Colony and evolutionary dynamics of a two-stage model with brood cannibalism and division of labor in social insects

Marisabel Rodriguez-Rodriguez, Yun Kang

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Division of labor (DOL) is a major factor for the great success of social insects because it increases the efficiency of a social group where different individuals perform different tasks repeatedly and presumably with increased performance. Cannibalism plays an important role in regulating colony growth and development by regulating the number of individuals in a colony and increasing survival by providing access to essential nutrients and minimizing competition among colony mates. To understand the synergy effects of DOL and cannibalistic behavior on colony dynamic outcomes, we propose and study a compartmental two-stage model using ecological and evolutionary game theory settings. Our analytical results of the ecological and evolutionary models suggest that: (1) A noncannibalistic colony can survive if the efficiency of energy investment reflecting the DOL is greater than the relative death rate of the older population. (2) A cannibalistic colony can die out if both the efficiency of energy investment and the relative cannibalism rate (where each is also reflecting the DOL) are too large; or if the relative cannibalism rate alone is too small. (3) From our numerical analysis, cannibalism can increase or reduce the colony's total population size, which greatly depends on the benefit of egg cannibalism increasing or decreasing of adult's lifespan. (4) A cannibalistic and noncannibalistic colony can experience bistability due to cooperative behavior. (5) In the evolutionary settings, DOL can prevent colony death and natural selection can preserve strong Allee effects by selecting the traits with the largest investment on brood care and the lowest cannibalism rate. (6) Evolutionary dynamics may increase the fitness of the colony, i.e., the successful production of workforce which results in the increase of total worker population size, colony survival, and reproduction. Our results suggest both cannibalism and DOLs are adaptive strategies that increase the size of the worker population, and therefore, persistence of the colony.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)633-662
Number of pages30
JournalNatural Resource Modeling
Volume29
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 1 2016

Fingerprint

Social Insects
Two-stage Model
Evolutionary Dynamics
social insect
cannibalism
labor division
Division
Personnel
Population Size
Allee Effect
Evolutionary Game Theory
Compartmental Model
Cooperative Behavior
Adaptive Strategies
Natural Selection
Bistability
Life Span
Game theory
Synergy
Energy

Keywords

  • brood care
  • colony dynamics
  • Division of labor
  • egg cannibalism
  • evolutionary dynamics
  • stage-structure model

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Modeling and Simulation
  • Environmental Science (miscellaneous)

Cite this

Colony and evolutionary dynamics of a two-stage model with brood cannibalism and division of labor in social insects. / Rodriguez-Rodriguez, Marisabel; Kang, Yun.

In: Natural Resource Modeling, Vol. 29, No. 4, 01.11.2016, p. 633-662.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{a79dd756fb5f44b687e3ec72b030383e,
title = "Colony and evolutionary dynamics of a two-stage model with brood cannibalism and division of labor in social insects",
abstract = "Division of labor (DOL) is a major factor for the great success of social insects because it increases the efficiency of a social group where different individuals perform different tasks repeatedly and presumably with increased performance. Cannibalism plays an important role in regulating colony growth and development by regulating the number of individuals in a colony and increasing survival by providing access to essential nutrients and minimizing competition among colony mates. To understand the synergy effects of DOL and cannibalistic behavior on colony dynamic outcomes, we propose and study a compartmental two-stage model using ecological and evolutionary game theory settings. Our analytical results of the ecological and evolutionary models suggest that: (1) A noncannibalistic colony can survive if the efficiency of energy investment reflecting the DOL is greater than the relative death rate of the older population. (2) A cannibalistic colony can die out if both the efficiency of energy investment and the relative cannibalism rate (where each is also reflecting the DOL) are too large; or if the relative cannibalism rate alone is too small. (3) From our numerical analysis, cannibalism can increase or reduce the colony's total population size, which greatly depends on the benefit of egg cannibalism increasing or decreasing of adult's lifespan. (4) A cannibalistic and noncannibalistic colony can experience bistability due to cooperative behavior. (5) In the evolutionary settings, DOL can prevent colony death and natural selection can preserve strong Allee effects by selecting the traits with the largest investment on brood care and the lowest cannibalism rate. (6) Evolutionary dynamics may increase the fitness of the colony, i.e., the successful production of workforce which results in the increase of total worker population size, colony survival, and reproduction. Our results suggest both cannibalism and DOLs are adaptive strategies that increase the size of the worker population, and therefore, persistence of the colony.",
keywords = "brood care, colony dynamics, Division of labor, egg cannibalism, evolutionary dynamics, stage-structure model",
author = "Marisabel Rodriguez-Rodriguez and Yun Kang",
year = "2016",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/nrm.12119",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "29",
pages = "633--662",
journal = "Natural Resource Modelling",
issn = "0890-8575",
publisher = "Rocky Mountain Mathematics Consortium",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Colony and evolutionary dynamics of a two-stage model with brood cannibalism and division of labor in social insects

