Are Mixed Economies Persistent or Transitional? Evidence Using Social Networks from Arctic Alaska

Shauna BurnSilver, James Magdanz, Rhian Stotts, Matthew Berman, Gary Kofinas

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

33 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Two opposing narratives describe future prospects for mixed economic livelihoods in Alaska and the broader Arctic. On the one hand, Arctic anthropologists have written about the emergence of persistent mixed economies in Native communities. A second narrative echoes modernization assumptions and assumes that "subsistence is dying," mixed economies are transitional, and Native communities are headed inevitably toward full market dependence. We provide evidence that mixed economies are not transitional. Mixed economies have three components: households engage in (1) market exchange, (2) subsistence activities, and (3) culturally embedded social relationships sustained by flows of wild food and other resources. Using household-level social network and economic data from two Iñupiat communities spanning 30 years, we explore hypotheses designed to test an assumed transition to market dependence. If transition assumptions hold, households with high engagement in the cash economy will have low engagement in subsistence production and diminished social relationships. Results do not support this narrative of change. Although there is considerable variability in household harvest, income, and social relationships, those highly engaged in market activities are also disproportionately involved in subsistence activities, sharing, and cooperation. Beyond broad narratives, an assessment of underlying processes and conditions supporting persistent mixed economies is warranted.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)121-129
Number of pages9
JournalAmerican Anthropologist
Volume118
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1 2016

Fingerprint

Arctic
social network
economy
evidence
narrative
market
community
household income
dying
social economics
livelihood
Economy
Social Networks
modernization
food
Subsistence
Household
resources
economics
Social Relationships

Keywords

  • Arctic
  • Cash economy
  • Mixed economies
  • Social networks
  • Subsistence hunting

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Arts and Humanities (miscellaneous)
  • Anthropology

Cite this

Are Mixed Economies Persistent or Transitional? Evidence Using Social Networks from Arctic Alaska. / BurnSilver, Shauna; Magdanz, James; Stotts, Rhian; Berman, Matthew; Kofinas, Gary.

In: American Anthropologist, Vol. 118, No. 1, 01.03.2016, p. 121-129.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

BurnSilver, Shauna ; Magdanz, James ; Stotts, Rhian ; Berman, Matthew ; Kofinas, Gary. / Are Mixed Economies Persistent or Transitional? Evidence Using Social Networks from Arctic Alaska. In: American Anthropologist. 2016 ; Vol. 118, No. 1. pp. 121-129.
@article{d604dbbf6337441bacfa7793ffc4c908,
title = "Are Mixed Economies Persistent or Transitional? Evidence Using Social Networks from Arctic Alaska",
abstract = "Two opposing narratives describe future prospects for mixed economic livelihoods in Alaska and the broader Arctic. On the one hand, Arctic anthropologists have written about the emergence of persistent mixed economies in Native communities. A second narrative echoes modernization assumptions and assumes that {"}subsistence is dying,{"} mixed economies are transitional, and Native communities are headed inevitably toward full market dependence. We provide evidence that mixed economies are not transitional. Mixed economies have three components: households engage in (1) market exchange, (2) subsistence activities, and (3) culturally embedded social relationships sustained by flows of wild food and other resources. Using household-level social network and economic data from two I{\~n}upiat communities spanning 30 years, we explore hypotheses designed to test an assumed transition to market dependence. If transition assumptions hold, households with high engagement in the cash economy will have low engagement in subsistence production and diminished social relationships. Results do not support this narrative of change. Although there is considerable variability in household harvest, income, and social relationships, those highly engaged in market activities are also disproportionately involved in subsistence activities, sharing, and cooperation. Beyond broad narratives, an assessment of underlying processes and conditions supporting persistent mixed economies is warranted.",
keywords = "Arctic, Cash economy, Mixed economies, Social networks, Subsistence hunting",
author = "Shauna BurnSilver and James Magdanz and Rhian Stotts and Matthew Berman and Gary Kofinas",
year = "2016",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/aman.12447",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "118",
pages = "121--129",
journal = "American Anthropologist",
issn = "1548-1433",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Are Mixed Economies Persistent or Transitional? Evidence Using Social Networks from Arctic Alaska

AU - BurnSilver, Shauna

AU - Magdanz, James

AU - Stotts, Rhian

AU - Berman, Matthew

AU - Kofinas, Gary

PY - 2016/3/1

Y1 - 2016/3/1

N2 - Two opposing narratives describe future prospects for mixed economic livelihoods in Alaska and the broader Arctic. On the one hand, Arctic anthropologists have written about the emergence of persistent mixed economies in Native communities. A second narrative echoes modernization assumptions and assumes that "subsistence is dying," mixed economies are transitional, and Native communities are headed inevitably toward full market dependence. We provide evidence that mixed economies are not transitional. Mixed economies have three components: households engage in (1) market exchange, (2) subsistence activities, and (3) culturally embedded social relationships sustained by flows of wild food and other resources. Using household-level social network and economic data from two Iñupiat communities spanning 30 years, we explore hypotheses designed to test an assumed transition to market dependence. If transition assumptions hold, households with high engagement in the cash economy will have low engagement in subsistence production and diminished social relationships. Results do not support this narrative of change. Although there is considerable variability in household harvest, income, and social relationships, those highly engaged in market activities are also disproportionately involved in subsistence activities, sharing, and cooperation. Beyond broad narratives, an assessment of underlying processes and conditions supporting persistent mixed economies is warranted.

AB - Two opposing narratives describe future prospects for mixed economic livelihoods in Alaska and the broader Arctic. On the one hand, Arctic anthropologists have written about the emergence of persistent mixed economies in Native communities. A second narrative echoes modernization assumptions and assumes that "subsistence is dying," mixed economies are transitional, and Native communities are headed inevitably toward full market dependence. We provide evidence that mixed economies are not transitional. Mixed economies have three components: households engage in (1) market exchange, (2) subsistence activities, and (3) culturally embedded social relationships sustained by flows of wild food and other resources. Using household-level social network and economic data from two Iñupiat communities spanning 30 years, we explore hypotheses designed to test an assumed transition to market dependence. If transition assumptions hold, households with high engagement in the cash economy will have low engagement in subsistence production and diminished social relationships. Results do not support this narrative of change. Although there is considerable variability in household harvest, income, and social relationships, those highly engaged in market activities are also disproportionately involved in subsistence activities, sharing, and cooperation. Beyond broad narratives, an assessment of underlying processes and conditions supporting persistent mixed economies is warranted.

KW - Arctic

KW - Cash economy

KW - Mixed economies

KW - Social networks

KW - Subsistence hunting

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84962169542&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84962169542&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/aman.12447

DO - 10.1111/aman.12447

M3 - Article

VL - 118

SP - 121

EP - 129

JO - American Anthropologist

JF - American Anthropologist

SN - 1548-1433

IS - 1

ER -