry, {Randall S.} and Nicola Mcloughlin and Lynne, {Bridget Y.} and Sephton, {Mark A.} and Oliver, {Joan D.} and Perry, {Carole C.} and Kathleen Campbell and Engel, {Michael H.} and Jack Farmer and Brasier, {Martin D.} and Staley, {James T.}",
year = "2007",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.sedgeo.2007.05.014",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "201",
pages = "157--179",
journal = "Sedimentary Geology",
issn = "0037-0738",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "1-2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Defining biominerals and organominerals

T2 - Direct and indirect indicators of life

AU - Perry, Randall S.

AU - Mcloughlin, Nicola

AU - Lynne, Bridget Y.

AU - Sephton, Mark A.

AU - Oliver, Joan D.

AU - Perry, Carole C.

AU - Campbell, Kathleen

AU - Engel, Michael H.

AU - Farmer, Jack

AU - Brasier, Martin D.

AU - Staley, James T.

PY - 2007/9/1

Y1 - 2007/9/1

N2 - By introducing the new term 'organomineral' to apply to minerals that are affected by organics, mostly life-related, but not directly produced by living cells, we hope to increase the accuracy of the terminology in present usage. We believe that the term 'biomineral' does not describe all mineral deposits precisely enough and offer case studies to support instances where the use of the new term 'organomineral' is more appropriate. We provide examples of some materials that are biominerals such as those in diatoms and human bones and which perform a functional purpose. We then attempt to show that terminology can sometimes mislead investigators, drive the direction and prejudice interpretations of scientific investigation. This is achieved by presenting case studies of minerals that have been investigated as biominerals although they may not actually be directly controlled by biology. For this reason we pay special attention to desert varnish, hot-spring siliceous deposits, stromatolites, and bacterial encrustations. We go on to explain why we regard biominerals as direct indictors of life whereas organominerals should be treated as indirect indicators of life that require careful characterization to establish the origin of contained organics and whether these are biotic in origin. How organic compounds are preserved and transformed in sedimentary environments and in the mineral matrix is as highly relevant to the study of modern Earth environments as it is in the search for the oldest evidence of life in the terrestrial rock record. It is also important to many disciplines such as microbiology and archaeology and especially to scientists planning missions to look for evidence of 'life' on other planetary surfaces.

AB - By introducing the new term 'organomineral' to apply to minerals that are affected by organics, mostly life-related, but not directly produced by living cells, we hope to increase the accuracy of the terminology in present usage. We believe that the term 'biomineral' does not describe all mineral deposits precisely enough and offer case studies to support instances where the use of the new term 'organomineral' is more appropriate. We provide examples of some materials that are biominerals such as those in diatoms and human bones and which perform a functional purpose. We then attempt to show that terminology can sometimes mislead investigators, drive the direction and prejudice interpretations of scientific investigation. This is achieved by presenting case studies of minerals that have been investigated as biominerals although they may not actually be directly controlled by biology. For this reason we pay special attention to desert varnish, hot-spring siliceous deposits, stromatolites, and bacterial encrustations. We go on to explain why we regard biominerals as direct indictors of life whereas organominerals should be treated as indirect indicators of life that require careful characterization to establish the origin of contained organics and whether these are biotic in origin. How organic compounds are preserved and transformed in sedimentary environments and in the mineral matrix is as highly relevant to the study of modern Earth environments as it is in the search for the oldest evidence of life in the terrestrial rock record. It is also important to many disciplines such as microbiology and archaeology and especially to scientists planning missions to look for evidence of 'life' on other planetary surfaces.

KW - Bacterial encrustations

KW - Biominerals

KW - Desert varnish

KW - Hot-spring

KW - Micro-fossils

KW - Organominerals

KW - Philosophy of science

KW - Science definitions

KW - Science language

KW - Silica sinter

KW - Stromatolites

KW - Terminology

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=34249821749&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=34249821749&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.sedgeo.2007.05.014

DO - 10.1016/j.sedgeo.2007.05.014

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:34249821749

VL - 201

SP - 157

EP - 179

JO - Sedimentary Geology

JF - Sedimentary Geology

SN - 0037-0738

IS - 1-2

ER -