Cross-cultural invariances in the architecture of shame

Daniel Sznycer, Dimitris Xygalatas, Elizabeth Agey, Sarah Alami, Xiao Fen An, Kristina I. Ananyeva, Quentin D. Atkinson, Bernardo R. Broitman, Thomas J. Conte, Carola Flores, Shintaro Fukushima, Hidefumi Hitokoto, Alexander N. Kharitonov, Charity N. Onyishi, Ike E. Onyishi, Pedro P. Romero, Joshua M. Schrock, J. Josh Snodgrass, Lawrence S. Sugiyama, Kosuke Takemura & 6 others Cathryn Townsend, Jin Ying Zhuang, C Athena Aktipis, Lee Cronk, Leda Cosmides, John Tooby

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

8 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Human foragers are obligately group-living, and their high dependence on mutual aid is believed to have characterized our species' social evolution. It was therefore a central adaptive problem for our ancestors to avoid damaging thewillingness of other groupmembers to render them assistance. Cognitively, this requires a predictive map of the degree to which others would devalue the individual based on each of various possible acts. With such a map, an individual can avoid socially costly behaviors by anticipating how much audience devaluation a potential action (e.g., stealing) would cause and weigh this against the action's direct payoff (e.g., acquiring). The shame system manifests all of the functional properties required to solve this adaptive problem, with the aversive intensity of shame encoding the social cost. Previous data from three Western(ized) societies indicated that the shame evoked when the individual anticipates committing various acts closely tracks the magnitude of devaluation expressed by audiences in response to those acts. Here we report data supporting the broader claim that shame is a basic part of human biology.We conducted an experiment among 899 participants in 15 small-scale communities scattered around the world. Despite widely varying languages, cultures, and subsistence modes, shame in each community closely tracked the devaluation of local audiences (mean r = +0.84). The fact that the same pattern is encountered in such mutually remote communities suggests that shame's match to audience devaluation is a design feature crafted by selection and not a product of cultural contact or convergent cultural evolution.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)9702-9707
Number of pages6
JournalProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
Volume115
Issue number39
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 25 2018

Fingerprint

Shame
Cultural Evolution
Theft
Action Potentials
Language
Costs and Cost Analysis

Keywords

  • Cognition
  • Cooperation
  • Culture
  • Emotion
  • Evolutionary psychology

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • General

Cite this

Sznycer, D., Xygalatas, D., Agey, E., Alami, S., An, X. F., Ananyeva, K. I., ... Tooby, J. (2018). Cross-cultural invariances in the architecture of shame. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 115(39), 9702-9707. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1805016115

Cross-cultural invariances in the architecture of shame. / Sznycer, Daniel; Xygalatas, Dimitris; Agey, Elizabeth; Alami, Sarah; An, Xiao Fen; Ananyeva, Kristina I.; Atkinson, Quentin D.; Broitman, Bernardo R.; Conte, Thomas J.; Flores, Carola; Fukushima, Shintaro; Hitokoto, Hidefumi; Kharitonov, Alexander N.; Onyishi, Charity N.; Onyishi, Ike E.; Romero, Pedro P.; Schrock, Joshua M.; Snodgrass, J. Josh; Sugiyama, Lawrence S.; Takemura, Kosuke; Townsend, Cathryn; Zhuang, Jin Ying; Aktipis, C Athena; Cronk, Lee; Cosmides, Leda; Tooby, John.

In: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, Vol. 115, No. 39, 25.09.2018, p. 9702-9707.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Sznycer, D, Xygalatas, D, Agey, E, Alami, S, An, XF, Ananyeva, KI, Atkinson, QD, Broitman, BR, Conte, TJ, Flores, C, Fukushima, S, Hitokoto, H, Kharitonov, AN, Onyishi, CN, Onyishi, IE, Romero, PP, Schrock, JM, Snodgrass, JJ, Sugiyama, LS, Takemura, K, Townsend, C, Zhuang, JY, Aktipis, CA, Cronk, L, Cosmides, L & Tooby, J 2018, 'Cross-cultural invariances in the architecture of shame', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, vol. 115, no. 39, pp. 9702-9707. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1805016115
Sznycer, Daniel ; Xygalatas, Dimitris ; Agey, Elizabeth ; Alami, Sarah ; An, Xiao Fen ; Ananyeva, Kristina I. ; Atkinson, Quentin D. ; Broitman, Bernardo R. ; Conte, Thomas J. ; Flores, Carola ; Fukushima, Shintaro ; Hitokoto, Hidefumi ; Kharitonov, Alexander N. ; Onyishi, Charity N. ; Onyishi, Ike E. ; Romero, Pedro P. ; Schrock, Joshua M. ; Snodgrass, J. Josh ; Sugiyama, Lawrence S. ; Takemura, Kosuke ; Townsend, Cathryn ; Zhuang, Jin Ying ; Aktipis, C Athena ; Cronk, Lee ; Cosmides, Leda ; Tooby, John. / Cross-cultural invariances in the architecture of shame. In: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 2018 ; Vol. 115, No. 39. pp. 9702-9707.
@article{e129429a81474e0798e9a9d16df8855b,
title = "Cross-cultural invariances in the architecture of shame",
abstract = "Human foragers are obligately group-living, and their high dependence on mutual aid is believed to have characterized our species' social evolution. It was therefore a central adaptive problem for our ancestors to avoid damaging thewillingness of other groupmembers to render them assistance. Cognitively, this requires a predictive map of the degree to which others would devalue the individual based on each of various possible acts. With such a map, an individual can avoid socially costly behaviors by anticipating how much audience devaluation a potential action (e.g., stealing) would cause and weigh this against the action's direct payoff (e.g., acquiring). The shame system manifests all of the functional properties required to solve this adaptive problem, with the aversive intensity of shame encoding the social cost. Previous data from three Western(ized) societies indicated that the shame evoked when the individual anticipates committing various acts closely tracks the magnitude of devaluation expressed by audiences in response to those acts. Here we report data supporting the broader claim that shame is a basic part of human biology.We conducted an experiment among 899 participants in 15 small-scale communities scattered around the world. Despite widely varying languages, cultures, and subsistence modes, shame in each community closely tracked the devaluation of local audiences (mean r = +0.84). The fact that the same pattern is encountered in such mutually remote communities suggests that shame's match to audience devaluation is a design feature crafted by selection and not a product of cultural contact or convergent cultural evolution.",
keywords = "Cognition, Cooperation, Culture, Emotion, Evolutionary psychology",
author = "Daniel Sznycer and Dimitris Xygalatas and Elizabeth Agey and Sarah Alami and An, {Xiao Fen} and Ananyeva, {Kristina I.} and Atkinson, {Quentin D.} and Broitman, {Bernardo R.} and Conte, {Thomas J.} and Carola Flores and Shintaro Fukushima and Hidefumi Hitokoto and Kharitonov, {Alexander N.} and Onyishi, {Charity N.} and Onyishi, {Ike E.} and Romero, {Pedro P.} and Schrock, {Joshua M.} and Snodgrass, {J. Josh} and Sugiyama, {Lawrence S.} and Kosuke Takemura and Cathryn Townsend and Zhuang, {Jin Ying} and Aktipis, {C Athena} and Lee Cronk and Leda Cosmides and John Tooby",
year = "2018",
month = "9",
day = "25",
doi = "10.1073/pnas.1805016115",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "115",
pages = "9702--9707",
journal = "Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America",
issn = "0027-8424",
number = "39",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Cross-cultural invariances in the architecture of shame

