TY - JOUR
T1 - Boron isotope composition of secondary smectite in suevites at the Ries crater, Germany
T2 - Boron fractionation in weathering and hydrothermal processes
AU - Muttik, Nele
AU - Kirsimäe, Kalle
AU - Newsom, Horton E.
AU - Williams, Lynda
N1 - Funding Information:
The research was financially supported by the NASA Planetary Geology and Geophysics grant NNH07DA001N , Estonian Science Foundation Grant No. 6795 and Target Financing grant SF0180069s08 . Authors would like to thank Gisela Pösges (ZERIN) for providing core samples from the Nördlingen 1973 drill core, also Klaus Franzreb for his kind help in Cameca 3f secondary ion mass spectrometer (SIMS) laboratory at Arizona State University. Authors are grateful to reviewers Horst Marschall and Christian Koeberl for critical reading and the most helpful comments to the paper.
PY - 2011/10/15
Y1 - 2011/10/15
N2 - The 24-km diameter Ries crater, in Germany, is one of the best-preserved terrestrial complex impact structure and clay minerals in the groundmass of the Ries suevites have been recognized for several decades. It is generally accepted that these clays were formed by post-impact aqueous alteration of impact-generated glasses and/or finely comminuted crystalline basement material at temperatures above ambient conditions. The Ries impact structure provides a good opportunity to study the evolution of post-impact development of impact craters. Here we present a study of boron isotopic compositions (δ11B) and B concentrations of the secondary smectite clay fraction in fall-out and crater suevites from the Ries crater (Germany). These data were used to study the boron fractionation in clay mineral precipitation processes and to model, using B-isotope fractionation, the characteristics (pH, temperature, and salinity) of fluids during fluid-rock interaction at different positions within the crater.The results of this study show that the boron isotopic composition of smectite in fall-out suevites sampled from 4 different locations (average -24.5±1.8%) was significantly different from that of the smectite in crater suevites sampled from the Nördlingen 1973 drill core at different depth intervals, from 370m to 525m (average -4.07%). Similarly, the δ11B composition of the fluids responsible for the alteration calculated from smectite isotopic composition in the fall-out suevites (+7.5±1.6%), differed from the alteration fluid composition in crater suevites (+17.6±10.8%); indicating a different origin of the fluids responsible for the alteration of the fall-out and crater suevites in the Ries crater. Our results suggest that the alteration in fall-out suevites occurred at lower temperatures than the crater suevites and at a lower pH, which is consistent with the smectite precipitation in equilibrium with meteoritic fluids. The boron isotopic composition of smectite in the crater suevites, suggests secondary clay formation at higher temperatures and/or at elevated pH (>8-9).Low δ11B values of fixed boron in secondary smectite in fall-out suevites suggests that B was incorporated into the mineral structure during the precipitation of authigenic smectite; whereas the smectite precipitated in equilibrium with the boron and hydrogen isotopic composition in the meteoric water that percolated through the system.Our study provides new constraints on the origin and evolution of the (geothermal) fluids that were involved in the formation of altered minerals at the Ries crater and suggests that boron isotope composition studies of the secondary clay phases associated with post-impact cooling may have important implications for the changes in fluid flow and changes in geochemical signatures of the fluids, and provide new constraints on fluid/rock interaction and mass transport during the cooling of the impact crater.
AB - The 24-km diameter Ries crater, in Germany, is one of the best-preserved terrestrial complex impact structure and clay minerals in the groundmass of the Ries suevites have been recognized for several decades. It is generally accepted that these clays were formed by post-impact aqueous alteration of impact-generated glasses and/or finely comminuted crystalline basement material at temperatures above ambient conditions. The Ries impact structure provides a good opportunity to study the evolution of post-impact development of impact craters. Here we present a study of boron isotopic compositions (δ11B) and B concentrations of the secondary smectite clay fraction in fall-out and crater suevites from the Ries crater (Germany). These data were used to study the boron fractionation in clay mineral precipitation processes and to model, using B-isotope fractionation, the characteristics (pH, temperature, and salinity) of fluids during fluid-rock interaction at different positions within the crater.The results of this study show that the boron isotopic composition of smectite in fall-out suevites sampled from 4 different locations (average -24.5±1.8%) was significantly different from that of the smectite in crater suevites sampled from the Nördlingen 1973 drill core at different depth intervals, from 370m to 525m (average -4.07%). Similarly, the δ11B composition of the fluids responsible for the alteration calculated from smectite isotopic composition in the fall-out suevites (+7.5±1.6%), differed from the alteration fluid composition in crater suevites (+17.6±10.8%); indicating a different origin of the fluids responsible for the alteration of the fall-out and crater suevites in the Ries crater. Our results suggest that the alteration in fall-out suevites occurred at lower temperatures than the crater suevites and at a lower pH, which is consistent with the smectite precipitation in equilibrium with meteoritic fluids. The boron isotopic composition of smectite in the crater suevites, suggests secondary clay formation at higher temperatures and/or at elevated pH (>8-9).Low δ11B values of fixed boron in secondary smectite in fall-out suevites suggests that B was incorporated into the mineral structure during the precipitation of authigenic smectite; whereas the smectite precipitated in equilibrium with the boron and hydrogen isotopic composition in the meteoric water that percolated through the system.Our study provides new constraints on the origin and evolution of the (geothermal) fluids that were involved in the formation of altered minerals at the Ries crater and suggests that boron isotope composition studies of the secondary clay phases associated with post-impact cooling may have important implications for the changes in fluid flow and changes in geochemical signatures of the fluids, and provide new constraints on fluid/rock interaction and mass transport during the cooling of the impact crater.
KW - Alteration fluids
KW - Boron isotope composition
KW - Hydrothermal alteration
KW - Ries crater
KW - Smectite
KW - Suevite
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=80053371122&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=80053371122&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.epsl.2011.08.028
DO - 10.1016/j.epsl.2011.08.028
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:80053371122
SN - 0012-821X
VL - 310
SP - 244
EP - 251
JO - Earth and Planetary Sciences Letters
JF - Earth and Planetary Sciences Letters
IS - 3-4
ER -