Analysis of instructional support elements for an online, educational simulation on active listening for women graduate students in science and engineering

Bianca Bernstein, Jennifer Bekki, Kerrie G. Wilkins, Caroline J. Harrison

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Strong interpersonal communication skills (ICS) are critical for educational and career success, but effective and widely accessible training systems are not available. This paper describes a 2 × 2 × 2 experimental study of an online, educational simulation for practice with the ICS of active listening. The simulation was customized for women graduate students in the natural sciences and engineering. In such environments, where gender stereotyping is common, ICS can make the difference between continued progress and discouraging setbacks. The pedagogical effects of following three instructional support variables were investigated: (1) elaborative versus simple feedback (2) presence versus absence of a static image to accompany the content delivered aurally by a human pedagogical agent, and (3) presence versus absence of instructional hints. The four outcome measures were self-reported knowledge about, skill in applying, and self-efficacy with respect to active listening, along with the usability of the simulation itself. Participants in the study included N = 137 women in the natural sciences and engineering. Results showed that the instructional support variables were significantly related to the outcome measures of knowledge, skills, and usability, but not self-efficacy with respect to active listening. A three-way interaction among all three of the instructional support variables was found to be statistically significant for both the knowledge and skills outcome variables; for both, the highest scores were obtained by participants who were presented with elaborative feedback and neither pedagogical agent image nor hints. Also, participants who received elaborative feedback reported the simulation to have significantly greater usability than those who received simple feedback.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)136-171
Number of pages36
JournalJournal of Computing in Higher Education
Volume28
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Aug 1 2016

Fingerprint

interpersonal communication
communication skills
graduate
engineering
simulation
natural sciences
science
self-efficacy
student
career
gender
interaction

Keywords

  • Active listening
  • Elaborative feedback
  • Graduate women in STEM
  • Hints
  • Interpersonal communication skills
  • Online educational simulation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education

Cite this

@article{9633de483649470da86f9259abdb47d0,
title = "Analysis of instructional support elements for an online, educational simulation on active listening for women graduate students in science and engineering",
abstract = "Strong interpersonal communication skills (ICS) are critical for educational and career success, but effective and widely accessible training systems are not available. This paper describes a 2 × 2 × 2 experimental study of an online, educational simulation for practice with the ICS of active listening. The simulation was customized for women graduate students in the natural sciences and engineering. In such environments, where gender stereotyping is common, ICS can make the difference between continued progress and discouraging setbacks. The pedagogical effects of following three instructional support variables were investigated: (1) elaborative versus simple feedback (2) presence versus absence of a static image to accompany the content delivered aurally by a human pedagogical agent, and (3) presence versus absence of instructional hints. The four outcome measures were self-reported knowledge about, skill in applying, and self-efficacy with respect to active listening, along with the usability of the simulation itself. Participants in the study included N = 137 women in the natural sciences and engineering. Results showed that the instructional support variables were significantly related to the outcome measures of knowledge, skills, and usability, but not self-efficacy with respect to active listening. A three-way interaction among all three of the instructional support variables was found to be statistically significant for both the knowledge and skills outcome variables; for both, the highest scores were obtained by participants who were presented with elaborative feedback and neither pedagogical agent image nor hints. Also, participants who received elaborative feedback reported the simulation to have significantly greater usability than those who received simple feedback.",
keywords = "Active listening, Elaborative feedback, Graduate women in STEM, Hints, Interpersonal communication skills, Online educational simulation",
author = "Bianca Bernstein and Jennifer Bekki and Wilkins, {Kerrie G.} and Harrison, {Caroline J.}",
year = "2016",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s12528-016-9110-4",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "28",
pages = "136--171",
journal = "Journal of Computing in Higher Education",
issn = "1042-1726",
publisher = "Paideia Publishers",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Analysis of instructional support elements for an online, educational simulation on active listening for women graduate students in science and engineering

AU - Bernstein, Bianca

AU - Bekki, Jennifer

AU - Wilkins, Kerrie G.

AU - Harrison, Caroline J.

PY - 2016/8/1

Y1 - 2016/8/1

N2 - Strong interpersonal communication skills (ICS) are critical for educational and career success, but effective and widely accessible training systems are not available. This paper describes a 2 × 2 × 2 experimental study of an online, educational simulation for practice with the ICS of active listening. The simulation was customized for women graduate students in the natural sciences and engineering. In such environments, where gender stereotyping is common, ICS can make the difference between continued progress and discouraging setbacks. The pedagogical effects of following three instructional support variables were investigated: (1) elaborative versus simple feedback (2) presence versus absence of a static image to accompany the content delivered aurally by a human pedagogical agent, and (3) presence versus absence of instructional hints. The four outcome measures were self-reported knowledge about, skill in applying, and self-efficacy with respect to active listening, along with the usability of the simulation itself. Participants in the study included N = 137 women in the natural sciences and engineering. Results showed that the instructional support variables were significantly related to the outcome measures of knowledge, skills, and usability, but not self-efficacy with respect to active listening. A three-way interaction among all three of the instructional support variables was found to be statistically significant for both the knowledge and skills outcome variables; for both, the highest scores were obtained by participants who were presented with elaborative feedback and neither pedagogical agent image nor hints. Also, participants who received elaborative feedback reported the simulation to have significantly greater usability than those who received simple feedback.

AB - Strong interpersonal communication skills (ICS) are critical for educational and career success, but effective and widely accessible training systems are not available. This paper describes a 2 × 2 × 2 experimental study of an online, educational simulation for practice with the ICS of active listening. The simulation was customized for women graduate students in the natural sciences and engineering. In such environments, where gender stereotyping is common, ICS can make the difference between continued progress and discouraging setbacks. The pedagogical effects of following three instructional support variables were investigated: (1) elaborative versus simple feedback (2) presence versus absence of a static image to accompany the content delivered aurally by a human pedagogical agent, and (3) presence versus absence of instructional hints. The four outcome measures were self-reported knowledge about, skill in applying, and self-efficacy with respect to active listening, along with the usability of the simulation itself. Participants in the study included N = 137 women in the natural sciences and engineering. Results showed that the instructional support variables were significantly related to the outcome measures of knowledge, skills, and usability, but not self-efficacy with respect to active listening. A three-way interaction among all three of the instructional support variables was found to be statistically significant for both the knowledge and skills outcome variables; for both, the highest scores were obtained by participants who were presented with elaborative feedback and neither pedagogical agent image nor hints. Also, participants who received elaborative feedback reported the simulation to have significantly greater usability than those who received simple feedback.

KW - Active listening

KW - Elaborative feedback

KW - Graduate women in STEM

KW - Hints

KW - Interpersonal communication skills

KW - Online educational simulation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84978139618&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84978139618&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s12528-016-9110-4

DO - 10.1007/s12528-016-9110-4

M3 - Article

VL - 28

SP - 136

EP - 171

JO - Journal of Computing in Higher Education

JF - Journal of Computing in Higher Education

SN - 1042-1726

IS - 2

ER -