AU - Sznycer, Daniel

AU - Xygalatas, Dimitris

AU - Agey, Elizabeth

AU - Alami, Sarah

AU - An, Xiao Fen

AU - Ananyeva, Kristina I.

AU - Atkinson, Quentin D.

AU - Broitman, Bernardo R.

AU - Conte, Thomas J.

AU - Flores, Carola

AU - Fukushima, Shintaro

AU - Hitokoto, Hidefumi

AU - Kharitonov, Alexander N.

AU - Onyishi, Charity N.

AU - Onyishi, Ike E.

AU - Romero, Pedro P.

AU - Schrock, Joshua M.

AU - Snodgrass, J. Josh

AU - Sugiyama, Lawrence S.

AU - Takemura, Kosuke

AU - Townsend, Cathryn

AU - Zhuang, Jin Ying

AU - Aktipis, C Athena

AU - Cronk, Lee

AU - Cosmides, Leda

AU - Tooby, John

PY - 2018/9/25

Y1 - 2018/9/25

N2 - Human foragers are obligately group-living, and their high dependence on mutual aid is believed to have characterized our species' social evolution. It was therefore a central adaptive problem for our ancestors to avoid damaging thewillingness of other groupmembers to render them assistance. Cognitively, this requires a predictive map of the degree to which others would devalue the individual based on each of various possible acts. With such a map, an individual can avoid socially costly behaviors by anticipating how much audience devaluation a potential action (e.g., stealing) would cause and weigh this against the action's direct payoff (e.g., acquiring). The shame system manifests all of the functional properties required to solve this adaptive problem, with the aversive intensity of shame encoding the social cost. Previous data from three Western(ized) societies indicated that the shame evoked when the individual anticipates committing various acts closely tracks the magnitude of devaluation expressed by audiences in response to those acts. Here we report data supporting the broader claim that shame is a basic part of human biology.We conducted an experiment among 899 participants in 15 small-scale communities scattered around the world. Despite widely varying languages, cultures, and subsistence modes, shame in each community closely tracked the devaluation of local audiences (mean r = +0.84). The fact that the same pattern is encountered in such mutually remote communities suggests that shame's match to audience devaluation is a design feature crafted by selection and not a product of cultural contact or convergent cultural evolution.

AB - Human foragers are obligately group-living, and their high dependence on mutual aid is believed to have characterized our species' social evolution. It was therefore a central adaptive problem for our ancestors to avoid damaging thewillingness of other groupmembers to render them assistance. Cognitively, this requires a predictive map of the degree to which others would devalue the individual based on each of various possible acts. With such a map, an individual can avoid socially costly behaviors by anticipating how much audience devaluation a potential action (e.g., stealing) would cause and weigh this against the action's direct payoff (e.g., acquiring). The shame system manifests all of the functional properties required to solve this adaptive problem, with the aversive intensity of shame encoding the social cost. Previous data from three Western(ized) societies indicated that the shame evoked when the individual anticipates committing various acts closely tracks the magnitude of devaluation expressed by audiences in response to those acts. Here we report data supporting the broader claim that shame is a basic part of human biology.We conducted an experiment among 899 participants in 15 small-scale communities scattered around the world. Despite widely varying languages, cultures, and subsistence modes, shame in each community closely tracked the devaluation of local audiences (mean r = +0.84). The fact that the same pattern is encountered in such mutually remote communities suggests that shame's match to audience devaluation is a design feature crafted by selection and not a product of cultural contact or convergent cultural evolution.

KW - Cognition

KW - Cooperation

KW - Culture

KW - Emotion

KW - Evolutionary psychology

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85054015349&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85054015349&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1073/pnas.1805016115

DO - 10.1073/pnas.1805016115

M3 - Article

VL - 115

SP - 9702

EP - 9707

JO - Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America

JF - Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America

SN - 0027-8424

IS - 39

ER -