Artful and contorted coordinating: The ramifications of imposing formal logics of task jurisdiction on situated practice

Kathleen Pine, Melissa Mazmanian

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

9 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Ongoing coordination is the backbone of work process and organizational effectiveness. Coordinating requires that interdependent specialists achieve integrating conditions for coordination - including understanding who is accountable for carrying out a given task, how a sequence of actions should proceed, and how one's work fits into the whole on an ongoing basis. Navigating the inevitable disconnect between formal logics of action and the specifics of the local context and situation at hand is a hallmark of effective coordinating. Nevertheless, as work systems designed to direct action with a heavy hand are increasingly implemented in organizations, the disconnect between formal delineations and situated practice is transformed with large negative consequences for organizations. Through 16 months of empirical research using ethnographic methods surrounding implementation of an electronic health records (EHR) system in a hospital obstetric unit, we find that the EHR rendered what was once a productive disconnect between formal logics and situated practice into an unproductive disconnect. Further, this shift engendered a new form of ongoing coordinating. What was once "artful coordinating" - in which clinicians across occupations drew upon formal logics, local context, and situated contingencies as resources to action and, in so doing, created conditions of predictability and informal accountability - became "contorted coordinating," characterized by working around formal logics of the EHR while struggling to meet the demands of local context and situated contingencies, thus undermining predictability.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)720-742
Number of pages23
JournalAcademy of Management Journal
Volume60
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 1 2017

Fingerprint

Formal logic
Health
Obstetrics
Logic
Jurisdiction
Electronic health record
Predictability
Contingency

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Business and International Management
  • Business, Management and Accounting(all)
  • Strategy and Management
  • Management of Technology and Innovation

Cite this

Artful and contorted coordinating : The ramifications of imposing formal logics of task jurisdiction on situated practice. / Pine, Kathleen; Mazmanian, Melissa.

In: Academy of Management Journal, Vol. 60, No. 2, 01.04.2017, p. 720-742.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{ac55dafcd1654f61b180e4d3d044db3b,
title = "Artful and contorted coordinating: The ramifications of imposing formal logics of task jurisdiction on situated practice",
abstract = "Ongoing coordination is the backbone of work process and organizational effectiveness. Coordinating requires that interdependent specialists achieve integrating conditions for coordination - including understanding who is accountable for carrying out a given task, how a sequence of actions should proceed, and how one's work fits into the whole on an ongoing basis. Navigating the inevitable disconnect between formal logics of action and the specifics of the local context and situation at hand is a hallmark of effective coordinating. Nevertheless, as work systems designed to direct action with a heavy hand are increasingly implemented in organizations, the disconnect between formal delineations and situated practice is transformed with large negative consequences for organizations. Through 16 months of empirical research using ethnographic methods surrounding implementation of an electronic health records (EHR) system in a hospital obstetric unit, we find that the EHR rendered what was once a productive disconnect between formal logics and situated practice into an unproductive disconnect. Further, this shift engendered a new form of ongoing coordinating. What was once {"}artful coordinating{"} - in which clinicians across occupations drew upon formal logics, local context, and situated contingencies as resources to action and, in so doing, created conditions of predictability and informal accountability - became {"}contorted coordinating,{"} characterized by working around formal logics of the EHR while struggling to meet the demands of local context and situated contingencies, thus undermining predictability.",
author = "Kathleen Pine and Melissa Mazmanian",
year = "2017",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.5465/amj.2014.0315",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "60",
pages = "720--742",
journal = "Academy of Management Journal",
issn = "0001-4273",
publisher = "Academy of Management",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Artful and contorted coordinating

T2 - The ramifications of imposing formal logics of task jurisdiction on situated practice

AU - Pine, Kathleen

AU - Mazmanian, Melissa

PY - 2017/4/1

Y1 - 2017/4/1

N2 - Ongoing coordination is the backbone of work process and organizational effectiveness. Coordinating requires that interdependent specialists achieve integrating conditions for coordination - including understanding who is accountable for carrying out a given task, how a sequence of actions should proceed, and how one's work fits into the whole on an ongoing basis. Navigating the inevitable disconnect between formal logics of action and the specifics of the local context and situation at hand is a hallmark of effective coordinating. Nevertheless, as work systems designed to direct action with a heavy hand are increasingly implemented in organizations, the disconnect between formal delineations and situated practice is transformed with large negative consequences for organizations. Through 16 months of empirical research using ethnographic methods surrounding implementation of an electronic health records (EHR) system in a hospital obstetric unit, we find that the EHR rendered what was once a productive disconnect between formal logics and situated practice into an unproductive disconnect. Further, this shift engendered a new form of ongoing coordinating. What was once "artful coordinating" - in which clinicians across occupations drew upon formal logics, local context, and situated contingencies as resources to action and, in so doing, created conditions of predictability and informal accountability - became "contorted coordinating," characterized by working around formal logics of the EHR while struggling to meet the demands of local context and situated contingencies, thus undermining predictability.

AB - Ongoing coordination is the backbone of work process and organizational effectiveness. Coordinating requires that interdependent specialists achieve integrating conditions for coordination - including understanding who is accountable for carrying out a given task, how a sequence of actions should proceed, and how one's work fits into the whole on an ongoing basis. Navigating the inevitable disconnect between formal logics of action and the specifics of the local context and situation at hand is a hallmark of effective coordinating. Nevertheless, as work systems designed to direct action with a heavy hand are increasingly implemented in organizations, the disconnect between formal delineations and situated practice is transformed with large negative consequences for organizations. Through 16 months of empirical research using ethnographic methods surrounding implementation of an electronic health records (EHR) system in a hospital obstetric unit, we find that the EHR rendered what was once a productive disconnect between formal logics and situated practice into an unproductive disconnect. Further, this shift engendered a new form of ongoing coordinating. What was once "artful coordinating" - in which clinicians across occupations drew upon formal logics, local context, and situated contingencies as resources to action and, in so doing, created conditions of predictability and informal accountability - became "contorted coordinating," characterized by working around formal logics of the EHR while struggling to meet the demands of local context and situated contingencies, thus undermining predictability.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85018303188&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85018303188&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.5465/amj.2014.0315

DO - 10.5465/amj.2014.0315

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85018303188

VL - 60

SP - 720

EP - 742

JO - Academy of Management Journal

JF - Academy of Management Journal

SN - 0001-4273

IS - 2

ER -