AU - Rodriguez-Rodriguez, Marisabel

AU - Kang, Yun

PY - 2016/11/1

Y1 - 2016/11/1

N2 - Division of labor (DOL) is a major factor for the great success of social insects because it increases the efficiency of a social group where different individuals perform different tasks repeatedly and presumably with increased performance. Cannibalism plays an important role in regulating colony growth and development by regulating the number of individuals in a colony and increasing survival by providing access to essential nutrients and minimizing competition among colony mates. To understand the synergy effects of DOL and cannibalistic behavior on colony dynamic outcomes, we propose and study a compartmental two-stage model using ecological and evolutionary game theory settings. Our analytical results of the ecological and evolutionary models suggest that: (1) A noncannibalistic colony can survive if the efficiency of energy investment reflecting the DOL is greater than the relative death rate of the older population. (2) A cannibalistic colony can die out if both the efficiency of energy investment and the relative cannibalism rate (where each is also reflecting the DOL) are too large; or if the relative cannibalism rate alone is too small. (3) From our numerical analysis, cannibalism can increase or reduce the colony's total population size, which greatly depends on the benefit of egg cannibalism increasing or decreasing of adult's lifespan. (4) A cannibalistic and noncannibalistic colony can experience bistability due to cooperative behavior. (5) In the evolutionary settings, DOL can prevent colony death and natural selection can preserve strong Allee effects by selecting the traits with the largest investment on brood care and the lowest cannibalism rate. (6) Evolutionary dynamics may increase the fitness of the colony, i.e., the successful production of workforce which results in the increase of total worker population size, colony survival, and reproduction. Our results suggest both cannibalism and DOLs are adaptive strategies that increase the size of the worker population, and therefore, persistence of the colony.

AB - Division of labor (DOL) is a major factor for the great success of social insects because it increases the efficiency of a social group where different individuals perform different tasks repeatedly and presumably with increased performance. Cannibalism plays an important role in regulating colony growth and development by regulating the number of individuals in a colony and increasing survival by providing access to essential nutrients and minimizing competition among colony mates. To understand the synergy effects of DOL and cannibalistic behavior on colony dynamic outcomes, we propose and study a compartmental two-stage model using ecological and evolutionary game theory settings. Our analytical results of the ecological and evolutionary models suggest that: (1) A noncannibalistic colony can survive if the efficiency of energy investment reflecting the DOL is greater than the relative death rate of the older population. (2) A cannibalistic colony can die out if both the efficiency of energy investment and the relative cannibalism rate (where each is also reflecting the DOL) are too large; or if the relative cannibalism rate alone is too small. (3) From our numerical analysis, cannibalism can increase or reduce the colony's total population size, which greatly depends on the benefit of egg cannibalism increasing or decreasing of adult's lifespan. (4) A cannibalistic and noncannibalistic colony can experience bistability due to cooperative behavior. (5) In the evolutionary settings, DOL can prevent colony death and natural selection can preserve strong Allee effects by selecting the traits with the largest investment on brood care and the lowest cannibalism rate. (6) Evolutionary dynamics may increase the fitness of the colony, i.e., the successful production of workforce which results in the increase of total worker population size, colony survival, and reproduction. Our results suggest both cannibalism and DOLs are adaptive strategies that increase the size of the worker population, and therefore, persistence of the colony.

KW - brood care

KW - colony dynamics

KW - Division of labor

KW - egg cannibalism

KW - evolutionary dynamics

KW - stage-structure model

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84995403913&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84995403913&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/nrm.12119

DO - 10.1111/nrm.12119

M3 - Article

VL - 29

SP - 633

EP - 662

JO - Natural Resource Modelling

JF - Natural Resource Modelling

SN - 0890-8575

IS - 4

ER -