Co²⁺ as a chemical analogue for Fe²⁺ in high-temperature experiments in basaltic systems

High-temperature experiments on ferromagnesian compositions have been hampered by the rapid absorption of up to 95% of the original iron by platinum and 40% by silver-palladium capsules. Molybdenum or iron capsule materials can decrease or alleviate iron loss, but restrict oxygen fugacities to values near the iron-wustite buffer. Because Co²⁺ is stable at f{hook}_O2 = HM and because the solubility of Co in platinum in this range of f{hook}_O2 is ∼0.05% at temperatures to 1350°C, its use as an analogue for Fe²⁺ is possible. In addition, experiments simulating various Fe²⁺ ratios can be easily performed by choosing appropriate Co²⁺/Fe³⁺ ratios. The cobalt phases produced possess brilliant and distinctive colors which are valuable aids in optical identification of minute phases. The cobalt analogue hypothesis was tested with atmospheric pressure experiments in air on the cobalt analogue of the 1921 Kilauea basalt at three simulated Fe²⁺/Fe³⁺ ratios. The results were compared with those of R.E.T. Hill (1969) for the natural 1921 basalt. The phase relations were the same, with the cobalt system stability fields systematically shifted by about +50°C. Microprobe analysis of olivines and the coexisting glasses indicate that the distribution of Co²⁺ between olivine and melt is independent of temperature and liquid composition. Although the analogue liquid composition differs from the equilibrium composition of the natural system, it may be corrected be employing distribution coefficients (K_D = 0.61 for the Co system; K_D = 0.33 for the Fe system) to closely approximate what the natural system would yield if iron loss did not occur.